Forum:SH Archive/New things or all things on the lists for each film?

Wookieepedia &gt; Senate Hall &gt; 

I asked about this on the TPM talk page, but I'm repeating it here. What should go into the "locations/vehicles/characters" etc lists in each film article: new things only or all things in the film? Because Coruscant (filmwise) was first shown in ROTJ (and even that wasn't a first appearance, really), yet Finlayson put it back on the TPM page. Personally, I'm in favor of listing all things appearing in each film and marking "first appearance" for the ones relevant. For instance, the X-34 landspeeder appears in both TPM and ANH, and should be listed as such, with a "first appearance" note on the ANH page. VT-16 12:31, 11 September 2006 (UTC)