Wookieepedia:Trash compactor/Category:Chalmun's Cantina patrons (second nomination)

Category:Chalmun's Cantina patrons
Second nomination; the first one ended in no consensus a year ago. It hasn't ceased to be any less of a ridiculously unencylopedic joke of a category. It's a triviality, and if you want trivia, go to the Federal Bureau of Miscellaneous Information. Does Wikipedia have Category:People who have been to Applebee's? Do we want a precedent for Category:People who have been to the Headquarters? Should we have Category:People who have ever been to Coruscant? Category:People who have fought Boba Fett? It's the same sort of unencylopedic, overbroad, pointless categorization of trivia. As interesting as the subject might seem to you, it's not a category topic.

Last time, people suggested it was good for telling you who's in the cantina scene. Well, a lot more people have been to Chalmun's than have ever been in the cantina scene. There was no consensus to maybe use a list instead, or have it on ANH's page. Well, let this just be a straight up-or-down delete or keep vote. If you think this is truly worthy of being a category, vote to keep it. If you don't, vote to delete it, and you're free to create a list or a new section on another page as you wish. But let's not clutter up what should be a straightforward vote with the kind of maybe-if-something-else nonsense that gets us no consensus and doesn't benefit anyone. Havac 17:53, 13 March 2009 (UTC)

Delete

 * 1) Havac 17:53, 13 March 2009 (UTC)