Wookieepedia:AC/Log/2011 November 5

Nov 05 15:06 <@CC7567>	Welcome, everyone, to AC Meeting 40 Nov 05 15:06 <@CC7567>	Thank you to Tommy and Jon for being the only two to show up Nov 05 15:06 <@CC7567>	First up, we have probed articles from last time Nov 05 15:06 <@Tommy9281>	It's all good Nov 05 15:06 <@Jujiggum>	Cheers Nov 05 15:06 <@CC7567>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Thannik Nov 05 15:06 <@CC7567>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:AC/Thannik Nov 05 15:06 <@CC7567>	http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Thannik&diff=3764080&oldid=3731405 Nov 05 15:06 <@Jujiggum>	Appears to be fixed Nov 05 15:06 <@Jujiggum>	Keep Nov 05 15:07 <@CC7567>	Keep, absentees vote keep Nov 05 15:07 <@Tommy9281>	Keep Nov 05 15:07 <@CC7567>	Thannik Kept Nov 05 15:07 <@CC7567>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Jinx Nov 05 15:07 <@CC7567>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:AC/Jinx Nov 05 15:07 <@CC7567>	http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Jinx&diff=3758151&oldid=3731409 Nov 05 15:08 <@Jujiggum>	Not familiar with what needed to be added, but Jang says he got it Nov 05 15:08 <@Tommy9281>	Let's have a look. Nov 05 15:08 <@CC7567>	I can vouch that everything's there Nov 05 15:09 <@CC7567>	Keep Nov 05 15:09 <@Jujiggum>	Cool Nov 05 15:09 <@Tommy9281>	Look's clean. Nov 05 15:09 <@Jujiggum>	Keep Nov 05 15:09 <@CC7567>	Absentees vote keep Nov 05 15:09 <@Tommy9281>	Keep Nov 05 15:09 <@CC7567>	Jinx kept Nov 05 15:09 <@CC7567>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Treaty_of_Coruscant Nov 05 15:09 <@CC7567>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:AC/Treaty_of_Coruscant_%28second_review%29 Nov 05 15:09 <@CC7567>	http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Treaty_of_Coruscant&diff=3763147&oldid=3731418 Nov 05 15:10 <@Jujiggum>	Requested changes have been made. Keep Nov 05 15:10 <@CC7567>	Keep Nov 05 15:10 <@Tommy9281>	Keep as well. Nov 05 15:10 <@Jujiggum>	It does have 3 redlinks, so we should keep an eye out, but it's good for now Nov 05 15:10 <@Tommy9281>	I trust him to get to them. Nov 05 15:11 <@Jujiggum>	Yeah Nov 05 15:11 <@CC7567>	Tope voted kill because of redirects, but they appear to have been fixed since then Nov 05 15:11 <@CC7567>	All other absentees vote keep Nov 05 15:11 <@CC7567>	Treaty of Coruscant kept Nov 05 15:11 <@CC7567>	Kay, on to new articles Nov 05 15:11 <@CC7567>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Kosh Nov 05 15:11 <@CC7567>	The Sand Tender: The Hammerhead's Tale has been recently added as an appearance. I've checked it, and the only character who may fit the description is called "some Imperial captain." Indeed, he commands the troops searching for the droids in Mos Eisley, but he is never explicitly identified as Kosh. If the AC think that there is enough evidence to assume that it's him, then the article will… Nov 05 15:11 <@CC7567>	...require a bit of updating, but until then, I'm going to withhold from touching it. QuiGonJinn Senate seal.svg(Talk) 20:36, October 25, 2011 (UTC) Nov 05 15:11 <@CC7567>	Update: Apparently, other sources, such as Star Wars: The Official Starships & Vehicles Collection 36, address the character from The Hammerhead's Tale as the Imperial Prefect of Tatooine. Just some more food for thought. QuiGonJinn Senate seal.svg(Talk) 15:34, November 4, 2011 (UTC) Nov 05 15:12 <@Jujiggum>	I honestly don't think that's quite enough to say that they're the same character Nov 05 15:12 <@Tommy9281>	I agree. Nov 05 15:12 <@CC7567>	Maybe a Bts note, if any, but it doesn't sound probeworthy Nov 05 15:12 <@Jujiggum>	I'm not familiar with the material, but from what Qui-Gon said, it sounds pretty speculative Nov 05 15:12 <@Jujiggum>	Aye Nov 05 15:12 <@Jujiggum>	Spare, with a suggestion for mentioning the possible appearance in the BTS? Nov 05 15:13 <@CC7567>	Sure Nov 05 15:13 <@CC7567>	Kosh spared Nov 05 15:13 <@Tommy9281>	Is there more evidence leading to him not being the same fellow? Is that what QGJ is saying? Nov 05 15:14 <@CC7567>	There's more evidence, but not necessarily plausible is what we are saying Nov 05 15:14 <@Tommy9281>	Alright. Nov 05 15:14 <@CC7567>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Pharl_McQuarrie Nov 05 15:14 <@CC7567>	Pharl McQuarrie - I've updated the article to what I believe to be a satisfactory level for GA standards and AC moot scrutiny. It may not be in the most prettiest state right now, but everything should be there in its most basic form. I'm going to go through and beautify everything further when I have more time. (I'm leaving the inuse tag on the article for now for this reason.) Toprawa and... Nov 05 15:14 <@CC7567>	...Ralltiir 08:29, November 5, 2011 (UTC) Nov 05 15:15 <@Jujiggum>	I'm willing to spare. I trust Tope to take care of it sufficiently Nov 05 15:15 <@CC7567>	Spare Nov 05 15:15 <@Tommy9281>	Spare. Nov 05 15:15 <@Tommy9281>Pardon any delayed responses, I'm back and forth at a stove Nov 05 15:15 <@CC7567> :P Nov 05 15:15 <@Jujiggum>	no worries Nov 05 15:15 <@CC7567>	McQuarrie spared Nov 05 15:16 <@CC7567>	starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Suba Nov 05 15:16 <@CC7567>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Suba Nov 05 15:16 <@CC7567>	Similar to Pharl McQuarrie above, intro might benefit from some expansion with Murder on the Executor info. Note that he is not explicitly identified by name, and the only mention of him is "gaining permission to enter (the murder victim's quarters) is as simple as asking the ship’s Chief of Security with no skill roll required," see if it can be safely concluded to be him. If not, then also... Nov 05 15:16 <@CC7567>	...fix Executor. I will leave this to Toprawa, and this might not even need to be tagged for GA review. Hanzo Hasashi 23:04, November 1, 2011 (UTC) Nov 05 15:16 <@CC7567>	Fully updated. Toprawa and Ralltiir 02:53, November 5, 2011 (UTC) Nov 05 15:16 <@Jujiggum>	Spare Nov 05 15:16 <@CC7567>	Updated, so spare Nov 05 15:17 <@CC7567>	Absentees vote same Nov 05 15:17 <@CC7567>	Suba spared Nov 05 15:17 <@CC7567>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Vindoo_Barvel Nov 05 15:17 <@CC7567>	I'm abstaining on voting to probe Vindoo Barvel, Chiraneau, DS-181-4, or any other article needing a Galaxies-related update. StarsiderSWG said originally when prompted that he would give us all further information on our respective articles, but he has apparently yet to do that, and I don't know what the status of this is at the moment. I suggest we give this more time in order to obtain... Nov 05 15:17 <@CC7567>	...any further info. Toprawa and Ralltiir 20:22, November 3, 2011 (UTC) Nov 05 15:17 <@Tommy9281>	I can get with that. Nov 05 15:18 <@Jujiggum>	Hmm Nov 05 15:18 <@Jujiggum>	That works for me Nov 05 15:18 <@CC7567>	Hmm... Nov 05 15:18 <@CC7567>	As long as StarsideSWG gets the info in a proper manner Nov 05 15:18 <@CC7567>	*proper...time Nov 05 15:18 <@Jujiggum>	Yeah Nov 05 15:19 <@Tommy9281>	Should he be given a deadline? Nov 05 15:19 <@CC7567>	If the update tags are still there at the next meeting, we should probe them if only to get others to check the source Nov 05 15:19 <@CC7567>	Next meeting, probably Nov 05 15:19 <@Jujiggum>	Make sure we leave him a message Nov 05 15:19 <@Jujiggum>	Aye Nov 05 15:19 <@CC7567>	Okay Nov 05 15:19 <@CC7567>	Are we voting the same for http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Chiraneau and http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/DS-181-4 Nov 05 15:19 <@CC7567>	? Nov 05 15:19 <@Jujiggum>	Yep Nov 05 15:20 <@Tommy9281>	Ok Nov 05 15:20 <@Jujiggum>	Appear to be the same situation Nov 05 15:20 <@CC7567>	Kay, Vindoo Barvel, Ciraneau, and DS-181-4 spared with the proviso that someone (person doing paperwork today, I suppose) lets StarsiderSWG know that he should provide the info by next meeting Nov 05 15:21 <@CC7567>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Krepauk Nov 05 15:21 <@Tommy9281>	Cool Nov 05 15:21 <@CC7567>	Update tag Nov 05 15:21 <@CC7567>	Probe? :P Nov 05 15:21 <@Tommy9281>	Has it been a month since the source release? Nov 05 15:21 <@Tommy9281>	lol yes Nov 05 15:22 <@Tommy9281>	It has Nov 05 15:22 <@Tommy9281>	probe Nov 05 15:22 <@CC7567>	:P Nov 05 15:22 <@Jujiggum>	Probe Nov 05 15:22 <@CC7567>	Krepauk probed Nov 05 15:22 <@CC7567>	Any more articles to discuss? Nov 05 15:22 <@Jujiggum>	Nothing from me Nov 05 15:22 <@Tommy9281>	Me neither. Nov 05 15:23 <@CC7567>	No discussion items, so we're done Nov 05 15:23 <@CC7567>	Thanks guys for coming :)