Talk:SuperShadow

VfD
On April 28, 2005, this article was nominated for deletion. The result was Keep. See Star Wars:Votes for deletion/SuperShadow for a record of the discussion. -- Riffsyphon1024 05:49, 3 May 2005 (UTC)

It seems that SS is now jabbering about a second sequel trilogy (Episodes X, XI, and XII) being "made" by himself...--Spanky The Dolphin 09:12, 7 Jul 2005 (UTC)
 * If that is so, then it must be noted to prevent even further chaos. -- Riffsyphon1024 19:36, 7 Jul 2005 (UTC)
 * I agree, SS can't make his own sequel trilogy, unless they are all fanfare movies.This chaos must be stopped before it begins.Purplesaber 42

Scary
It scares me that this is one of our best articles. :) QuentinGeorge 02:20, 24 Jul 2005 (UTC)
 * I know what you mean. This page gets more hits on Wookiepedia than Coruscant, Thrawn, and Darth Bane--hallmarks of the Expanded Universe he pretends is non canonical. --User:SFH
 * The only good info I ever found on his page was a map he ripped off of nav-computer.com (without giving any credit) and a list of sentient species that he copied and pasted off MY Catalogue of Sentient Species in theforce.net's lit forums (I'm Senator Cilghal over there). So I feel a kinship with Cartographer (maker of nav-computer), a respectable and polite feloow fan with whom I have shared many emails concerning possible planet placements and whose map is by far the best available (even outclassing official maps available at present), b/c we are both victims of SuperShadow.  When SuperShadow did this to me, I did not mind my list being copied at all, just that he did not even give me so much as a nod of appreciation towards me and the other forumfolk whom helped me compile it!  And Cartographer, apparently, even wrote him an email saying he didn't mind the map being mirrored, and just wanted credit.  By that time, I had heard all about SS's reputation at the forums, and found out my complaint of piracy was nothing new, and I had checked out his site and seen how dishonest he was, so I didn't even bother writing the guy, since it would have done NO good.  There's nothing wrong with fanfiction (which was essentially what most of his content was), except that he tried to act as if it was canon, privy info.  "Bad form!" to quote James T. Hook.  "Bad form!" -- JustinGann
 * SS is a disgrace to the SW community. I wish he would do something better with his life, like work for the tabloids, which I'm sure he'd be good at. About Carty, if given full credit, would he let us use his maps at all? -- Riffsyphon1024 20:59, 14 Aug 2005 (UTC)
 * We know SS is a disgrace to the Star Wars community. But a thought comes to mind. Does Cartographer have exclusive rights to that specific map? If he does, he might be able to threaten SS with legal action. Not that I'm actively advocating this. It was just a thought. --User:SFH
 * I'm sure he wouldn't mind us using his maps if we asked him first and gave him credits, like a link to his website within the article. I'll ask him. (Unsigned comment by User:JustinGann)
 * We already link to his website on the article on the Galaxy. That shouldn't be much of a problem. --User:SFH

Khameir Sarin

 * Star Wars Timeline Gold confirms that "Khameir Sarin" is Maul's real name:


 * The name comes from the foreign editions of the Virtual Encyclopedia (I’m assuming the Insider’s Guide). It was cut from the English edition, but made it through to be officially “printed” in the foreign markets.


 * So there ya go. MarcK 06:56, 23 Aug 2005 (UTC)
 * Hmmm...does that make it canon, though? Regardless, someone should update the Khameir Sarin page. QuentinGeorge 06:58, 23 Aug 2005 (UTC)
 * If it indeed made it into foreign printings "accidentally", then it isn't canon, as no cut content is canon. But I think the article Khameir Sarin should be left as is and a notice about these foreign versions should be included into Darth Maul's BTS section. - Sikon 08:06, 23 Aug 2005 (UTC)
 * Is the name "canon"? Or was it fanon that foreign translations picked up on? I understood it was officially abandonned, if it had ever been legit. --McEwok 15:27, 2 Sep 2005 (UTC)

Arline Tickets?
Who deleted everything on this page and replaced it with airline ticket links of some kind? I hate vandilism!
 * I reverted it, but I had to remove the petitionsonline.com link due to it triggering a spam filter of some sort. StarNeptune 15:06, 2 Sep 2005 (UTC)