Forum:SH Archive/Talk page editintro

So, while looking at the Talkheader and the various editintro templates we have like Featured editintro and Good editintro, I came up with an idea. Users often create talk pages about off-topic discussion that is barred by the talkheader, but when the new user is the first to create the page, they don't see the talkheader. My proposal is that we create a new template, Talk editintro, that appears every time any user edits a talk page. Thus, the talkheader's warning is consistently apparent to users, no matter whether they create a talk page or simply edit a section at the bottom. As a result, Talkheader would become obsolete, except for the talk page archive functionality. Therefore, I also think we can strip out the talkheader part and leave a smaller template with just the archive links; the talkheader could then be deprecated with a bot.

Here are example templates I came up with. So, thoughts? I'm fine with modifications to the specific text of the editintro template and the text formatting, but I think that using an editintro would be far more effective than a talkheader. Cade   Calrayn  22:36, January 28, 2014 (UTC)