Forum:Disputed Trash compactor closing

Per the newly adopted administrative autonomy rule, I have created this forum to discuss an administrator action. --Imperialles 17:53, 21 October 2007 (UTC)


 * Involved administrators: Darth Culator, Imperialles
 * The disputed action: Darth Culator closed the Trash compactor discussion regarding the article "List of sexual references in Star Wars" after the discussion had been up for ten days, with a result of "No consensus." (link) (diff)
 * The dispute: Darth Culator feels enough debate has occurred, and wishes to keep the thread closed. Imperialles feels the TC discussion could benefit from more debate, and wishes to re-open the thread.

The issue was discussed in part in Wookieepedia's IRC channel. (

Discussion
I would like to see the thread re-opened because this is a difficult case that, given more debate and time, we might see a clear-cut consensus in. I feel ten days is far too little time to establish consensus in a disputed TC such as this. Additionally, there already exists a consensus to leave TC discussions open for two weeks before closing (link). --Imperialles 17:53, 21 October 2007 (UTC)