Wookieepedia:AC/Log/2011 October 1

Oct 01 23:06:58 <@ecks>	Welcome to AC meeting 39. Oct 01 23:07:13 <@ecks>	First up on the agenda is old articles. Oct 01 23:07:31 <@ecks>	wait... :P Oct 01 23:07:36 <@ecks>	starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Battle_of_Malastare Oct 01 23:07:42 <@ecks>	great, firefox Oct 01 23:07:49 <@ecks>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Battle_of_Malastare Oct 01 23:08:01 <@ecks>	http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?diff=cur&oldid=3681422 Oct 01 23:08:10 <@Toprawa>	I wish CC was here to tell us what he thought of this Oct 01 23:08:11 <@ecks>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:AC/Battle_of_Malastare Oct 01 23:08:41 <@Jujiggum>	Aye. looks fixed, but I know nothing of the source etc. so I can't say for sure... Oct 01 23:08:54 <@ecks>	Hmm Oct 01 23:08:56 <@CavalierOne>	Same. Oct 01 23:08:58 <@ecks>	http://www.rebelscum.com/TCW28-CloneGoji.asp Oct 01 23:09:08 <@Toprawa>	The info appears to be there Oct 01 23:09:09 <@ecks>	Looks like that is the source. Oct 01 23:09:13 <@Toprawa>	Whether it's quality or not, I cannot say Oct 01 23:09:23 <@Toprawa>	I can vote keep Oct 01 23:09:33 <@Jujiggum>	I'm good with keeping Oct 01 23:09:33 *	@ecks votes keep Oct 01 23:09:37 <@grunny>	keep, appears okay, can always revisit Oct 01 23:09:45 <@CavalierOne>	Keep Oct 01 23:09:52 <@ecks>	Battle of Malastare kept. Oct 01 23:10:02 <@ecks>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Gor Oct 01 23:10:10 <@ecks>	http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?diff=cur&oldid=3690331 Oct 01 23:10:16 <@ecks>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:AC/Gor_%28third_review%29 Oct 01 23:10:20 <@grunny>	keep Oct 01 23:10:25 <@Toprawa>	Keep Oct 01 23:10:27 <@Jujiggum>	Keep Oct 01 23:10:37 <@ecks>	keep Oct 01 23:10:42 <@CavalierOne>	Keep Oct 01 23:10:53 <@ecks>	Gor kept. Oct 01 23:11:00 <@ecks>	Next up, new articles. Oct 01 23:11:07 <@ecks>	Thannik. Written as if the intro is the first paragraph of the bio. Virtually everything in the intro isn't repeated anywhere else in the article. Menkooroo 09:03, September 27, 2011 (UTC) Oct 01 23:11:13 <@ecks>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Thannik Oct 01 23:11:23 <@Toprawa>	Agreed Oct 01 23:11:24 <@Jujiggum>	Probe Oct 01 23:11:26 <@Toprawa>	Probe Oct 01 23:11:27 <@ecks>	Probe Oct 01 23:11:34 <@grunny>	probe Oct 01 23:11:59 <@CavalierOne>	Probe Oct 01 23:12:03 <@ecks>	Thannik probed. Oct 01 23:12:08 <@ecks>	Jinx - Update tag. Toprawa and Ralltiir 18:09, September 29, 2011 (UTC) Oct 01 23:12:16 <@ecks>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Jinx Oct 01 23:12:24 <@ecks>	Probe Oct 01 23:12:25 <@Jujiggum>	Probe it Oct 01 23:12:29 <@Toprawa>	Probe Oct 01 23:12:35 <@CavalierOne>	Probe Oct 01 23:13:08 <@grunny>	probe Oct 01 23:13:13 <@ecks>	Jinx probed. Oct 01 23:13:20 <@ecks>	Treaty of Coruscant - Has a Fact tag in there somewhere. Toprawa and Ralltiir 18:09, September 29, 2011 (UTC) Oct 01 23:13:20 <@ecks>	   This diff is what you're looking for. Master Jonathan — Jedi Council Chambers Friday, September 30, 2011, 01:19 UTC Oct 01 23:13:25 <@ecks>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Treaty_of_Coruscant Oct 01 23:13:27 <@Toprawa>	There are enough redirects in this article that I would note that for fixing as well. Oct 01 23:14:09 <@Jujiggum>	As for the fact tag, though, if that's the case then just put an "circa" before the date Oct 01 23:14:31 <@Jujiggum>	(Bob added it: "I can find no information that gives a firm date; everything is "approximately" in BioWare's information") Oct 01 23:14:31 <@Toprawa>	Would that solve the issue? Oct 01 23:14:32 <@ecks>	Yeah, I'm not really sure. Oct 01 23:14:41 <@ecks>	It might be hidden there in the video somewhere. Oct 01 23:14:47 <@ecks>	I'm not sure if it gives the date. Oct 01 23:15:06 <@Jujiggum>	There are a TON of redirects, though, you're right Tope Oct 01 23:15:08 <@grunny>	I thought the Treaty of Coruscant was ATC 0 or whatever Oct 01 23:15:13 <@grunny>	which is that date Oct 01 23:15:16 <@Jujiggum>	It'd probably be worth a good copy-edit to check other stuff as well Oct 01 23:15:29 <@ecks>	Yeah, but is it mentioned in the video? Oct 01 23:15:49 <@Jujiggum>	Yeah, actually for the date: we have other dates for things like the Sacking of Coruscant Oct 01 23:16:00 <@Jujiggum>	And books like Deceived that connect the two Oct 01 23:16:07 <@Jujiggum>	We don't have to use the timeline for the source Oct 01 23:16:14 <@Jujiggum>	*timeline video, I mean Oct 01 23:16:26 <@Toprawa>	It sounds like it needs a written-out reference note, at least Oct 01 23:16:32 <@Jujiggum>	Aye Oct 01 23:16:34 <@Toprawa>	Just adding a generic source isn't clear enough Oct 01 23:16:46 <@ecks>	Yeah, exactly my thoughts. Oct 01 23:17:02 <@ecks>	I'm willing to probe Oct 01 23:17:05 <@grunny>	probe, for get it looked into and clarify + general copy-edit, redirect cleanup, etc. Oct 01 23:17:08 <@Jujiggum>	Go ahead and probe, based on that and the fact that it could probably use some general cleanup Oct 01 23:17:16 <@Jujiggum>	Yeah, what Grunny said Oct 01 23:17:20 <@Toprawa>	yeah ^ Oct 01 23:17:34 <@CavalierOne>	Agreed Oct 01 23:17:48 <@ecks>	Alright, Treaty of Coruscant probed. Oct 01 23:18:02 <@ecks>	Nothing new on the maintenance page. Oct 01 23:18:07 <@ecks>	Anyone have something else? Oct 01 23:18:15 <@Jujiggum>	Nothing from me Oct 01 23:18:18 <@Toprawa>	I'll pull up the duties Oct 01 23:18:23 <@Toprawa>	the Duties* Oct 01 23:18:29 <@ecks>	No discussion items either? Oct 01 23:18:34 <@ecks>	I'm also looking for them :P Oct 01 23:18:47 <@ecks>	hmm Oct 01 23:18:52 <@ecks>	who was it last time? :P Oct 01 23:19:06 <@Toprawa>	ok, Floyd scheduled last time Oct 01 23:19:08 <@ecks>	Appears like CavalierOne gets to schedule the next meeting. Oct 01 23:19:13 <@Toprawa>	so Cav schedules next meeting Oct 01 23:19:23 <@Toprawa>	who did paperwork last time? Oct 01 23:19:28 <@grunny>	Kilson? Oct 01 23:19:30 <@ecks>	^ Oct 01 23:19:34 <@Toprawa>	yeah, I think it was Oct 01 23:19:37 <@ecks>	so it's me Oct 01 23:19:38 <@ecks>	bah! Oct 01 23:19:54 <@ecks>	Anyway, are we done? Oct 01 23:20:19 <@Jujiggum>	Think so Oct 01 23:20:20 <@ecks>	Apparently. Oct 01 23:20:28 <@ecks>	Meeting 39 is hereby adjourned. Oct 01 23:20:32 <@ecks>	Thanks for coming.