Forum:SH Archive/Speculation?

Both pages Thul Fain & Unidentified Lamproid (Jabba's court) state that the said characters were present at the Battle of the Great Pit of Carkoon however according the film, they were not, and we currently have no proof that they were.

Both Decipher CCG images consist of production images photoshopped over background stills from Return of the Jedi. While I can agree that, if we truly infer information from these images, that the said characters at some stage in their lives travelled aboard a sail barge, we have no concrete evidence of when, which sail barge, or where exactly. While I could maybe (highly unlikely) bring myself to agree as per duck test that yes they're aboard the Khetanna or in Thul Fain's image that he was aboard the Khetanna somewhere in the Dune Sea, I can't agree that they were present at the Battle of Carkoon simply due to the background images. Neither of the cards even make mention of the Battle of Carkoon. I believe the statements on these two pages are inherently wrong.

It seems to go against our aim of being encyclopedic to assume that they were at the Battle of Carkoon just because of a background image that does not even depict the battle. What are other people's thoughts on this? Bo Shuda (talk) 11:42, September 20, 2013 (UTC)