Wookieepedia:AgriCorps/Log/2010 September 4

[2010-09-05 06:48:24]  Ok, now it's bidness time everyone. [2010-09-05 06:48:36]  Xd, I'm assuming you're familiar with our meetings are run for the most part? [2010-09-05 06:48:39]  how* [2010-09-05 06:48:58]  I think so. [2010-09-05 06:49:05]  Ok, we can always help you along the way. :) [2010-09-05 06:49:14]  First on the agenda is the probed articles from Meeting 25. [2010-09-05 06:49:20]  http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Battle_of_Kirrek_(Unification_Wars) [2010-09-05 06:49:25]  This is the discussion from the meeting page: [2010-09-05 06:49:35]  I've checked it, and it is correct.—Tommy 9281 14:49, August 19, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 06:49:36]      * In that case, could you explain why the original sourcing/version was incorrect? Toprawa and Ralltiir 21:58, September 1, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 06:49:38]            o I confess to my personal ignorance of the existence of First Battle between Jedi and Sith at the time of the article's nomination, and I suspect that was also the case with the nominator of the Battle of Kirrek.—Tommy 9281 22:24, September 1, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 06:49:40]                  + Very well. Thanks. Toprawa and Ralltiir 22:26, September 1, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 06:49:43]  http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:AC/Battle_of_Kirrek_(Unification_Wars) [2010-09-05 06:49:58]  Basically, the nominator got the preceding and following battles wrong. [2010-09-05 06:50:00]  And it was fixed. [2010-09-05 06:50:43]  Keep. [2010-09-05 06:50:49] <Xd1358> Keep it. [2010-09-05 06:50:54] <Darth_Burger> Keep. [2010-09-05 06:50:55] <ChackJadson> Keep [2010-09-05 06:51:02] <Cylka> Keep [2010-09-05 06:51:16] <Darth_Burger> All absentees vote keep. [2010-09-05 06:51:19] <Darth_Burger> Battle of Kirrek kept. [2010-09-05 06:51:30] <Darth_Burger> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Fall_of_Bastion [2010-09-05 06:51:37] <Darth_Burger> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:AC/Fall_of_Bastion [2010-09-05 06:51:47] <Darth_Burger> No change made. [2010-09-05 06:51:53] <ChackJadson> Kill [2010-09-05 06:51:55] <Xd1358> Kill [2010-09-05 06:51:56] <GrandMoffTranner> Kill. [2010-09-05 06:51:59] <Darth_Burger> Kill. [2010-09-05 06:52:00] <Cylka> Kill [2010-09-05 06:52:08] <Darth_Burger> All absentees vote keel. [2010-09-05 06:52:22] <Darth_Burger> that wasn't intentionally spelled that way, btw :P [2010-09-05 06:52:29] <Darth_Burger> Fall of Bastion killed. [2010-09-05 06:52:29] <ChackJadson> haha [2010-09-05 06:52:44] <Darth_Burger> Ok. [2010-09-05 06:52:56] <Darth_Burger> Moving on to new articles for our evil evaluations [2010-09-05 06:53:03] <Darth_Burger> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Battle_of_Rakata_Prime [2010-09-05 06:53:08] <Darth_Burger> LG issues, lacking context for vital things, perhaps a bit too subsectioned, Bts should include where the event first appeared and so on. -- 1358 (Talk) 17:27, August 16, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 06:53:32] <Xd1358> Uh, probe. [2010-09-05 06:53:33] <GrandMoffTranner> Probe. [2010-09-05 06:53:41] <ChackJadson> Probe [2010-09-05 06:53:54] <Cylka> Probe [2010-09-05 06:53:55] <Darth_Burger> Personally, I'm ok with the subsectioning [2010-09-05 06:54:04] <Darth_Burger> But everything else should be fixed. [2010-09-05 06:54:19] <Darth_Burger> All absentees vote probe. [2010-09-05 06:54:31] <Darth_Burger> Battle of Rakata Prime probed. [2010-09-05 06:54:43] <Darth_Burger> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Iridium [2010-09-05 06:54:53] <Darth_Burger> One unsourced item in the infobox, and quite a lot links to redirects. -- 1358 (Talk) 17:34, August 16, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 06:54:54] <Darth_Burger>    * Eyre seems to have fixed this one. -- 1358 (Talk) 20:28, August 20, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 06:54:56] <Darth_Burger>          o Yeah, the unsourced item was added by an anon. --Eyrezer 21:29, September 1, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 06:55:10] <ChackJadson> Keep [2010-09-05 06:55:21] <Xd1358> Spare? :O [2010-09-05 06:55:25] <GrandMoffTranner> Strike! [2010-09-05 06:55:31] <GrandMoffTranner> :p [2010-09-05 06:55:38] <Darth_Burger> Two absentees vote no probe. [2010-09-05 06:55:43] <GrandMoffTranner> But spare. [2010-09-05 06:55:51] <Darth_Burger> No probe as well [2010-09-05 06:55:53] <Cylka> Seems fine. Spare. [2010-09-05 06:56:13] <Darth_Burger> Iridium not probed. [2010-09-05 06:56:19] <Darth_Burger> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Drunost [2010-09-05 06:56:28] <Darth_Burger> No Bts, needs to be sourced due to more than one source. -- 1358 (Talk) 17:37, August 16, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 06:56:29] <Darth_Burger>    * There should also be a Description section that describes its place in the galaxy and whatnot. There also seems to be information in the intro and infobox not present in the body. Xicer9(Combadge) 18:31, August 22, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 06:56:31] <Darth_Burger>          o This should be fixed. A Christian 23:38, August 24, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 06:56:56] <ChackJadson> Keep [2010-09-05 06:57:02] <Darth_Burger> All absentees vote no probe [2010-09-05 06:57:09] <Xd1358> Keep [2010-09-05 06:57:10] <GrandMoffTranner> Keep. [2010-09-05 06:57:14] <Darth_Burger> Keep [2010-09-05 06:57:16] <Cylka> Looks good. [2010-09-05 06:57:19] <Cylka> Keep [2010-09-05 06:57:21] <Darth_Burger> Drunost not probed. [2010-09-05 06:57:29] <Darth_Burger> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Rainboh [2010-09-05 06:57:34] <Darth_Burger> Rainboh—Intro is less than one row, could probably use slight expansion. -- 1358 (Talk) 17:40, August 16, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 06:57:36] <ChackJadson> Probe [2010-09-05 06:57:39] -->| Jujiggum|Away (~chatzilla@cpe-76-185-7-74.tx.res.rr.com) has joined #wookieepedia-agricorps [2010-09-05 06:57:40] =-= Mode #wookieepedia-agricorps +o Jujiggum|Away by ChanServ [2010-09-05 06:57:41] <Darth_Burger> We have absentee consideratiion: [2010-09-05 06:57:44] <Jujiggum|Away> WOO HOO! [2010-09-05 06:57:47] <Jujiggum|Away> I'm here [2010-09-05 06:57:50] <Xd1358> Hello Jon. [2010-09-05 06:57:52] <ChackJadson> Jon! [2010-09-05 06:57:53] <GrandMoffTranner> Jon?!?! [2010-09-05 06:57:55] <Darth_Burger> Tommy says don't probe: Rainboh, because I think the intro is sufficient given the amount of content in the article.—Tommy 9281 20:45, September 1, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 06:57:56] <Darth_Burger> Hey Jugs. [2010-09-05 06:57:57] <Jujiggum|Away> whats up folks? [2010-09-05 06:58:02] <GrandMoffTranner> A meeting. :p [2010-09-05 06:58:03] <Cylka> Jugs. [2010-09-05 06:58:04] <Darth_Burger> Jugs, we're doing new articles. [2010-09-05 06:58:06] <Darth_Burger> We're on Rainboh. [2010-09-05 06:58:08] <Jujiggum|Away> cool [2010-09-05 06:58:19] <Darth_Burger> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Rainboh [2010-09-05 06:58:25] <Darth_Burger> Rainboh—Intro is less than one row, could probably use slight expansion. -- 1358 (Talk) 17:40, August 16, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 06:58:42] <Darth_Burger> Cav's comment: Probe: Battle of Rakata Prime, Rainboh (could probably be expanded further due to its inclusion in the TEA) [2010-09-05 06:58:51] <GrandMoffTranner> I'd say probe. [2010-09-05 06:58:52] <Jujiggum|Away> Probe [2010-09-05 06:58:57] <Xd1358> Probish. [2010-09-05 06:58:58] <Darth_Burger> We have four other absentee probes. [2010-09-05 06:59:01] <Darth_Burger> I vote probe as well. [2010-09-05 06:59:06] <Darth_Burger> Just add another sentence or two. [2010-09-05 06:59:07] <Cylka> Probe [2010-09-05 06:59:10] <Darth_Burger> Rainboh probed. [2010-09-05 06:59:20] <Darth_Burger> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Terephon [2010-09-05 06:59:27] <Darth_Burger> Bts could probably use some work, to include mentions of the sources and the appearances. The two-row section could be merged with another section, and TEA could be checked for grid coordinates. Also, several links to redirects. -- 1358 (Talk) 17:45, August 16, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 06:59:29] <Darth_Burger>    * Also suffering from underlinking, and I think that redlink in the inhabitants sections should also be put in the "native species" in the infobox, meaning it'd then have an infobox redlink, too. (Either that, or the subject should be de-linked entirely; I'm not sure whether it needs an article in this case). Jonjedigrandmaster (Talk) 12:40, September 4, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 06:59:41] <ChackJadson> Probe [2010-09-05 06:59:43] <Jujiggum|Away> Probe [2010-09-05 06:59:46] <GrandMoffTranner> Probe that one, too. [2010-09-05 06:59:57] <Cylka> Probe [2010-09-05 06:59:58] <Darth_Burger> Unanimous absentee probe. [2010-09-05 07:00:01] <Darth_Burger> Probe from me. [2010-09-05 07:00:17] <Darth_Burger> Terephon probed.. [2010-09-05 07:00:29] <Darth_Burger> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Taspan_II [2010-09-05 07:00:43] <Darth_Burger> Intro redlink. Xicer9(Combadge) 18:14, August 16, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 07:00:44] <Darth_Burger>    * And an infobox redlink. Jonjedigrandmaster (Talk) 12:40, September 4, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 07:00:48] <Cylka> probe [2010-09-05 07:00:50] <Jujiggum|Away> Probe [2010-09-05 07:00:52] <GrandMoffTranner> Probe. [2010-09-05 07:01:06] <Xd1358> Probe. [2010-09-05 07:01:12] <Darth_Burger> Unanimous absentee probe. [2010-09-05 07:01:15] <Darth_Burger> I vote probe as well. [2010-09-05 07:01:18] <Darth_Burger> Taspan II probed. [2010-09-05 07:01:27] <Darth_Burger> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Tresk_Im%27nel [2010-09-05 07:01:31] <Darth_Burger> # Tresk Im'nel—His Wizards article lists a few Force skills that may warrant a P&A (they should be mentioned somewhere in the article at least). First name usage as well. Xicer9(Combadge) 02:26, August 25, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 07:01:45] <GrandMoffTranner> You missed Gektl. [2010-09-05 07:01:58] <Darth_Burger> Oh [2010-09-05 07:02:00] <Darth_Burger> We'll come back :P [2010-09-05 07:02:04] <Xd1358> Heh. [2010-09-05 07:02:06] <GrandMoffTranner> Fine with me. :p [2010-09-05 07:02:07] <ChackJadson> Probe Tresk [2010-09-05 07:02:09] <Darth_Burger> Unanimous absentee probe for Tresk [2010-09-05 07:02:14] <ChackJadson> It skips right into the body [2010-09-05 07:02:14] <Jujiggum|Away> Probe Tresk [2010-09-05 07:02:15] <Cylka> Probe [2010-09-05 07:02:19] <GrandMoffTranner> Probe Tresk as well. [2010-09-05 07:02:29] <Darth_Burger> yeah, per Chack on the bio introduction [2010-09-05 07:02:44] <Darth_Burger> Someone note that on the probe page :P [2010-09-05 07:02:50] <Darth_Burger> Tresk Im'nel probed. [2010-09-05 07:02:59] <Darth_Burger> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Gektl [2010-09-05 07:03:02] <Darth_Burger> Gektl—Unsourced infobox item and may need update from Fatal Alliance. Xicer9(Combadge) 05:38, August 24, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 07:03:23] <Darth_Burger> Infobox has been sourced. [2010-09-05 07:03:25] <Xd1358> Seems to be updated. [2010-09-05 07:03:28] <GrandMoffTranner> Keep. [2010-09-05 07:03:29] <Jujiggum|Away> Keep -- I got everything I could find from Fatal Alliance [2010-09-05 07:03:36] <Xd1358> Keep per Jon. [2010-09-05 07:03:40] <Cylka> Spare [2010-09-05 07:03:42] <Darth_Burger> Absentees vote spare. [2010-09-05 07:03:43] <ChackJadson> Keep [2010-09-05 07:03:48] <Darth_Burger> Keep. [2010-09-05 07:03:54] <Darth_Burger> Gektl not probed. [2010-09-05 07:04:02] <Darth_Burger> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Unidentified_Jedi_(Battle_of_Alderaan) [2010-09-05 07:04:10] <Darth_Burger> # Unidentified Jedi (Battle of Alderaan)—Accoring to this interview with Robert Chestney, this unidentified Jedi is Satele Shan. Apparently at CV, the people running the TOR panel also identified her Satele. There was also an interview done with one of the TOR guys a while back where he specifically said the Jedi in the trailer was NOT Satele, but now all traces of that question are gone.... [2010-09-05 07:04:11] <Darth_Burger> ...Links to the interview are still around, but that specific comment has been removed. All of this may not be reason enough to merge the articles, as we should probably wait for official official word, but this is something the ACs should keep an eye on. Xicer9(Combadge) 20:13, August 29, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 07:04:13] <Darth_Burger>    * As a note, I believe that we should keep these articles separate until, like Xicer says, we have more official word on the matter. I only say this given the apparent contradictions, and I have added a short BTS note on the matter. Darth Trayus(Trayus Academy) 20:21, August 29, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 07:04:19] <Jujiggum|Away> Spare until we get official word [2010-09-05 07:04:27] <GrandMoffTranner> Per Jon. Spare. [2010-09-05 07:04:32] <Xd1358> Spare. [2010-09-05 07:04:38] <Darth_Burger> All absentees vote no probe [2010-09-05 07:04:46] <Cylka> Per Jon. Spare. [2010-09-05 07:04:50] <Darth_Burger> per Jugs [2010-09-05 07:04:59] <ChackJadson> Probe [2010-09-05 07:05:04] <Darth_Burger> Unidentified Jedi not probed. [2010-09-05 07:05:05] <ChackJadson> Ugh, wait [2010-09-05 07:05:08] <Darth_Burger> Yes? [2010-09-05 07:05:09] <ChackJadson> Ok, cool [2010-09-05 07:05:11] <ChackJadson> I meant keep :P [2010-09-05 07:05:14] <GrandMoffTranner> Heh. [2010-09-05 07:05:16] <Darth_Burger> haha [2010-09-05 07:05:17] <Jujiggum|Away> heh [2010-09-05 07:05:27] <Darth_Burger> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Chaf%27orm%27bintrano [2010-09-05 07:05:31] <Darth_Burger> # Chaf'orm'bintrano—Two fact tags in the infobox, the article itself could use a thorough copy-edit as well. JangFett (Talk) 20:24, August 29, 2010 (UTC) [2010-09-05 07:05:40] <ChackJadson> Probe [2010-09-05 07:05:42] <Darth_Burger> Ugh [2010-09-05 07:05:43] <Darth_Burger> God [2010-09-05 07:05:46] <Xd1358> Probe. [2010-09-05 07:05:47] <Darth_Burger> Kill now, please. [2010-09-05 07:05:48] <Jujiggum|Away> probe [2010-09-05 07:05:48] <GrandMoffTranner> Probe. [2010-09-05 07:05:52] <Cylka> Probe. [2010-09-05 07:05:54] <GrandMoffTranner> Though I do agree with Tope. :p [2010-09-05 07:05:55] <Xd1358> The orange links to redirects hurt my eyes. [2010-09-05 07:06:02] <Darth_Burger> yes [2010-09-05 07:06:04] <Jujiggum|Away> heh per Xd [2010-09-05 07:06:20] <Darth_Burger> Four absentee probes. [2010-09-05 07:06:24] <Darth_Burger> Chaf probed. [2010-09-05 07:06:43] <Darth_Burger> Ok. [2010-09-05 07:06:47] <Darth_Burger> We have non-agenda items. [2010-09-05 07:07:06] <Darth_Burger> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Gode_Takrab [2010-09-05 07:07:08] <Darth_Burger> has update tag [2010-09-05 07:07:24] <ChackJadson> P r o b e [2010-09-05 07:07:26] <Cylka> Probe [2010-09-05 07:07:28] <Darth_Burger> Probe. [2010-09-05 07:07:31] <Jujiggum|Away> I'm completely unfamiliar with the material [2010-09-05 07:07:38] <Xd1358> Probe. [2010-09-05 07:07:40] <GrandMoffTranner> Probe. [2010-09-05 07:07:40] <Jujiggum|Away> but I suppose probe so we can get it figured out [2010-09-05 07:07:45] <Darth_Burger> per Jugs [2010-09-05 07:07:50] <Darth_Burger> Gode Takrab probed. [2010-09-05 07:07:56] <ChackJadson> Aye, Jonny [2010-09-05 07:07:57] <Darth_Burger> Does anyone else have anything for our platters? [2010-09-05 07:08:04] <ChackJadson> Did you check the thingy? [2010-09-05 07:08:17] <Darth_Burger> yes [2010-09-05 07:08:18] <ChackJadson> I can never remember the name or where to find it :P [2010-09-05 07:08:20] <ChackJadson> Ok cool [2010-09-05 07:08:21] <Darth_Burger> that's where I found that dude :P [2010-09-05 07:08:32] <ChackJadson> Figured :P [2010-09-05 07:08:35] <Darth_Burger> Ok, moving on [2010-09-05 07:08:41] <Darth_Burger> We have no discussion items listed on the agenda. [2010-09-05 07:08:45] <Darth_Burger> Does anyone have any? [2010-09-05 07:09:00] <Cylka> I'll be paperwork bitch, but not log or minutes. I hate those. :P [2010-09-05 07:09:08] <Darth_Burger> I can do minutes. [2010-09-05 07:09:12] <ChackJadson> I have log [2010-09-05 07:09:21] <ChackJadson> Thanks, Cylka and Tope [2010-09-05 07:09:26] <Darth_Burger> That hereby concludes Meeting 26. Happy reviewing. And welcome to the AC, Xd. :)