Wookieepedia:AC/Meeting Five

Wookieepedia &gt; AgriCorps &gt; 

"I killed them. I killed them all. They're dead, every single one of them. And not just the men&hellip;but the women, and the children, too. They're like animals! And I slaughtered them like animals! I hate them!"

- Anakin Skywalker reveals his feelings toward poor Good articles

Get ready, AC members, for Meeting Five. This meetings marks the beginning of our review of Character articles. Because there are so many, we're going to have to divide the Character review into two or even three meetings. We're holding this meeting back on our original time, Sunday afternoon, Jan. 18th, 4 PM EST for North American users. Please do your best to show up. If you cannot show up, we highly encourage you to still leave your mark in the Notes section below. You can still leave your two cents on the articles being looked at, which will be taken into consideration at the meeting.

Probed articles
Voting on whether or not to strip the probed articles from Meeting Four:


 * Battle of Balmorra (Second Galactic Civil War)
 * Duel in the Chancellor's Office
 * Duel in the Senate (Great Jedi Purge)
 * Duel on Roqoo Depot
 * Mandalorian Wars
 * Massacre at Ossus
 * New Sith Wars
 * Operation: Knightfall
 * Skirmish at Carkoon
 * Combined Clans Center Building
 * Exovar's Emporium
 * Fondor
 * Korriban
 * Ryloth
 * Taris
 * Taris dueling ring
 * Telos IV
 * Cloak of Deception

Character articles for review
Due to time constraints, I've limited this review to 25 Character articles. I ask that no one add anymore beyond the 25 limit. If some of these are handled and stricken before the meeting, feel free to add new articles in their place. Toprawa and Ralltiir 19:21, 31 December 2008 (UTC)


 * Hermione Bagwa - Unsourced infobox and biography items. No P/T. Everything just seems a little skimpy, especially the BTS. Probably not a huge fix, but it would definitely benefit from someone taking the time to improve this one.
 * Sio Bibble - Just a number of minor fixes. Unsourced infobox, references aren't all linked. The Fact Files should be more specific for an individual issue. Source list not in correct order.
 * Depa Billaba - Nothing is sourced.
 * Buboicullaar - Unsourced references for an easy fix. It seems like the biography could be fleshed out a little more, even for as short as his anthology story is, but maybe I'm wrong.
 * Xandel Carivus - Unsourced infobox and succession box. Should be easy enough for someone knowledgeable
 * Jorus C'baoth - I think this article does well to exemplify what a "broad-coverage GA" should be. Over 1,000 words, but not enough detail to be an FA. Still, some very minor infobox sourcing issues, and it should have a Powers and Abilities section.
 * Chaf'orm'bintrano - Needs a P/T.
 * Tsui Choi - Infobox and article sourcing issues. Could use a P/A, I assume?
 * Kaleb Darme - No P/T or BTS.
 * Samhan Dobo - I'm calling this one out for having information exclusive to the introduction, not found in the biography anywhere. A simple fix for someone knowledgeable.
 * Daultay Dofine - Weak sourcing
 * Dorsk 81 - Weak sourcing
 * Giles Durane - No sourcing
 * Durrei - No BTS. P/T and P/A?
 * Energizer Bunny - Some really poor speculation and OR. Serious MOS issues.
 * The Envoy - No sourcing. The BTS claims that it is unclear whether she's a Jedi, but the entire article treats her as one. Not so good.
 * Valenthyne Farfalla - Unsourced infobox, paragraph in the bio, succession box. No P/A section.
 * Melvin Fett - Unnecessary speculative bits that should be cleaned up.
 * Herrit - No P/T.
 * Tresk Im'nel - No P/T, BTS
 * Irek Ismaren - Lots of relics of a bygone era of article quality. No infobox sourcing, unlinked references, no P/T, no BTS.
 * Shimrra Jamaane - Unsourced infobox, fact tag, unsourced bio paragraph, unsourced succession box. "Physical appearance" section should be merged into the P/T per MOS. Unlinked references.
 * Jin-Jin - No BTS.
 * K'Kruhk - Serious sourcing issues.
 * Obi-Wan Kenobi impersonator - No sourcing, P/T, or BTS.

Sign me up

 * 1) I hope. Toprawa and Ralltiir 19:21, 31 December 2008 (UTC)