Wookieepedia:AgriCorps/Log/2008 November 23

[15:04]		But AC Meeting Three is now underway. [15:05]		Thank you for those who decided to show up. [15:05]		:) [15:05]		B) [15:05]		Our first item of business is to decide on those articles probed in Meeting 2. [15:06]		http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Chevin [15:06]		First up [15:06]		http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Chevin&diff=2241424&oldid=2233271 [15:06]		Acky wanted it killed, so... [15:07]		It does seem skimpy, and it doesn't exactly conform to the LG. [15:07]		Someone (SD, I think) went in and reffed it correctly. [15:07]		I vote kill. [15:07]		But its coverage is not so great. [15:07]		Yes, kill it [15:07]		I say kill, and so will Greyman. [15:07]		Killed. [15:07]	<Toprawa>	Next: [15:08]	<Toprawa>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Eol_Sha_lichen [15:08]	<Toprawa>	I believe it's short of 250 words. [15:08]	<Graestan>	Kill. This will never make 250 words. Even if we dummyfied it. [15:08]	<ChackJadson>	Kill! [15:08]	<Toprawa>	Kill [15:08]	<Toprawa>	Killed. [15:08]	<Toprawa>	Next: [15:09]	<Toprawa>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Laze_Loneozner [15:09]	<Toprawa>	I don't think anything was done to it. [15:09]	<Toprawa>	Kill. [15:09]	<Graestan>	I removed that lame template. Kill. [15:09]	<ChackJadson>	Kill [15:09]	* Graestan	loves killing [15:10]	<Toprawa>	Killed. [15:10]	<Toprawa>	Next: [15:10]	<Toprawa>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Nemoidian [15:10]	<Graestan>	http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Neimoidian&diff=2251806&oldid=2233272 [15:10]	<Toprawa>	Severely unsourced still. [15:10]	<Toprawa>	Kill. [15:10]	<ChackJadson>	Kill [15:10]	<Graestan>	Skippy sourced the intro? [15:10]	<Graestan>	Kill. [15:11]	<Toprawa>	Killed. [15:11]	<Toprawa>	Next: [15:11]	<Toprawa>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Darth_Nihilus [15:11]	<Graestan>	http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Darth_Nihilus&diff=2246885&oldid=2233264 [15:11]	<Graestan>	Kill; no work was done. [15:11]	<Toprawa>	A bunch of things. [15:11]	<Toprawa>	Kill [15:11]	<ChackJadson>	Kill [15:11]	<Toprawa>	Killed. [15:12]	<Toprawa>	Next: [15:12]	<Toprawa>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Rainboh [15:12]	<Toprawa>	I don't know if it's 250 or not [15:12]	<ChackJadson>	It's been expanded to 261, I believe [15:12]	<Graestan>	Will never be long enough, unless we allow fanon. [15:12]	<Toprawa>	It looks like it might be. [15:12]	<Graestan>	261? [15:12]	<Toprawa>	Someone want to get a Word count? [15:13]	* Graestan	lacks the technical ability, remember :P [15:13]	<Toprawa>	I could...if you want to wait... [15:13]	<ChackJadson>	Grae: I put it in Word recently; it was like that length [15:13]	<Toprawa>	We should get an official mark. [15:13]	<Toprawa>	I'll do it...Please hold. [15:14]	-->|	Tommy9281 has joined #wookieepedia-agricorps [15:14]	=-=	Mode #wookieepedia-agricorps +v Tommy9281 by chanserv [15:14]	<Tommy9281>	Good afternoon fellas [15:14]	<ChackJadson>	Hey [15:15]	<Toprawa>	261 indeed. [15:15]	<Toprawa>	Keep, then [15:15]	<Toprawa>	We're currently deciding whether to keep or kill those articles probed at meeting 2, Tommy [15:15]	<Tommy9281>	Right [15:15]	<Toprawa>	We're voting on Rainboh [15:15]	<Toprawa>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Rainboh [15:15]	<Toprawa>	The issue was that it wasn't 250 words [15:15]	<Tommy9281>	Ahh [15:15]	<Toprawa>	but it's been resolved [15:16]	<Tommy9281>	Alright then [15:16]	<Graestan>	Eh, keep. Why not? We all love pictures drawn in crayon by little children. How delightful! [15:16]	<ChackJadson>	I dislike it, but keep [15:17]	<Tommy9281>	I didn't care for that either, but keep also [15:17]	<Toprawa>	Kept. [15:17]	<Toprawa>	Next: [15:17]	<Toprawa>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Separatist_Droid_Army [15:17]	<Toprawa>	Just pretty rough still. [15:17]	<Tommy9281>	I was looking at that yesterday [15:17]	<ChackJadson>	Kill [15:17]	<Toprawa>	That whole list section is unsourced. [15:17]	<Toprawa>	Kill [15:17]	<Tommy9281>	ditto [15:18]	<Graestan>	In no way detailed enough. Kill. [15:18]	<Tommy9281>	dead then [15:19]	<Toprawa>	Killed. [15:19]	<Toprawa>	Next agenda item. [15:19]	<Toprawa>	The Species/Droid review. [15:19]	<Tommy9281>	Species & Droids? [15:19]	<Tommy9281>	yes. [15:19]	<Toprawa>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Algae First up. [15:19]	<Graestan>	Charming, but I guarantee this article could be better. Not all info from all sources. Probation. [15:19]	<Toprawa>	My comments: "Very weak coverage. No history section whatsoever. There's a lot that could be added here. " [15:20]	<Tommy9281>	Ditto that [15:20]	<Toprawa>	Probe. [15:20]	<ChackJadson>	Probe [15:20]	<Toprawa>	Probed. [15:20]	<Toprawa>	Next: [15:20]	<Toprawa>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Arcona [15:20]	<Graestan>	Way too short. Probe. This would be FA length if done properly. I mean, Window Ned was. [15:20]	<Tommy9281>	Probe [15:20]	<Toprawa>	"Little to no sourcing. History section is severely lacking. Doesn't match Layout Guide in terms of coverage. " [15:20]	<Toprawa>	Probe. [15:20]	<ChackJadson>	Probation [15:21]	<Toprawa>	Probed. [15:21]	<Toprawa>	Next: [15:21]	<Toprawa>	Well, you've all gone and done it. [15:21]	<Toprawa>	Now I can't drag links anymore... [15:21]	<Toprawa>	Sarlacc is up, though [15:21]	<Tommy9281>	Sarlacc is dead [15:21]	<Tommy9281>	probe [15:21]	<Graestan>	Probation. Sourcing issues, to say the very least. [15:21]	<ChackJadson>	Indeed [15:21]	<Toprawa>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Sarlacc There we go [15:21]	<Graestan>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Sarlacc [15:22]	<Toprawa>	Probe [15:22]	<Toprawa>	Probed. [15:22]	<Toprawa>	Next: [15:22]	<Toprawa>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Species [15:22]	<Toprawa>	"Subpar coverage for such a broad topic." [15:22]	<Graestan>	Yeah. [15:22]	<Toprawa>	Probe. [15:22]	<Graestan>	It would be like Lando-length (his article, not... oh, nevermind) if it was long enough. [15:23]	<ChackJadson>	Probe [15:23]	<Graestan>	Probation. [15:23]	<Toprawa>	Probed. [15:23]	<Toprawa>	Next up: [15:23]	<ChackJadson>	lol Grae [15:23]	<Toprawa>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Ugor [15:23]	<Toprawa>	Acky handled what I had noticed, but he claims there is a bunch of missing info [15:23]	<Graestan>	Acky says it: [15:23]	<Toprawa>	So, probe on his word. [15:23]	<Graestan>	"there's a number of sources and appearances that aren't covered at all" [15:23]	<Graestan>	Probation. [15:23]	<ChackJadson>	Probe [15:24]	<Toprawa>	Probed. [15:24]	<Toprawa>	Next: [15:24]	<Toprawa>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Verpine [15:24]	<Toprawa>	"Intro just isn't long enough. Some bits of unsourced information, specifically in infobox. Unnecessary list section. " [15:24]	<ChackJadson>	Probation [15:24]	<Toprawa>	Probe. [15:24]	<Tommy9281>	I like the verpine, just not the article. Probe [15:24]	<Toprawa>	Probed. [15:24]	<Toprawa>	Next: [15:24]	<Graestan>	http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Verpine&diff=2260884&oldid=2181871 [15:24]	<Graestan>	Probation. [15:25]	<Toprawa>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/IG-100_MagnaGuard [15:25]	<Toprawa>	"Coverage is sketchy. Doesn't conform to Layout Guide. Missing information - missing even more substantial bits of info following new TCW episodes " [15:25]	<Toprawa>	We only need 3/4 votes :P [15:25]	<Toprawa>	The first 3 to get in [15:25]	<Toprawa>	Probe. [15:25]	<ChackJadson>	Probe [15:25]	<Toprawa>	It's a decent article, but it's just lacking [15:25]	<Tommy9281>	probe. [15:25]	<Toprawa>	Probed. [15:25]	<Toprawa>	Next: [15:25]	<Toprawa>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Variable_Geometry_Self-Propelled_Battle_Droid%2C_Mark_I [15:25]	<Toprawa>	"For the large number of appearances, I'm not sure the History section is adequate enough. Same with MagnaGuard, good chunks of missing TCW info. " [15:26]	<Toprawa>	This concerned me when I first voted for it. [15:26]	<Graestan>	Yeah [15:26]	<Tommy9281>	Meh [15:26]	<Toprawa>	Coverage not quite broad enough [15:26]	<Graestan>	This one will have to be put on hold as new sources appear. [15:26]	<Toprawa>	I regretted voting immediately afterward [15:26]	<Graestan>	TCW has them in like every episode. [15:26]	<Graestan>	Probation. [15:26]	<Toprawa>	Yeah [15:26]	<Toprawa>	Probe. [15:26]	<Tommy9281>	probe then [15:26]	<Toprawa>	Probed. [15:26]	<Toprawa>	Ok, discussion items now. [15:26]	<Toprawa>	First up, an easy one. [15:27]	* Graestan	only watches every TCW in the hopes a plunk will shuffle across the screen [15:27]	<Toprawa>	I want to make teh GA page look like the FA page for Characters [15:27]	<Toprawa>	Namely, organize by last name. [15:27]	<Toprawa>	Any objections? [15:27]	<Graestan>	Nope. [15:27]	<Tommy9281>	no [15:27]	<ChackJadson>	Go for it [15:27]	<Graestan>	Ye canna doooit, Captain! [15:27]	<Toprawa>	Cool. [15:27]	<Toprawa>	It will be done. [15:27]	<Graestan>	We canna hold it any longer! [15:27]	<Toprawa>	Next, Grae has the flloor. [15:27]	* Graestan	prepares The Boot [15:28]	<Graestan>	*REVIEW MORE ARTICLES, PEOPLE! YES, I UNDERSTAND I AM PART OF THE PROBLEM!* [15:28]	<Graestan>	:P [15:28]	<Graestan>	That is all. [15:28]	<Toprawa>	In all fairness, we just had like 17 new noms in the past 36 hours. [15:28]	<Graestan>	True. [15:28]	<Toprawa>	We went from like 7 to 27 in 2 days. [15:28]	<Graestan>	Part of the Fourdot Quest for 100. [15:28]	<Toprawa>	Yeah [15:28]	<Tommy9281>	Yeah I noticed that [15:28]	<Graestan>	His too-shorts end up on our page instead of the FAN. [15:28]	<ChackJadson>	Real quick, the reason I might not read a ton is cuz I'm very active reading FA noms [15:29]	<Tommy9281>	I'll step it up a little this week [15:29]	<Tommy9281>	hopefully [15:29]	<Toprawa>	Ok. [15:29]	<Tommy9281>	pc time is limited, but I'll do what I can [15:29]	<Toprawa>	Any other lingering concerns? [15:29]	* Tommy9281	has none [15:30]	<Toprawa>	If there are none, Meeting 3 is hereby closed. Happy reviewing.