Talk:Vergere

Credits

 * 04:09, 24 Apr 2005 128.205.163.96
 * 14:18, 27 Mar 2005 81.17.197.146
 * 15:06, 24 Mar 2005 Aidje m (spelling)
 * 01:57, 13 Mar 2005 222.152.238.170
 * 21:47, 24 Nov 2004 67.48.88.113
 * 21:47, 24 Nov 2004 67.48.88.113
 * 19:45, 18 Oct 2004 24.157.80.49
 * 22:29, 13 Oct 2004 Jon Hart
 * 22:13, 30 Aug 2004 Kevyn m (Fixed link to Jacen Solo)
 * 00:44, 23 Aug 2004 Kevyn m (Fixed link to Fosh)
 * 07:59, 6 Aug 2004 203.164.57.104
 * 21:01, 7 Jul 2004 Fafner m
 * 05:48, 30 May 2004 DopefishJustin (disambig Expanded Universe, link fictional character)
 * 09:35, 14 May 2004 Jaredwf (sp)
 * 03:54, 23 Jan 2004 63.191.224.12 (Corrections)
 * 03:52, 23 Jan 2004 63.191.224.12 (The beginning of it all)

Captions?
why aren't their captions on any pictures? Danny Havelick 22:53, 12 October 2006 (UTC)]]

Master?
Should we count Vergere as a Master? -- SFH 17:09, 29 Oct 2005 (UTC)

No, because she was only a newly appointed Jedi Knight when she left for her mission, and should well have been corrupted before the events of the NJO where she corrupts Jacen, which makes her a fallen Jedi and more precisely, a dark Jedi. While there are new hints that she is a failed Sith apprentice, that would still make her a dark Jedi, and not any Sith rank, unless she and Lumiya are working together to bring a new Sith order. Additionally, Jedi Masters of Vergere's time frame (Rise of the Empire Era: 32-19 years BBY) could achieve the status of Jedi Master ONLY if the Jedi High Council approved it, which they did not. Either way, her status as a Jedi itself is gone, let alone the potential of her being a master.

Creator?
I'd like to know who created Vergere 'cause i'm doin' a list of who created who? so I really like to know (and I think it's either Greg Bear or James Luceno.) And I'm sota confused partly because of the Quinlan Vos thing (in which even thou that he was written for the then upcoming Twlight story arc i think his first offical appearence was issue 5 of the Emissaries of Malastare which came before Twlight itself. And I was thinkin' Was this like this with Vergere?Thanks.
 * Creator of Vergere was Jim Luceno. She was created for the NJO series, and inserted in Rogue Planet and Cloak of Deception to give her a background. QuentinGeorge 23:30, 12 Nov 2005 (UTC)

Cleanup?
Some of this article is confusing. I don't really know her story, so I think this should be dealt with by someone with a little more knowlege of the subject. I think the 5th and 6th paragraphs in her biography are what I'm getting hung up on the most. The 5th paragraph has a run on sentence that is missing enough words for the meaning to be lost. Another confusing point would be the death of Tsavong Lah: I noticed an inconsistency between his own biography and what this page says; again, I don't know the story, so I'm not sure which one is correct.

Also, I'm new to this editing process, so if I should(and could) have recommended this for clean up, I apologise for not doing so. If anyone can tell me how I might do that, or direct me to a source that would, please do. Thank you.


 * Tagged for cleanup. - QuentinGeorge 09:47, 29 Nov 2005 (UTC)

clean up
Cleaned up some grammar and stuff. My first attempt at editing, so I hope I haven't trodden on anyone's toes.

Infobox
So what do we classify Vergere as now? Sith? Jedi? Dark Jedi? I'm losing track again. -- SFH 05:01, 20 May 2006 (UTC)
 * It seems like she would be a Jedi and a Sith. Kuralyov 05:10, 20 May 2006 (UTC)
 * And another question: Would she have been Dark Lord of the Sith with Darth Sidious, or did their Master/Apprentice relationship ever get that far? -- SFH 20:32, 20 May 2006 (UTC)
 * Seeing as this flies right in the face of the entire Rule of Two thing, I think it's best to assume not unless/until told otherwise. Kuralyov 20:42, 20 May 2006 (UTC)
 * First, who was the other Sith Lord? Does she come before or after Maul? Second, Palpatine holds no laws before his own amibition. He's broken the rule of two before, he might do it again. -- SFH 22:29, 20 May 2006 (UTC)
 * She was more likely a Dark Acolyte. Nothingmore. Like Joruus C'BaothDarthMalus 06:49, 23 May 2006 (UTC)
 * Joruus was an insane clone. Vergere was initially accepted as a Sith Apprentice - there's a difference. QuentinGeorge 06:52, 23 May 2006 (UTC)
 * I just also came to a scary conclusion: Is death by Palpatine so bad that she would spend five decades with the Yuuzhan Vong? I know Palpatine made murder a form of art, but before you answer, remember, these are the Yuuzhies we're talking about here. -- SFH 20:00, 30 May 2006 (UTC)
 * If she was an apprentice, she would have to be after Maul but before Dooku. Looks like Palpy had more than one Jedi on the line. Stinkywookie 15:14, 31 May 2006 (UTC)
 * would that really shock anyone, this is Palpatine hes a Sith Lord, betrayel is the way the sith work, Vergere was intially a sith apprentice she tried to kill him, she failed she ran. Yes she ran to the Vong who in her view was the noly way she could keep the true sith way alive, and eventually pass it on. Jedi Dude
 * Doesn't shock me. I don't see the Rule of Two as a solid rule but more of a natural balance that Bane tried to make the norm.  Basically, if there is more than one, they gang up on the other until the other is dead.  Then there are two again.  I just like how it is looking like Vegere maybe turning the Sith into more of a Dark Grey Jedi as oppossed to pure evil.  Stinkywookie 19:31, 31 May 2006 (UTC)
 * My two Cents: While Vergere may have apprenticed under Palpatine (MAY), you cannot discount her reaction, seemingly VERY genuine and heartfelt, to the 'news' that Anakin became Darth Vader. "Oh no, could it not have been otherwise? What a WASTE." She gets very still. Very quiet, and I feel her shock is genuine. It's the only real time we see her reacting emotionally. I think what she says when asked if she is a Jedi or a Sith is very true. She is Vergere. Her reactions cannot be interpreted through the lens of Sith or Jedi because she is neither (although paradoxically I also want to think of her as an essentially good being). I think Jacen's fall is very much based around his perversion of what Vergere taught him, rather than springing from them. One only has too look at Jacen's behavior in Chiss Imperium space in the Force Heretic series to see that, then, when he was most under the influence of Vergere's teachings, he was also a very moral person. This is why the change in the Dark Nest trilogy feels both pronounced and forced. In short: Jacen's fall must be based on his own weakness rather than on a failure of Vergere's teaching (which actually hurts more as I identify myself very strongly with Jacen). Then again, "is it what the teacher teaches or the student learns?". 74.132.136.109 22:47, 21 June 2006 (UTC)
 * Something of note. If Vergere is such a Sith, then why did she tell Jacen and others that her loyalty was to the Galactic Republic, not this new "Alliance," etc.?  It would seem a Sith, for instance Count Dooku, would be especially against the Republic that it either saw as corrupt, if they were more "genuinely idealistic" Sith, or in the way of their quest for power and destruction of the Jedi, if they were more of the mold of Palpatine.  Vergere doesn't seem to BE Sith.  Perhaps she should be called the first Vong Knight.
 * Vergere is a sith, the whole point of her being sith is like Darth Vec is so that we understand now not all sith were greedy dibolocal evil people, this is Lumiyas point, this is what gets Jacen to be a sith. Sith are not all evil, thats the whole point of Lumiya and now Vergere. She says that Jacen could be the first sith to use his powers for good. Vong Knight? no way. shes a sith whether candidate for the mantle of the rule of two or a apprentice, it goes to how you look into it. but the fact remains shes established as a sith in Lecacy.. Jedi Dude 12:40, 5 July 2006 (UTC)
 * Look at the way Lumiya and Vergere seduce Jacen. It is very similar to how Palpatine's seduction of Anakin. Fact is they both want Jacen as a Sith. All Sith start out with the intent of doing good, but they are corrupted. Vergere and Lumiya both are corrupted, and are mixing truth with lies. The true reason Darth Vectivus wasn't heard of was that he lived when the Sith were thought extinct. Vergere and Lumiya must have been working together.l The Potentium leads to the darkside. Vergere was a FAILED apprentice. She was more of a Sith Acolyte or Disciple as Dooku's apprenticeship was soon after Maul's death. She was not Darth anything as far as we know. DarthMalus 04:25, 11 July 2006 (UTC)
 * Vergere wasn't exactly...corrupted, and she wasn't a failed apprentice, IIRC she left Sidious. Anyways, Lumiya's "seduction" of Jacen wasn't quite like Palpatines, it was more like Vergere's. Both are curious force users who aren't satisfied with the abilities of the Jedi and feel they aren't seeing everything. Anyways, this is off topic and not really pertinent to a talk page. --Sauron18 19:23, 11 July 2006 (UTC)
 * yer we need to get back ot the topic, what infobox are we going to use. i would go with sith. for reasons abov enad more. but like Sauron said this talk page isn't a discussion board. Jedi Dude 19:31, 11 July 2006 (UTC)
 * Out of respect for me (who feels like continuing the argument) is there a really good place for this to continue? Kegren&#39;Te 02:33, 12 July 2006 (UTC)
 * Uh. I've had a recent thought, IF Vergere is as Sith, I think it's possible she could be a kind of believer of Darth Traya, as Kreia said there will always be one. Now, stick with me, if she was a Sith, she Betrayed the Jedi and Jacen by not revealing it, and Jacen saving Jaina was a betrayal in itself, remember, Traya is the betrayer who will be betrayed in turn.  Merely a thought, think it over.75.22.150.255 07:38, 25 July 2006 (UTC)
 * PS, last edit was mine, sorry.RushinSundaws 07:39, 25 July 2006 (UTC)

Eye Color
Correct me if I'm wrong, but in every canonical source, and especially in the novels, aren't here eyes black? As in fully black? Sort of like this ?--Sauron18 05:39, 26 July 2006 (UTC)

Backwards knees?
When Vergere was introduced in the NJO series, she was referred to as having backwards knees. However, our birds (along with modern cats and most two-legged dinosaurs) have what appears to be a backwards knee but is really the ankle. Modern birds walk on their toes. This is also true of cats and two-legged dinosaurs.

Could the authors have been mixed up?Will 07:07, 18 August 2006 (UTC)


 * I think they have. --Tinwe 11:11, 4 October 2006 (UTC)

NPOV
I feel some of the info in the BTS is a bit biased. Not too badly, but nonetheless. If someone could subdue it a little, it would be great. (If I went to edit it myself the result might be just as biased, just the other way round, because I actually like Vergere. ;) --Tinwe 11:11, 4 October 2006 (UTC)
 * Actually it is only stating the facts. If you are bias is only facts, then is it really bias? Vergere was not a true Sith but she was following the dark path. That is what is said in the article. Itis simply the truth.

I disagree. Lumiya may have tried to convince Jacen of that, but that does not make it the truth. Will (talk -- contribs) 19:21, 16 October 2006 (UTC)

No these statements didnt come from Lumiya. These came from Vergere other objective sources and can be read in the NJO novels. She was a darksider.


 * Define "Vergere other objective sources". Also, you and the second poster did not sign. Will (talk -- contribs) 04:59, 21 October 2006 (UTC)

I agree. Remove that and the NPOV warning.
 * I don't see how it's NPOV, since it's stating facts and it provides evidence for it. The only thing that I might see the need to remove is the last sentence of the second to last paragraph: "While the previous clues hinted the dark nature of Vergere, this particular clue could be seen as the most important piece." Kuralyov 05:30, 21 October 2006 (UTC)

I really dont think there is any proof of vergere being a sith it is true that she does some things that are dark to jacen but i beleive that is from her time with the yuuzan vong corrupted her. the only proof of her being sith is lumiya. Also she tells jacen and luke that she is not a sith or a jedi i dont think she would lie to jacen and not tell him the truth 69.26.85.244 03:05, 4 November 2006 (UTC)


 * Oh you dont. If she is a Sith, yes she would. Right now all EU and OOU material supports the theory of her being a darksider.

Should Lumiya really be believed when it comes to Vergere? I was one of those who liked Traitor and didn't believe Lumyia in Traitor. She doesn't really corrupt Jacen during the NJO as that only happens after in DN and LOTF novels.


 * Take note that what she teaches Jacen is strikingly similar to the Sith teachings.

I looked at Vergere in depth in this essay and it presents an alternate view of her as she changes and the perception of her changes as well.

[] --Katana Geldar 00:01, 22 November 2006 (UTC)
 * She is, in fact a darksider, no way to get around it.
 * HAHAHAHAHAHA...That was the worst defense for Vergere I have ever read! Vergere in Traitor seemed more like a Sith than a Jedi. She presents a philosophy that is very close to that of Palpatine. She is a darksider. Sorry to the people that want to advocate relativeism and subjectivism. Those two philosophies are plain and simple wishful thinking for ignorant, unintelligent minds. Absolutes exist. Right and Wrong exist. According to Lucas the force has a dark and lightside.


 * I suggest reading the thoughts of Matt Stover himself on some of this stuff. http://www.inblogs.net/mattstover Check out his January 4th and January 6th entries. He makes an interesting case on George's thoughts and classifications.

Kreia Reincarnation?

 * Does anybody notice the paralells between Vergere and Kreia? Teachers, neutral powerful force users, Sith and Jedi, teaching their students unusual powers?  Could this be noted in BTS?  Wait a minute, its already there.  Could it be expanded upon, though?--Vladius Magnum
 * Can you name one single place in any film or EU source that mentions or even remotely indicates reincarnation of any character in the SW universe? No. - JMAS 18:40, 7 December 2006 (UTC)
 * Before you snap at me again, note that I never said that she was a Kreia Reincarnation. That was just a simple summary in the heading on the general lines of what I was saying.  I just said that they were very similar, and that deserved more recognition.  Look before you leap.  I'm not stupid, and I wouldn't suggest that theory, but I do suggest that you read more.
 * Agreeing with Vlad, he doesn't suggest actual spiritual reincarnation, but more the reincarnation of ideas. Kreia herself said there must always be a Darth Traya.  Maybe this reflects a side line Sith tradition in a similar vien to the Jedi/Grey Jedi relationship? {{User: CunningSmile}

Correction on Potentium Heresy

 * In the book where Zonama Sekot is first introduced (I believe it's Rogue Planet, but am not 100% certain), the heresy of the Potentium is introduced by Obi-wan. One thing he notes is that although it was branded as heresy, none of its adherents fell to the Dark Side.  If someone else has seen this mentioned in that book, it should be updated in this page and the other Potentium-referencing pages (including the Force page and the Potentium page. --BozoCat (Haven't made an account yet, but may.)


 * While this may not belong in the article, I suggest reading the thoughts of Matt Stover himself on some of this stuff. http://www.inblogs.net/mattstover  Check out his January 4th and January 6th entries.  He brings up some very interesting points of view which kinda kick the whole "Jedi/Sith" thing in the teeth.  Not to mention some of that crap quoted by the "George Lucas is god" people.