Talk:Musical score

I disagree with the classification of the "Victory Celebration" piece at the end of Episode VI as diegetic.
I disagree with the classification of the "Victory Celebration" piece at the end of Episode VI as diegetic. I base this on several points.


 * 1) The fact that several localities are shown in the special edition ending (Coruscant, Cloud City, Naboo, etc.) while the music continues to play unabated.
 * 2) None of the instruments played by the Ewoks on Endor match the orchestration of this piece.
 * 3) None of the actions of the Ewoks playing their instruments line up with their soundtrack counterparts.  In other words, you don't actually "hear" the ewoks playing the instruments, hitting the storm trooper helmets, etc.
 * 4) The use of a choir by John Williams at the end of this piece.  There is not choir present on Endor (or any of the other localities shown during this sequence).

--Dormous