Forum:CT Archive/Individual Lightsabers

It's been two weeks since this, so I figured, "What the hey." It's been kind-of a loose end in my mind, and I hate to leave it as an unanswered question.

Suggested Lightsaber Notability Guidelines

 * 1) Is specifically named (like Darksaber and Jinzu Razor)
 * 2) Has a unique history of its own that does not fit into one character's article" (Like Anakin Solo's lightsaber)

If these lightsabers can fit easily into another page, as a small subsection or a footnote, then they don't really deserve a page no matter how well written. Depending on the success of this CT, the policy may apply to things like Luke Skywalker's backpack or Individual Jedi Starfighters.

Deleted or merged under proposed policy

 * Anakin Skywalker's first lightsaber
 * Kit Fisto's lightsaber
 * Tera Sinube's lightsaber
 * Palpatine's lightsaber
 * Windu's lightsaber
 * Dooku's lightsaber Dooku is a popular guy, but his lightsaber's large article is redundant with the wielder's history. It is notable for being Dooku's saber and little more.
 * Yoda's lightsaber
 * Darth Vader's lightsaber
 * Darth Zannah's lightsaber
 * Luke Skywalker's lightsaber
 * Aurra Sing's lightsaber
 * Mace Windu's lightsaber
 * Ahsoka Tano's lightsaber
 * Obi-Wan Kenobi's lightsaber
 * Ki-Adi-Mundi's lightsaber
 * Qui-Gon Jinn's lightsaber

Kept under proposed policy

 * Darksaber (lightsaber)
 * Anakin Solo's lightsaber Needs serious work, but fits policy
 * Anakin Skywalker's second lightsaber
 * Exar Kun's lightsaber Despite having the same problem as Dooku's saber, Exar Kun's saber was still used (briefly) long after Kun himself died.
 * Vima-Da-Boda's lightsaber The thing is 10,000 years old and had several owners, despite the article size. It's an artifact.
 * Freedon Nadd's short lightsaber
 * Sifo-Dyas's lightsaber

Suspect under proposed policy

 * Lumiya's lightwhip Could be merged into Lightwhip and Lumiya, but seems to have enough unique content to have made FA.

In Favor of Policy (as is)

 * 1) SinisterSamurai 21:43, May 8, 2010 (UTC)

Discussion
A lot of discussion already took place here, so try to add new stuff. If I'm missing a particular Lightsaber article, or you feel I've mis-catagorized one, mention it here.