Category talk:Fan films/Archive 1

Notability criteria?
What criteria are we Wookieepedians using to decide which fanfilms are important enough to rate an article?

Please note that I am not saying that Star Wars:Revelations, IMPS – The Relentless, or the Star Wars Fan Film Awards do not deserve articles. Nor am I saying these should be the only ones to deserve articles -- I'd like to see an article on TROOPS myself. I just want some guidelines. Silly Dan 02:27, 4 May 2005 (UTC)
 * I think any fan-film that has been featured in the Star Wars Fan Film Awards deserves an article, and perhaps later productions by the same people, if only a stub with a link to location. So long as it is clear these are not official products (as should be clear by the category) then I see no problem. I don't think any characters or ships from the fan-films merit articles though.--Eion 02:37, 4 May 2005 (UTC)
 * I agree. TROOPS predates the awards, but it's one of the first ones to become popular on the internet, and gained some media attention, so it's significant enough for an article too, I hope. Silly Dan 04:14, 4 May 2005 (UTC)
 * In additioon, Star Wars:Revelations is not eligible for a FF Award, b/c it is in-universe, but it does represent a signifigant effort on the part of the film-makers, and is well-known in the SW community, and thus merits and article IMHO.--Eion 04:16, 4 May 2005 (UTC)