Forum:CT Archive/Jack Nebulax

This thread is intended to work sort of like Wikipedia's requests for arbitration page. Except we don't have a designated arbitration committee and probably won't. Instead, all Wookieepedians are welcome to state their opinions. The final decision will be discussed by the admins collectively.

We're going through this because I think that we should not unilaterally permablock long-term contributors without prior discussion.

What is needed:
 * 1) Objective evidence of his disruptive behavior.
 * 2) Objective evidence that all other means of dispute resolution have been tried and failed.
 * 3) Public comments from Jack himself, directed at no specific users but at the Wookieepedia community in general.

Whatever the final community decision is, I will respect it, and I urge other administrators to respect it as well.

I ask other admins for cooperation rather than unilateral action, regardless of their views on the matter. We're talking about a long-term contributor here, and permablock is, effectively, "capital punishment" that, I feel, should not be applied to long-term contributors. If you believe that I'm abusing my power by starting this public process... go ahead, delete this thread and put me on RFRA. I won't object. It will only mean that a compromise of any sort has completely and utterly failed.

- Sikon 04:14, 20 June 2007 (UTC)