Wookieepedia:Comprehensive article review

 From time to time, a comprehensive article may need to be reviewed and possibly stripped of its status.

Comprehensive article review rules
 * 1) Any user may nominate an article for removal. In order to do so, the user must place the Cacleanup template on the article in question and list grievances against the article on the review page. If no grievances are provided with the nomination, the nominating user should be contacted to ask for objections; the nomination may be deemed frivolous if no objections are provided within 48 hours. Frivolous removal nominations, defined as nominations without objections 48 hours after contacting the user or any nomination clearly made in bad faith without any remotely valid objections (e.g. "this guy doesn't deserve status because he's a jerk"), may be unilaterally removed by any EduCorps member or admin and should not be archived (this is to prevent users from repeatedly nominating the same article and clogging the milestones template on that article's talk page, as well as to deny recognition).''
 * 2) One week is allowed for objections to be addressed, after which EduCorps members will have five days to vote to keep or remove the article.
 * 3) The support of at least two EC members with less than two opposed is required to strip a CA of its status. Otherwise, the CA will be kept after the allotted time period.
 * 4) Refer to the CA instructions page on how to properly archive a CA review.

=Comprehensive articles for review=

Gunnery captain

 * Review comments: Currently sits at 260 words, and the nominator hasn't been around since last year

(+0)
Keep

Vote to remove (votes in this section are only allowed after one week on the review page)

Objections/grievances
 * 1) Exiled Jedi
 * 2) *Currently sits at 260 words.
 * 3) * CSWECite should be used on the Encyclopedia source.
 * 4) **This one is fixed (and probably should have been ed, given that the necessary information was already present in a reference). &mdash;MJ&mdash; Council Chambers Sunday, June 17, 2012, 17:32 UTC
 * 5) ***Sorry about that, I have no clue what I was thinking at the time.-- Exiled Jedi  Oldrepublic crest.svg (Greetings)  20:20, June 17, 2012 (UTC)
 * 6) *The Bolvan article has more sources and appearances than the gunnery officer article. Since Bolvan is not called a Gunnery captain anywhere but in the CSWE, perhaps more of his appearances should count for chief gunnery officer.-- Exiled Jedi  Oldrepublic crest.svg (Greetings)  17:19, June 17, 2012 (UTC)
 * 7) **With the exception of the few sources/appearances around the time of Shadows of the Empire, should all sources that mention Bolvan during the events of ANH be considered gunnery captain mentions too, since they made mention of him at the time of him being a gunnery captain? If so, then his source list needs additions. Hanzo Hasashi 04:56, June 18, 2012 (UTC)
 * 8) ***I'm not sure if this is the right thing to do, but it is consistent with how the article currently is. I think we should get some other opinions before adding more sources.-- Exiled Jedi  Oldrepublic crest.svg (Greetings)  18:23, June 25, 2012 (UTC)
 * 9) ****Nope, a mention of Bolvan isn't a mention of "gunnery captain" unless the title itself is mentioned, just as a mention of Bib Fortuna isn't a mention of Twi'lek. An appearance of Bolvan during the events of ANH, however, is an appearance of a gunnery captain, which already seems to be the case here. Menkooroo 18:29, June 25, 2012 (UTC)
 * 10) *****How about the Visual Guides, in which Bolvan is both mentioned and pictured? Hanzo Hasashi 18:58, June 25, 2012 (UTC)
 * 11) ******That sounds good. I think it would be despite the mention of Bolvan, as the title itself isn't mentioned. Menkooroo 19:16, June 25, 2012 (UTC)

Comments
 * This should probably go the GA page, but I do not have all of the sources so I will not be able to do it.-- Exiled Jedi  Oldrepublic crest.svg (Greetings)  17:19, June 17, 2012 (UTC)
 * Unfortunately, Darth Morrt has been reported missing and unheard from IRL since December, see his Facebook profile for reference. Hanzo Hasashi 05:06, June 18, 2012 (UTC)
 * Should be ready to nominate for GAN. I will do so after an upcoming vacation. Hanzo Hasashi (talk) 00:31, June 28, 2012 (UTC)

Wertram Garran

 * Review comments: Factual errors

(+0)
Keep

Vote to remove (votes in this section are only allowed after one week on the review page)
 * 1) No work has been done, so it is time to remove its status.-- Exiled Jedi  Oldrepublic crest.svg  (Greetings)  13:20, July 13, 2012 (UTC)

Objections/grievances
 * 1) A major factual error in this article has been brought to light in the SH and on the article talk page. See the post here for details. &mdash;MJ&mdash; War Room Wednesday, June 27, 2012, 02:23 UTC

Comments