Wookieepedia:Inquisitorius/Log/2012 September 30

[09/30/12 02:26:27] <@Menkooroo>	Welcome, everyone! [09/30/12 02:26:38] <@Menkooroo>	First up, the old stuff [09/30/12 02:26:49] <@Menkooroo>	Hoth (Jedi Lord) [09/30/12 02:26:50] <@Menkooroo>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:Inq/Hoth_%28Jedi_Lord%29_%28second_review%29 [09/30/12 02:27:05] <@Menkooroo>	Purpilia updated it a while back, and I recently did the cleanup that was requested [09/30/12 02:27:16] <@Menkooroo>	no one seems to have any outstanding issues, and the note-leavers all said keep [09/30/12 02:27:18] <@Menkooroo>	I vote keep [09/30/12 02:27:22] <@IFYLOFD>	Keep [09/30/12 02:27:55] <@Menkooroo>	Quorum, even with Xd on the john [09/30/12 02:27:58] <@Menkooroo>	Hoth kept [09/30/12 02:28:05] <@Menkooroo>	Bevel Lemelisk [09/30/12 02:28:10] <@Menkooroo>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:Inq/Bevel_Lemelisk_%28second_review%29 [09/30/12 02:28:32] <@Menkooroo>	Reasons for extension: Large paragraphs of text identical across two articles (the other being Conan Antonio Motti), new updates not formatted properly. -- from Tope. Menkooroo (talk) 02:34, August 7, 2012 (UTC)     Identical text has never been a reason for status removal, as it isn't against site policy. It just means it wouldn't get votes on the nom page. NaruHina Talk Anakinsolo.png 00:18, September 23, 2012 (UTC) [09/30/12 02:28:39] <@Menkooroo>	In any case, I've rewritten and reformatted the paragraph in question. It's worded differently from Conan's, cite-web'd, free of redirects, etc. I believe the article is good to go. Menkooroo (talk) 14:08, September 24, 2012 (UTC) [09/30/12 02:28:56] <@Menkooroo>	Sooooo yeah the offending paragraph has been rewritten, reformatted, and cleaned up [09/30/12 02:29:07] <@Menkooroo>	Absentees all say keep [09/30/12 02:29:09] <@Menkooroo>	I say keep [09/30/12 02:30:47] <@Menkooroo>	!Floyd oy [09/30/12 02:30:48] <@Nuku-Nuku>	Menkooroo: Error: "Floyd" is not a valid command. [09/30/12 02:31:03] <@Menkooroo>	wait [09/30/12 02:31:05] <@Menkooroo>	Floyd oy [09/30/12 02:31:07] <@IFYLOFD>	KEEP [09/30/12 02:31:08] <@Menkooroo>	Yeah, that's better [09/30/12 02:31:16] <@Menkooroo>	Bevel kept. [09/30/12 02:31:18] <@Menkooroo>	Conan Antonio Motti. [09/30/12 02:31:20] <@Menkooroo>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:Inq/Conan_Antonio_Motti_%28second_review%29 [09/30/12 02:31:27] <@Menkooroo>	Same situation as Bevel [09/30/12 02:31:32] <@Menkooroo>	I cleaned up and rewrote the paragraph [09/30/12 02:31:39] <@Menkooroo>	and Jang filled out the Sources list [09/30/12 02:31:42] <@Menkooroo>	Absentees say keep [09/30/12 02:31:43] <@Menkooroo>	as do I [09/30/12 02:33:15] <@Menkooroo>	Floyd, thoughts? [09/30/12 02:33:48] <@Menkooroo>	Well we have quorum anyway with the absentees [09/30/12 02:33:49] <@Menkooroo>	Conan kept [09/30/12 02:33:53] <@Menkooroo>	Next up, Jaina Solo [09/30/12 02:33:56] <@Menkooroo>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:Inq/Conan_Antonio_Motti_%28second_review%29 [09/30/12 02:34:05] <@Menkooroo>	Ataru took care of both updates [09/30/12 02:34:07] <@IFYLOFD>	Keep all [09/30/12 02:34:11] <@Menkooroo>	Naru did some further cleanup that I requested [09/30/12 02:34:12] <@IFYLOFD>	This is no contest [09/30/12 02:34:30] <@Menkooroo>	Absentees say keep, as do I [09/30/12 02:34:32] <@Menkooroo>	Jaina kept [09/30/12 02:34:48] <@Menkooroo>	Adar Tallon [09/30/12 02:34:59] <@Menkooroo>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:Inq/Adar_Tallon [09/30/12 02:35:02] <@Menkooroo>	Intro has been expanded [09/30/12 02:35:10] <@Menkooroo>	Floyd, absentees, and I all say keep [09/30/12 02:35:12] <@Menkooroo>	Adar Tallon kept [09/30/12 02:35:14] <@Menkooroo>	Fairwind [09/30/12 02:35:27] <@Menkooroo>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:Inq/Fairwind [09/30/12 02:35:29] <@Menkooroo>	Intro has been expanded [09/30/12 02:35:29] <@IFYLOFD>	Keep [09/30/12 02:35:32] <@ecks>	Keep [09/30/12 02:35:40] <@Menkooroo>	Absentees agree! [09/30/12 02:35:42] <@Menkooroo>	Fairwind kept [09/30/12 02:35:48] <@Menkooroo>	Cody Sunn Childe [09/30/12 02:35:53] <@Menkooroo>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:Inq/Cody_Sunn-Childe [09/30/12 02:35:58] <@Menkooroo>	Redlink has been filled in [09/30/12 02:36:08] <@Menkooroo>	has been confirmed as belonging to a unique species [09/30/12 02:36:10] <@Menkooroo>	absentees say keep [09/30/12 02:36:12] <@Menkooroo>	I say keep [09/30/12 02:36:31] <@Menkooroo>	Floyd indicated "keep all" [09/30/12 02:36:34] <@Menkooroo>	Looks like Cody is kept [09/30/12 02:36:39] <@ecks>	keep [09/30/12 02:36:45] <@Menkooroo>	Everything is kept. [09/30/12 02:36:48] <@Menkooroo>	Beautiful. [09/30/12 02:36:50] <@Menkooroo>	Onto the new stuff. [09/30/12 02:37:01] <@Menkooroo>	Wedge Antilles [09/30/12 02:37:09] <@Menkooroo>	Needs updates from a novel and a short story [09/30/12 02:37:16] <@Menkooroo>	MJ will do it but wants us to probe anyway [09/30/12 02:37:34] <@ecks>	k, probe [09/30/12 02:37:47] <@Menkooroo>	GT, Cav, and Cal all say probe [09/30/12 02:37:52] <@IFYLOFD>	Probey dobey [09/30/12 02:37:55] <@Menkooroo>	I do too, which extends to Culator by proxy [09/30/12 02:37:58] <@Menkooroo>	in other words... [09/30/12 02:38:01] <@Menkooroo>	Wedge probed [09/30/12 02:38:15] <@Menkooroo>	No issues with Max (Bunny) [09/30/12 02:38:18] <@Menkooroo>	they were taken care of before the meeting [09/30/12 02:38:28] <@Menkooroo>	Kowakian Monkey-Lizard [09/30/12 02:38:34] <@Menkooroo>	severely lacking BTS. [09/30/12 02:38:42] <@Menkooroo>	and terrible linking. [09/30/12 02:38:51] <@IFYLOFD>	Probe [09/30/12 02:38:54] <@Menkooroo>	all absentees say probe [09/30/12 02:38:56] <@Menkooroo>	I say probe [09/30/12 02:39:05] <@ecks>	probe [09/30/12 02:39:11] <@Menkooroo>	Monkey-Lizard probed. [09/30/12 02:39:20] <@Menkooroo>	Bhindi Drayson [09/30/12 02:39:27] <@Menkooroo>	Ataru took care of the Mercy Kill update [09/30/12 02:39:31] <@Menkooroo>	but I had some grievances [09/30/12 02:39:41] <@Menkooroo>	"Can you clean it up a bit before the meeting? There are two separate refs for Mercy Kill, a number of redirects, and one quoteless section that has Mercy Kill for fodder. The bio could use another image, too; there's a long amount of imageless text after the Fall of Coruscant one." [09/30/12 02:40:04] <@IFYLOFD>	That's all minor stuff [09/30/12 02:40:11] <@IFYLOFD>	I don't that merits a probe [09/30/12 02:40:15] <@Menkooroo>	was taken care of anyway, apparently [09/30/12 02:40:18] <@IFYLOFD>	It could be taken care of in fifteen seconds [09/30/12 02:40:18] <@Menkooroo>	looking at the article again [09/30/12 02:40:29] <@Menkooroo>	a-ha! It's already done [09/30/12 02:40:32] <@Menkooroo>	In that case I say keep [09/30/12 02:40:47] <@Menkooroo>	Er, spare [09/30/12 02:40:49] <@Menkooroo>	Absentees all say spare [09/30/12 02:40:58] <@IFYLOFD>	Spare [09/30/12 02:41:26] <@Menkooroo>	going once [09/30/12 02:41:28] <@Menkooroo>	going twice [09/30/12 02:41:32] <@Menkooroo>	Bhindi spared. [09/30/12 02:41:35] <@Menkooroo>	Wraith Squadron [09/30/12 02:41:47] <@Menkooroo>	Needs a gigantic update for the new Wraith Squadron book. [09/30/12 02:41:52] <@Menkooroo>	Ataru has indicated that he will do it. [09/30/12 02:41:57] <@Menkooroo>	But I think we should probe anyway. [09/30/12 02:42:13] <@Menkooroo>	The update might necessitate reduxing. [09/30/12 02:42:35] <@Menkooroo>	I say probe [09/30/12 02:42:37] <@IFYLOFD>	Probe [09/30/12 02:42:39] <@Menkooroo>	Absentees say probe. [09/30/12 02:42:44] <@ecks>	probe [09/30/12 02:42:50] <@Menkooroo>	The Wraiths are probed. [09/30/12 02:42:59] <@Menkooroo>	Ton Phanan [09/30/12 02:43:09] <@Menkooroo>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Ton_Phanan [09/30/12 02:43:13] <@Menkooroo>	Needs a Mercy Kill update [09/30/12 02:43:26] <@Menkooroo>	Probably won't be a big update, but with Hav gone, I'm not sure if anyone is willing to do it. [09/30/12 02:43:38] <@IFYLOFD>	Then probe [09/30/12 02:43:39] <@ecks>	probe [09/30/12 02:43:43] <@Menkooroo>	probe [09/30/12 02:43:49] <@Menkooroo>	absentees save 1 say probe [09/30/12 02:43:52] <@Menkooroo>	Ton Phanan probed. [09/30/12 02:44:07] <@Menkooroo>	Shikkar [09/30/12 02:44:07] <@Menkooroo>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Shikkar [09/30/12 02:44:18] <@Menkooroo>	Needs an update from two sources. One of them is less than a month old, but the other is not. [09/30/12 02:44:35] <@IFYLOFD>	Probe then [09/30/12 02:44:44] <@Menkooroo>	Exact same deal for the next two [09/30/12 02:44:45] <@Menkooroo>	Keshiri [09/30/12 02:44:46] <@Menkooroo>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Keshiri [09/30/12 02:44:53] <@Menkooroo>	and Tahv [09/30/12 02:44:53] <@Menkooroo>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Tahv [09/30/12 02:44:54] <@ecks>	probe [09/30/12 02:44:58] <@Menkooroo>	All three? [09/30/12 02:45:00] <@IFYLOFD>	Non-me LtoS articles blow! [09/30/12 02:45:02] <@Menkooroo>	I say probe all three [09/30/12 02:45:05] <@IFYLOFD>	PROBE [09/30/12 02:45:06] <@ecks>	yeah yeah, all three [09/30/12 02:45:10] <@IFYLOFD>	THESE ABOMINATIONS SHOULD NOT EXIST [09/30/12 02:45:25] <@Menkooroo>	Most absentees say probe [09/30/12 02:45:26] <@Menkooroo>	no one says keep [09/30/12 02:45:30] <@Menkooroo>	All three probed. [09/30/12 02:45:42] <@Menkooroo>	Samoc Farr [09/30/12 02:45:43] <@Menkooroo>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Samoc_Farr [09/30/12 02:46:02] <@Menkooroo>	Warfare update isn't complete; Tope indicates that all is done save for some intro expansion [09/30/12 02:46:41] <@Menkooroo>	Cav says spare [09/30/12 02:46:43] <@Menkooroo>	GT says probe [09/30/12 02:46:52] <@IFYLOFD>	Spare [09/30/12 02:47:01] <@Menkooroo>	Xd has Cal's vote [09/30/12 02:47:09] <@ecks>	sprobe [09/30/12 02:47:21] <@ecks>	spare [09/30/12 02:47:39] <@Menkooroo>	Spare, but probe next time if it's not done [09/30/12 02:47:47] <@ecks>	*nod* [09/30/12 02:47:48] <@Menkooroo>	I have Culator's vote; spare wins the majority [09/30/12 02:47:52] <@Menkooroo>	Samoc spared [09/30/12 02:48:00] <@Menkooroo>	Great Sith War [09/30/12 02:48:09] <@Menkooroo>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Great_Sith_War [09/30/12 02:48:19] <@Menkooroo>	The Atlas introduced a ton of new battles on its maps [09/30/12 02:48:22] <@Menkooroo>	that haven't been added to the article yet [09/30/12 02:48:34] <@IFYLOFD>	Probe [09/30/12 02:48:39] <@Menkooroo>	It's on the RFAN page, but we can vote to remove it by saying probe [09/30/12 02:48:45] <@Menkooroo>	especially since it has objections more than three weeks old [09/30/12 02:49:02] <@Menkooroo>	I say probe [09/30/12 02:49:29] <@ecks>	probe [09/30/12 02:49:44] <@Menkooroo>	Most absentees say probe [09/30/12 02:49:48] <@Menkooroo>	Cav wasn't sure due to the RFANness [09/30/12 02:49:56] <@Menkooroo>	Great Sith War to be removed from RFAN and probed [09/30/12 02:50:02] <@Menkooroo>	Spiker [09/30/12 02:50:02] <@Menkooroo>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Spiker [09/30/12 02:50:07] <@Menkooroo>	The only issue was taken care of by Naru [09/30/12 02:50:09] <@Menkooroo>	spare [09/30/12 02:50:15] <@ecks>	spare [09/30/12 02:50:35] <@Menkooroo>	I crossed it out [09/30/12 02:50:39] <@Menkooroo>	It's kinda already been spared :P [09/30/12 02:50:52] <@Menkooroo>	going once... [09/30/12 02:50:54] <@Menkooroo>	going twice... [09/30/12 02:50:55] <@Menkooroo>	spared [09/30/12 02:51:04] <@Menkooroo>	Aaaaaaand that's everything. [09/30/12 02:51:09] <@Menkooroo>	Anyone have any new articles? [09/30/12 02:51:13] <@IFYLOFD>	NO [09/30/12 02:51:20] <@ecks>	did you check the maintenance page? [09/30/12 02:51:24] <@Menkooroo>	Ah, right [09/30/12 02:51:36] <@ecks>	http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:Inq/FA_maintenance_issues?t=20110515002055 [09/30/12 02:51:39] <@Menkooroo>	I checked it a few days ago; let's see if there's anything new [09/30/12 02:51:47] <@Menkooroo>	Xoxaan [09/30/12 02:51:51] <@Menkooroo>	but the source is less than a month old [09/30/12 02:52:02] <@Menkooroo>	Pellaeon, which is currently on redux [09/30/12 02:52:10] <@ecks>	spare xoxaan for now [09/30/12 02:52:24] <@Menkooroo>	aaaaaaand just the other ones on redux [09/30/12 02:52:24] <@Menkooroo>	that's all [09/30/12 02:52:29] <@Menkooroo>	yeah, spare Xoxaan for now [09/30/12 02:52:47] <@Menkooroo>	No new articles, then. [09/30/12 02:52:52] <@Menkooroo>	I have a couple of other comments [09/30/12 02:52:54] <@Menkooroo>	for new business [09/30/12 02:52:58] <@Menkooroo>	just two minutes. Bear with me! [09/30/12 02:53:09] <@Menkooroo>	I mean... [09/30/12 02:53:10] <@ecks>	more salary? [09/30/12 02:53:17] <@Menkooroo>	Yes, we all need raises. [09/30/12 02:53:25] <@ecks>	full support [09/30/12 02:53:36] <@ecks>	we'll have to cut from the EC's funding [09/30/12 02:53:41] <@Menkooroo>	I've been talking to Tommy. He sends his regards to everyone and his regrets that he can't be active right now. [09/30/12 02:53:58] <@Menkooroo>	Some RL stuff has been kicking his ass, including the loss of all of his digital data [09/30/12 02:54:07] <@Menkooroo>	He hopes he can be active again soon. [09/30/12 02:54:17] <@ecks>	:( [09/30/12 02:54:55] <@Menkooroo>	The RFAN page: Something we should discuss at the next meeting, perhaps. It was a great idea when we were still attempting to get a daily FA on the Main Page [09/30/12 02:55:06] <@Menkooroo>	But now that we're firmly onto two a week, it's kind of outlived its usefulness. [09/30/12 02:55:14] <@IFYLOFD>	I don't think necessarily [09/30/12 02:55:17] <@Menkooroo>	It sits gathering cobwebs, and we might be better off just scrapping it. [09/30/12 02:55:20] <@ecks>	from what I've seen, it's more or less completely dead [09/30/12 02:55:28] <@IFYLOFD>	I still love the idea [09/30/12 02:55:45] <@Menkooroo>	It IS a good idea... but 2007-quality usually makes reviewing more of a chore than one hopes [09/30/12 02:55:53] <@Menkooroo>	Even if we are onto 2008 ones now [09/30/12 02:56:23] <@Menkooroo>	If we scrap it, anything there with outstanding issues can be put on probation [09/30/12 02:56:27] <@Menkooroo>	and the rest just set free [09/30/12 02:56:34] <@Menkooroo>	Anyway, something to think about for next time. [09/30/12 02:56:50] <@ecks>	yeah, *something* needs to be done with it [09/30/12 02:57:25] <@Menkooroo>	I'll draft a proposal for the next meeting. [09/30/12 02:57:35] <@Menkooroo>	That's all I have. We have a new member; I'll send him an e-mail just to confirm that he wants in. [09/30/12 02:57:43] <@Menkooroo>	Also, check out this link: http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:Inq/Inquisitorius_bylaws [09/30/12 02:58:07] <@Menkooroo>	Tope was hoping to draft up some actual bylaws and have us ratify it at a meeting, but for now, let's just follow the schedule he's laid out. [09/30/12 02:58:12] <@Menkooroo>	Xd is on paperwork this time [09/30/12 02:58:18] <@Menkooroo>	I'm on tap for scheduling the next meeting