Wookieepedia:Trash compactor/SuperShadow (third nomination)

Technically, this is the fourth nomination, as it was also previously done under the votes for deletion. While once a featured article, I don't think now it even meets the requirements for a good article. Things have changed a lot since 2010, when the article was last placed in the trash compactor, which ended as no consensus. As follows:


 * Does the article or subject have any reference to Star Wars canon or provide any material that might be interest to Star Wars projects?: No. Not only does it have nothing to do with Star Wars canon, it was specifically denounced as containing false material unauthorized by Lucasfilm.


 * Does the article meet the notability requirements?: It fails the content requirement on two counts. First, it no longer exists and is only available through an archive. Second, even when it did exist, the content was of marginal interest since it was fictitious. The recognition requirement is the only possible lifeline that I see. The site was briefly acknowledged by Lucasfilm / Pablo Hidalgo, only to state that it was not in any way officially sanctioned. If there was any mainstream media recognition, I'm not aware of it. And whatever fan recognition there may must have been, if it was ever enough to meet high standards of evidence, is gone now. The site is toast. Rumors from SuperShadow are not circulating anymore, the site is well forgotten.

Delete

 * 1) And end this shadow over the Star Wars galaxy. ProfessorTofty (talk) 10:14, November 1, 2014 (UTC)