Forum:CT Archive/Blatant C-Canon contradiction of older C-Canon

Wookieepedia &gt; Consensus track &gt; 

When we get a case of C-Canon blatantly disregarding previously established C-Canon, I propose that we consider the new material non-canon, or put some sort of tag on it to identify that the information's canonicity is dubious, unless: This initiative should only occur when no tangible reason can exsist to explain the two conflicting stories.
 * The new material has been designed to retcon the previous material
 * The old material's canonicity is weak at best
 * The new material is closer tied to G-canon.

I give you two examples.
 * The capture of Shuttle Tydirium, where Star Wars: Rogue Squadron II: Rogue Leader blatantly contradicts X-Wing Alliance, an older source.
 * The well-known Labyrinth of Evil vs Clone Wars contradiction. Where LOE should trump Clone Wars.