Wookieepedia:EduCorps/Meeting 13/Log

[23:00:40] 	All right, welcome to the meeting everyone. [23:01:04] 	Would you like to start off with your proposal SE? [23:01:37] 	ill do it after the articles, just got back to the room and have a few things to get ready first [23:01:44] 	thanks though [23:01:51] 	Okay, works for me. [23:02:06] 	Starting with the old articles. [23:02:29] 	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Anj%27a [23:02:36] 	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Anj%27a [23:02:52] 	This is the one with the unsourced stuff in the BTS. [23:03:01] 	Which is still unsourced after the extension. [23:03:16] 	Kill [23:03:26] 	kill [23:03:38] 	Ex-ter-me-nate [23:03:39] 	Kill from Ayrehead and dogma [23:03:59] 	Cade? [23:04:44] 	An'ja killed. [23:05:20] 	Next up is http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Rseikharhl [23:05:47] 	I plan on finishing this at some point, but I have other stuff I need to take care of first. [23:05:57] 	It is nowhere near CA length. [23:06:08] 	Let's kill this. [23:06:11] 	kill for sure [23:06:27] 	dogma and Ayrehead vote kill [23:06:31] 	Yep, kill [23:07:01] 	Rseikharhl killed. [23:07:24] 	Next: http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Unidentified_scout_trooper_%28Dardano%27s_bodyguard%29 [23:07:31] 	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Unidentified_scout_trooper_%28Dardano%27s_bodyguard%29 [23:07:43] 	The issue here was determining what needed to be placed in RPG tags. [23:07:53] 	As nothing has been done, I vote kill. [23:08:25] 	I'd be fine with extending it. Give Hanzo/Lee/me time to play the game. [23:08:50] 	No one has touched it in almost two months. [23:09:12] 	Or close to three if you discount dogma adding the cleanup tag [23:10:02] 	I don't think anyone is paying attention to this anymore. [23:10:24] 	i vote kill [23:10:27] 	Ah. Better kill it then. [23:10:37] 	2 months is plenty of time for someone to look at it [23:10:52] 	dogma and Ayrehead vote kill [23:11:07] 	Unidentified scout trooper killed [23:11:34] 	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Unidentified_speeder_%28Grand_Army_of_the_Republic%29 [23:11:46] 	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Unidentified_speeder_%28Grand_Army_of_the_Republic%29 [23:12:01] 	I'm not sure exactly what is going on with this one, but it still isn't updated. [23:12:51] 	I can update it, but the problem is its called a BARC speeder when it....isn't [23:13:16] 	if the source says it is, there really isnt anything we can do but call it a BARC [23:13:28] 	Hmmm, a two person BARC? [23:13:48] 	modified perhaps [23:13:55] 	Oh, sorry, didn't know we started [23:14:13] 	If you want to try and work things out, I will vote to extend this one. [23:14:32] 	ill extend if CP wants to take it on [23:14:37] 	Sure [23:14:45] <Calrayn>	Extend [23:14:56] 	Okay, dogma and Ayrehead vote extend if someone wants to take it on. [23:15:07] 	Speeder thingy extended [23:15:27] 	Now onto the new articles [23:15:48] 	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Aaghra [23:16:17] 	The issue with this article and the rest on the agenda today is that they include extraploation based off of the Atlas maps. [23:16:34] 	*extrapolation [23:16:51] <Calrayn>	I vote probe on all of these [23:17:02] 	The history section here falls into that category. [23:17:16] <Supreme_Emperor>	probe all [23:17:22] 	Each one needs to be checked individually to see if it applies. [23:17:42] <Supreme_Emperor>	ah [23:17:42] <Calrayn>	Alright. [23:17:55] 	But if we all agree we can just probe the lot and see which ones have been checked before the next meeting. [23:18:06] <CorellianPremier>	Definitely, that's the best option [23:18:09] <Calrayn>	I think that's probably best. [23:18:10] <Supreme_Emperor>	i'm good with that [23:18:40] 	Alright then, probe all of the planet articles [23:19:14] 	Well, that is all for articles to review. [23:19:26] 	Are you ready for your proposal now SE? [23:20:59] <Supreme_Emperor>	i am, give me one second [23:21:16] 	Sure [23:21:22] <Supreme_Emperor>	Alright [23:21:37] *	dogma (cced66c2@wookieepedia/dogma) has joined [23:21:37] *	ChanServ gives channel operator status to dogma [23:21:46] *	dogma does a flyby [23:21:48] <Supreme_Emperor>	In the last few months, I have noticed a disturbing trend, in which people are mass nominating large amounts of articles at once [23:22:16] <Supreme_Emperor>	in some cases, over 10 at once [23:22:42] <Supreme_Emperor>	i feel that nobody needs this many articles nominated at once, and that having that many noms at once can lower their overall quality [23:22:47] <Supreme_Emperor>	therefore, i propose this [23:22:49] <Supreme_Emperor>	http://supreme-emperor-test.wikia.com/wiki/CAN_limit_proposal [23:22:54] <Supreme_Emperor>	i'll give everyone a minute to read that over [23:24:07] <Calrayn>	^ [23:24:08] <Calrayn>	Yes [23:24:10] 	I support the idea of the limit, and contrary to what I believed before, 4 noms should be a decent amount due to how fast they are passed [23:24:44] *	dogma flies out [23:24:46] 	Yeah, a CAN should ideally pass within a week. [23:24:47] *	dogma (cced66c2@wookieepedia/dogma) has left [23:25:01] <Supreme_Emperor>	i believe this will help improve quality and overall help the CAN move smoother [23:25:58] <Supreme_Emperor>	Ayre also said in his notes that he supports a limit [23:27:08] 	I support having a 4 CAN limit. [23:27:37] <Supreme_Emperor>	is everyone else alright with a 4 nom limit? [23:27:54] <CorellianPremier>	I think six would be better, it is not as limiting and still gives us time to check them out. [23:27:59] <Calrayn>	No [23:28:25] <Calrayn>	Particularly not with the quality of nominations and frankly, the quality of quite a few reviews [23:28:58] <Calrayn>	CANs should be treated as GANs [23:29:13] <Calrayn>	There's no reason someone should have more CANs than GANs [23:29:17] <Supreme_Emperor>	^ [23:31:14] <Calrayn>	So, let's vote [23:31:20] <Calrayn>	I support. [23:31:30] <CorellianPremier>	~support [23:31:31] 	I support. [23:32:01] 	dogma voiced his support earlier [23:32:04] <Supreme_Emperor>	support [23:32:08] <Supreme_Emperor>	Ayre also supports [23:32:11] <Calrayn>	Then it passes. [23:32:43] <Supreme_Emperor>	excellent [23:32:57] 	Even MJ agrees that a CT is not really necessary here, so we now have a limit. [23:33:15] <Supreme_Emperor>	excellent [23:33:48] <Supreme_Emperor>	i should be able to update the CAN page later tonight [23:34:44] 	So, looking at the scheduling, dogma is on scheduling and Corellian Premier is on paperwork. [23:35:41] 	I will post the log in a minute or so, thanks for coming people.