Forum:CT Archive/Proposal for approaching KotOR articles

This is an issue that I would like to discuss, and vote on, with my fellow Wookieepedians. I recently created an article called "Duel on Hrakert Station", which has since been moved to "Showdown with Darth Bandon", because it was stated that the exact order in which Revan traveled during his second search for the Star Forge has not been determined. I feel that we should list the order as this: "Tatooine–Kashyyyk–Manaan–Korriban". This is a controversial proposal at best, but I feel that it can work. We already go under the assumption that the Jedi Exile, from Telos, traveled to Nar Shaddaa, then Onderon/Dxun, then Dantooine, then back to Dxun/Onderon, and then Korriban. We should do no more, or less, for Revan. As Darth Culator points out here in the Senate Hall, the Knights of the Old Republic video game, in the cutscene where Revan's identity is revealed, has a flashback of Bastila Shan listing the planets in said order. Culator also points out that the game's dialogue files list the planets in this order, and the game's strategy guide recommends that one play in this order. Other than these three sources, there is no other source that explicitly states the order of the second search. I say we go under the assumption that Revan did travel in said order, until a canon source explicitly establishes a canonical path. A template could be created for this new policy. Remember, we also assume that the light-side, or least-dark-sided, choices are always correct, which is not always the case. Let me list two examples, in KotOR II, it was assumed that the Exile allowed Vaklu to live to stand trial. However, Vaklu's entry in The Complete Star Wars Encyclopedia states that the Exile let Queen Talia execute Vaklu. Not exactly a light-side choice, right? But it's canon, and that's what we, as Wookieepedia, have to go by. Another example is Sith apprentice Kel Algwinn and Revan. We assumed before the CSWE's release that Algwinn was redeemed by Revan. However, Algwinn's entry states that he was killed by Revan on Korriban after Uthar Wynn's death, making Algwinn's redemption, or the light-side choice, non-canon. I am asking that you consider my proposal carefully, and thank you, my fellow Wookieepedians, for your time and consideration.--Jedi Kasra (talk) 15:42, 25 August 2009 (UTC)

For proposal

 * 1) Jedi Kasra (talk) 15:42, 25 August 2009 (UTC)