Wookieepedia:EduCorps/Meeting 50/Log

[16:01] <@exiledjedi> We will start with the articles from last meeting. [16:02] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Brogune [16:02] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?diff=cur&oldid=7844830 [16:02] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Brogune [16:02] <@exiledjedi> No substantial changes. [16:02] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Kill [16:02] <@Ayrehead02> Kill [16:02] <@ecks> kill bill [16:02] <@exiledjedi> Kill [16:02] <@Imperators> kill [16:02] <@CorellianPremier> yep, kill [16:02] <@exiledjedi> Brogune killed. [16:03] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Dowutin_precursor_species [16:03] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?diff=cur&oldid=7844831 [16:03] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Dowutin_precursor_species [16:03] <@exiledjedi> Looks like this was updated. [16:03] <@Ayrehead02> Thanks for getting the reference Fred [16:05] <@Imperators> keep [16:05] <@exiledjedi> Keep [16:05] <@Ayrehead02> Keep [16:05] <@ecks> keep [16:05] <@CorellianPremier> keep [16:05] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Yeah keep [16:05] <@exiledjedi> Dowutin precursor species kept. [16:06] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Harbin-re [16:06] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?diff=cur&oldid=7844861 [16:06] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Harbin-re_(second_review) [16:06] <@exiledjedi> No change. [16:06] <@Ayrehead02> Kill [16:06] <@ecks> kill [16:06] <@exiledjedi> Kill [16:06] <@Tommy-Macaroni> kill [16:06] <@Imperators> astro-kill [16:06] <@CorellianPremier> kill [16:06] <@exiledjedi> Harbin-re killed. [16:06] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Mud_Jumpers [16:06] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?diff=cur&oldid=7722404 [16:06] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Mud_Jumpers [16:07] <@Imperators> I'm ready to kill it even without opening the review page. [16:07] <@exiledjedi> Some stuff was done, but nobody updated the review page. [16:07] <@ecks> do we even have a redux page? [16:08] <@Imperators> YES WE PROUDLY DO [16:08] <@Imperators> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Redux_page [16:08] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Sadly AV can't edit anymore to fix it [16:08] <@Ayrehead02> Oh crap yeah [16:09] <@exiledjedi> Is there nothing from Solo: A Star Wars Story? [16:09] <@Imperators> so wait, the former clone troopers later fought the Empire?? [16:09] <@Tommy-Macaroni> The clone bit is into exclusive [16:09] <@Tommy-Macaroni> I think it's an assumption [16:09] <@Imperators> if they appeared in Solo, there have to be image(s) [16:09] <@Ayrehead02> Yeah this articles a mess [16:10] <@Imperators> cut last BTS sentence [16:10] <@Imperators> extend [16:10] <@exiledjedi> There is nothing in the body from either the movie or the guide, which I find very suspect. [16:10] <@exiledjedi> Extend [16:10] <@Ayrehead02> Extend [16:10] <@ecks> extend I guess [16:10] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Extend, if only to kill later [16:11] <@CorellianPremier> OK, extend [16:11] <@exiledjedi> Mud Jumpers extended. May its nightmare never end. [16:11] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Rengali_Imperial_Naval_Academy [16:11] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?diff=cur&oldid=7722399 [16:11] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Rengali_Imperial_Naval_Academy [16:12] <@exiledjedi> Lots happened here. [16:12] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Imperators seems to have done a pretty thorough review [16:12] <@Imperators> CP fought for it :P [16:12] <@CorellianPremier> Indeed [16:14] <@Imperators> I believe CP has whipped the article into shape to my satisfaction, so unless anyone else has anything... [16:14] <@Ayrehead02> Looks alright to me [16:14] <@Tommy-Macaroni> I say keep [16:14] <@exiledjedi> Looks fine. [16:14] <@ecks> keep [16:14] <@exiledjedi> Keep [16:14] <@Ayrehead02> Keep [16:14] <@Imperators> keep [16:14] <@CorellianPremier> keep [16:15] <@exiledjedi> Rengali Imperial Naval Academy kept. [16:15] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Scorpion_slug [16:15] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?diff=cur&oldid=7844833 [16:15] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Scorpion_slug [16:15] <@Tommy-Macaroni> kill [16:15] <@exiledjedi> No substantial changes. [16:15] <@Imperators> kill the thing [16:15] <@exiledjedi> Kill [16:15] <@ecks> kill [16:15] <@Ayrehead02> Kill [16:16] <@exiledjedi> And the scorpion slug is no more. [16:16] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Shi%27kar [16:16] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?diff=cur&oldid=7844869 [16:16] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Shi%27kar_(second_review) [16:17] <@exiledjedi> It looks like the original stuff was worked on. [16:17] <@Imperators> unfortunately, I added more stuff to do [16:18] <@exiledjedi> Yeah, extend I guess... [16:18] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Extend [16:18] <@Imperators> extend [16:18] <@ecks> extend [16:18] <@CorellianPremier> ok extend [16:18] <@Ayrehead02> Extend [16:18] <@exiledjedi> Shi'kar extended. [16:18] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Toma_(Fallanassi) [16:18] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?diff=cur&oldid=7844836 [16:18] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Toma_(Fallanassi) [16:19] <@exiledjedi> No substantial changes. [16:19] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Kill [16:19] <@Imperators> yay, easy kill [16:19] <@exiledjedi> Kill [16:19] <@CorellianPremier> ok kill [16:19] <@Ayrehead02> Kill [16:19] <@exiledjedi> Toma killed. [16:20] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Unidentified_Tatooine_astromech_droid [16:20] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?diff=cur&oldid=7844865 [16:20] <@Imperators> oh boy [16:20] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Unidentified_Tatooine_astromech_droid_(second_review) [16:20] <@exiledjedi> Stuff was done. [16:20] <@Tommy-Macaroni> 261 words by my count [16:20] <@Imperators> sorry, CP, but this is still not yet done. [16:21] <@Imperators> ref 2 needs to mention that (and according to what source) this droid is an R5 [16:21] <@Imperators> that's kind of a new standard for status article referencing now [16:21] <@Imperators> I'd swap TERC for NEC in ref 3 [16:22] <@Imperators> and ref 4 needs to just be a simple reference to Crosscurrent [16:22] <@exiledjedi> I'm pretty sure this is going to need to be sectioned / have an intro added. [16:22] <@Imperators> there's a duplicate link, not that it's a big deal [16:22] <@Ayrehead02> So extend? [16:22] <@Imperators> the paragraph needs to be split [16:22] <@Imperators> extend [16:22] <@ecks> extend [16:22] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Extend [16:22] <@exiledjedi> extend [16:22] <@CorellianPremier> OK extend [16:23] <@Ayrehead02> Extend [16:23] <@exiledjedi> UTAD extended. [16:23] <@exiledjedi> On to new stuff. [16:23] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Adler_Roty [16:24] <@exiledjedi>    The BTS is currently entirely sourced to the definition for nummamorous. [16:24] <@exiledjedi>    Could a better site be used for the reference 4? [16:24] <@exiledjedi>    CSWECite should be used for reference 1. [16:24] <@exiledjedi>    The dates in the article need additional referencing. [16:24] <@Ayrehead02> Probe [16:24] <@exiledjedi> Probe [16:24] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Prob [16:24] <@CorellianPremier> Probe [16:24] <@Imperators> ew, dat date non-referencing [16:24] <@Imperators> probe [16:25] <@exiledjedi> Adler Roty probed. [16:25] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Angry_machine [16:25] <@Imperators> great, we're even going after magicians now [16:25] <@exiledjedi>    Reference 2 cannot be used to source the entire BTS. [16:25] <@exiledjedi>    Reference 2 needs to use a citation template / have a backup link provided. [16:26] <@ecks> probe [16:26] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Probe [16:26] <@Ayrehead02> Probe [16:26] <@exiledjedi> Probe [16:26] <@CorellianPremier> Prboe it [16:26] <@exiledjedi> Angry machine probed. [16:26] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Aplocaph [16:26] <@Imperators> where was Vader's angry machine, I wonder [16:27] <@exiledjedi>    If they received an entry, why does the sources section only reference another entry. If it has its own entry, it shouldn't need CSWECite in the sources. [16:27] <@exiledjedi>    BTS is unsourced. [16:27] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Probe [16:27] <@exiledjedi> Probe [16:27] <@Ayrehead02> Probe [16:27] <@CorellianPremier> Deep probe [16:27] <@Imperators> probe [16:27] <@exiledjedi> Aplocaph probed. [16:27] <@Imperators> cut the second sentence of BTS [16:28] <@Ayrehead02> Probe [16:28] <@ecks> p [16:28] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Aramb [16:28] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Thanks Ayre very cool [16:28] <@exiledjedi>    The BTS is unsourced. [16:28] <@exiledjedi>    The CSWE mention in the BTS seems unnecessary. [16:28] <@exiledjedi>    The date needs additional referencing. [16:28] <@exiledjedi>    Even without the CSWE mention in the BTS, this article is over 200 words and should be sectioned and have an introduction added. [16:28] <@ecks> p [16:29] <@exiledjedi> Probe [16:29] <@Ayrehead02> Probe [16:29] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Probe! [16:29] <@CorellianPremier> Probe [16:29] <@Imperators> CSWECite [16:29] <@Imperators> and then probe [16:29] <@exiledjedi> Aramb probed. [16:29] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Atrivis_Advancer [16:29] <@exiledjedi>    The body does not make any reference to the era the ship was used. [16:29] <@exiledjedi>    The BTS is unsourced. [16:30] <@Ayrehead02> Probe [16:30] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Probe? [16:30] <@exiledjedi> Probe [16:30] <@CorellianPremier> Probe [16:30] <@Imperators> probe ship [16:30] <@exiledjedi> Atrivis Advancer probed. [16:31] <@exiledjedi> https://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Aubin_Kleej%27s_mother [16:31] <@exiledjedi> The 3963 BBY date is exclusive to the infobox. [16:31] <@exiledjedi> Why does the infobox say that she is affiliated with The Crucible? The body doesn't back this up. [16:31] <@exiledjedi> The BTS is unsourced. [16:31] <@ecks> p [16:31] <@exiledjedi> Probe [16:31] <@Ayrehead02> Probe [16:31] <@Tommy-Macaroni> "Probe" [16:31] <@Imperators> probe [16:31] <@CorellianPremier> probe [16:32] <@exiledjedi> Aubin Kleej's mother probed. [16:32] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Ugh still no Tope [16:32] <@exiledjedi> Nothing in the bin. [16:32] <@exiledjedi> Does anyone else have any articles? [16:32] <@ecks> nay [16:32] <@Ayrehead02> Nothing from me [16:32] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Nope [16:32] <@CorellianPremier> Nope [16:33] <@Imperators> sec [16:33] <@Imperators> ooh yeah [16:33] <@Imperators> https://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Conduit_worm&diff=7901869&oldid=7639901 [16:33] <@Imperators> Redux baby [16:33] <@Ayrehead02> Redux [16:34] <@CorellianPremier> Sure, redux [16:34] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Redux [16:34] <@exiledjedi> Redux [16:34] <@ecks> redux [16:34] <@exiledjedi> Conduit worm reduxed. [16:34] <@exiledjedi> Anything else? [16:34] <@Imperators> https://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Amita_Fonti&diff=7812942&oldid=7709833 [16:35] <@Imperators> both image and additional sources added by anon [16:35] <@Imperators> I'd like some verification [16:35] <@ecks> verification of what exactly? [16:36] <@Imperators> the new image is sourced to Heroes on Both Sides [16:36] <@Imperators> BTS talks about this [16:36] <@Ayrehead02> Found her in the Organa gallery [16:37] <@Ayrehead02> Oh wow she is tiny in the back of an image in the CIS one as well [16:37] <@ecks> yep [16:37] <@exiledjedi> Is the BTS wrong or is the image selected wrong? [16:38] <@Ayrehead02> What's the contradiction? [16:38] <@Imperators> the way I read it, Heroes on Both Sides by itself cannot be used to identify Fonti visually [16:38] <@Ayrehead02> Oh the not specified bit [16:38] <@Imperators> I guess this looks like a simple revert, then [16:39] <@ecks> I'm not sure what exactly you mean [16:39] <@ecks> it is an image from HOBS, and their presence in HOBS is confirmed by the epguide [16:39] <@Imperators> " though it did not specify which Gossam was Fonti" [16:39] <@Ayrehead02> I assume there are multiple Gossam in HOBS [16:40] <@ecks> the epguide does say "Amita Fonti, a Gossam alien" [16:40] <@Imperators> so how can you have an image from HOBS supposedly depicting Fonti [16:40] <@exiledjedi> Either the BTS is wrong or we can't use that image. [16:41] <@exiledjedi> One way or another, something needs to be changed. [16:41] <@Imperators> I don't know enough about TCW to tell myself, but the former comes from an established editor and underwent review process, the latter comes from an anon [16:41] <@Ayrehead02> Yeah there's a tone of Gossam with identical models in the parliment scene [16:41] <@Ayrehead02> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qhDHWi43YaA [16:41] <@Ayrehead02> Just revert the image [16:42] <@Imperators> fine. Thanks for getting the backup links, anyway, ecks :P [16:42] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Yeah I agree with Ayre, just revert the anon [16:43] <@CorellianPremier> Sounds good [16:43] <@Imperators> and I'm afraid that's it, I can't stall any longer [16:43] <@Ayrehead02> Actually [16:43] <@Ayrehead02> The CIS DB link should be removed as well [16:43] <@Ayrehead02> Since we don't know if the Gossams in that image are her [16:43] <@exiledjedi> Yeah, I was assuming that we would just revert the entire edit. [16:44] <@Ayrehead02> The Organa link is legit [16:44] <@Imperators> OK, I'll revert the image and CIS, then [16:44] <@Ayrehead02> Cool [16:44] <@exiledjedi> All right, does anyone have any discussion items? [16:45] <@ecks> membership [16:45] <@ecks> did we discuss QGJ at the last meeting? [16:45] <@Tommy-Macaroni> No [16:45] <@Ayrehead02> Tope's mentioned wanting to add him in IRC, but not officially at any meeting [16:45] <@Imperators> off-the-record, to the log gods [16:45] <@ecks> nod [16:45] <@ecks> personally I think he's ready [16:46] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Agreed, he's a solid reviewer [16:46] <@Ayrehead02> Indeed [16:46] <@Tommy-Macaroni> A little rough around the edges maybe, but ready for the EC [16:46] <@CorellianPremier> yep, sounds good [16:46] <@Imperators> have to agree [16:47] <@ecks> any objections to admitting QGJ? [16:47] <@Ayrehead02> Looks like we're all good [16:47] <@Imperators> shame the guy's not around [16:48] <@Ayrehead02> Shame Tope isn't either [16:48] <@Tommy-Macaroni> He's a semi-regular, he'll be around [16:48] <@exiledjedi> Okay, have we asked him if he is interested yet? [16:48] <@Ayrehead02> I think Tope did [16:49] <@ecks> guess someone can ask him to come on IRC [16:49] <@exiledjedi> Okay, somebody will need to let him know. [16:49] <@Ayrehead02> Is it part of paperwork? [16:50] <@ecks> who's on paperwork? [16:50] <@exiledjedi> Let's see. [16:50] <@Imperators> scuttle [16:50] <@exiledjedi> Corellian Premier is on paperwork. [16:50] <@ecks> CP, you wanna do the honors? [16:50] <@exiledjedi> Supreme Emperor schedules meeting 51. [16:51] <@ecks> I can do it since I'm always on IRC if no one else wants to [16:51] <@ecks> (ps. I do have a life) [16:51] <@CorellianPremier> Alright [16:51] <@exiledjedi> If QGJ accepts, we should probably regenerate the duties at the next meeting. [16:51] <@Ayrehead02> Sounds good [16:51] <@exiledjedi> All right, thanks for coming everybody. [16:51] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Yay! [16:51] <@Ayrehead02> While everyone's here [16:51] <@Tommy-Macaroni> Thanks for hosting EJ [16:51] <@exiledjedi> I've got to head out, but I will post the log if no one else does. [16:51] <@exiledjedi> No problem. [16:51] <@Imperators> yeah, thanks EJ