Talk:List of planets/Legends

I have disassembled this list into bare minimums. All planets will link to their articles, with no descriptions. Keep with this format please. -- Riffsyphon1024 20:57, 2 May 2005 (UTC)

I propose that planets be marked with regional tags, e.g., 'Core Worlds', 'Outer Rim planets', etc. These could be sub-cats of Planets. --GenkiNeko 14:21, 3 Apr 2005 (EDT)
 * Alphabetical is really the best way to deal with this article. I have already copied lists of planets from TheForce.net and am waiting for a response from the author of their CUSWE. There are roughly 5000 planets in there.
 * As for detailing regions, this can be done in the Catalogue of celestial bodies created by Shadowtrooper. -- Riffsyphon1024 17:33, 3 Apr 2005 (EDT)
 * The author has not responded. Should I try again or go ahead with a move? -- Riffsyphon1024 13:28, 8 Apr 2005 (EDT)
 * I'm not sure about moving it yet. However, (I think you already know this, but I'll go there anyway) if you move them now, just know that the people from CUSWE reserve the right to request that the info be removed. Shadowtrooper 18:52, 8 Apr 2005 (EDT)
 * The only things I am taking are the lists of the planets (the names), not the info within them. Certainly acknowledging that a set of planets exist in that particular order is not a violation of copyright. Refer to my user page for more on this. -- Riffsyphon1024 23:43, 18 Apr 2005 (UTC)
 * Lists are generally not eligible for copyright. For instance, you can't copyright a phonebook organized alphabetically. Copyrights require a minimum of creative effort. Now, if you organized it by favorite color, you'd have a case.--Eion 06:06, 27 Apr 2005 (UTC)

I have posted all the lists now. Hope you Wookieepedians like it. -- Riffsyphon1024 19:14, 1 May 2005 (UTC)
 * WOW. When people complain about Naboo not showing up in the OT, I always say "Come on, it's a big galaxy&mdash;how many planets do you think there are?" Now I have a link. :-D -- Aidje 14:51, 2 May 2005 (UTC)
 * Very difficult to read the Planets of Star Wars article.

-- 222.152.236.155 17:00, 6 May 2005
 * How so anonymous one? I can read it just fine. -- Riffsyphon1024 05:09, 6 May 2005 (UTC)
 * I think it's much better read when looking for something specific. That, or just read the blue ones. --Fade 07:34, 6 May 2005 (UTC)

Notice on article
Why is this notice on the article rather than on the talk page?:

''I have disassembled this list into bare minimums. All planets will link to their articles, with no descriptions. Keep with this format, but make the planet names in parentheses redirects to the planet they are next to. -- Riffsyphon1024 05:20, 1 May 2005 (UTC)

I though that was what talk pages were for: information regarding the article and its construction that someone who merely wanted to read the article wouldn't care about. -- Aidje 19:58, 2 May 2005 (UTC)
 * Just making it apparent to those who wanted to edit it while I was working on it, and introducing the new format. -- Riffsyphon1024 19:35, 2 May 2005 (UTC)
 * Okay, that makes sense. I just didn't want to (re)move your instructions without saying anything. -- Aidje 19:58, 2 May 2005 (UTC)

Planets in parenthesis
What is the purpose of having these link to the planets next to them? Why not just eliminate this extra link since it's redundant, being merely an additional redirect? Of course, the redirect could still be created, but I see no reason for it to be a link on this page. All it will do is confuse people by causing them to open the same article twice. -- Aidje 14:58, 2 May 2005 (UTC)
 * Yes, we can create the redirect and then erase those from the list. -- Riffsyphon1024 19:35, 2 May 2005 (UTC)
 * Okay. I see that the rewritten instructions clarify the matter. Thanks. -- Aidje 19:56, 2 May 2005 (UTC)
 * Now it's redundant because I just finished redirecting all the planets myself. ;D -- Riffsyphon1024 04:54, 4 May 2005 (UTC)

Links
Does each planet need a link, if many of them couldn't concievably be more than a substub? The way we have it now, the the links are taking up a lot of space, and it linking implies that an article to the link is possible, if not desired.-LtNOWIS 02:43, 4 May 2005 (UTC)
 * It's to allow people to fill in information outside of the oh so annoying list required on Wikipedia. As this is a Wiki just for Star Wars, we can afford to give each planet its own page, even if only a short one. And if all the information available is listed, even if it is only a sentence, it is not a stub.--Eion 02:46, 4 May 2005 (UTC)
 * Every planet gets an article. Simply put. -- Riffsyphon1024 04:53, 4 May 2005 (UTC)

Holocron
After snooping around the StarWars.com forums, I have found an interesting fact: Tasty Taste only has entries for 3,033 planets in the Holocron. So it seems 1,066 of the planets on this page are not recognised by Lucasfilm. --Imperialles 14:16, 20 May 2005 (UTC)
 * Hmm, interesting. It's possible that they missed a few... but over 1,000? lol. --Beeurd 16:44, 20 May 2005 (UTC)
 * Many older items do not have a single holocron entry. I can't speak from fact as far as planets go, but on this page Tasty had this to say in reference to starships, which I suspect would also apply to planets:
 * But for older entries, such as minor ships from the West End Games RPG or the X-wing videogames, the ships are lumped together in a single entry by source, with little or no details. If those ships are used in a later source, they are then given their own entry.
 * jSarek


 * I know what the problem is now. Eion counted 4100 planets by using Microsoft Word's word counter. What he didn't realize was that it counted every word, not individual lines of text as he has hoped, which is why the number is larger. Alderaan would be one word, but New Alderaan would be two, and he would take that as two planets, which is not the case. So the Holocron is correct. -- Riffsyphon1024 20:36, 20 May 2005 (UTC)

Riff
I seem to be unable to move this to List of planets, so could you do it, Riff? --Imp 00:26, 19 Jul 2005 (UTC)

Bullets
Should this list be bulleted? I would do it, if nobody objects. The current format is rather untidy looking. Or perhaps in columns?
 * Absolutely not. This format is the only way to keep the page size as small as possible. -- Riffsyphon1024 00:41, 14 Aug 2005 (UTC)

An idea for Lists and categories
I have no idea how to do this, but I have an idea to propose. When you hit a link in a list, it takes to that article, and at the bottom of the article are two links, "previous article in list" and "next article in list." Could also work for categories. Is this doable? Is there a short and easy way to do this?
 * That would take too much time and is useless when a person can still get to Category:Planets via that planet's page. -- Riffsyphon1024 00:42, 14 Aug 2005 (UTC)

Help Please;)
I've done a lot of planets, but there are still over 800 to do. Any help would be appreciated. I have listed below the planets, moons, asteroids, and stations which still need articles. If you could do even one or two, thx! After making an article, please remove the name you did off the below list:

Gabredor III Gateway Space Station (Starlye Station) New Jinda New Shella Nigel IV Nixor Panna mud moon of Panna Pyria VI-D Ques Raskane IV Reega Regel Eight Retep IV Rigel-12 Rim 3 Roche Skip 1 Skip 2 Skip 3 Skip 5 Skip 6 Skip 8 Skip 52 Skip 72 Quay, moon of Sriluur Suarbi 7 Sulorine (Suolriep) Tamber Tanger Tao-Grant Taria II Tarsa Tas-La Tavya Tel I Tel II Tel III Tel IV Tillo Trindello Triton Tumus Vatta IV Vedis IV Yen-2 Welarn Sileron Vex Major Vinzen Neela 5 Vorian Four Wizar II Wyndigal 2 Xandil VII Xaza IV Xerton 9 Xuaquarres IV Yershaim III Yetoom Na Uun Uhanayih Yibikkoror Yitheeth Y'Trella Yuga 2 Yunkor IX Zebitrope IV Tieos Midani Vuchelle Repea Vagran Kail Kir Knolstee Mall'ordian Mos R'alla Reltooine Tol Ulicia Lenniera Vakkar Lorimax Kktkt L'at Nanta-Ri Woqua Maphus Tria Selnesh Shibric Tramanos Oorn Tchis Odos Arat Fraca Va'art Walin'or Ord Antalaha Uviuy Exen Obica Pallaxides Ord Sabaok Phracas Sanjin Sifuchi Rodaj New Canistel Ilimardon Jeyell Kaliska Lanthe Mowgle Nar Bo Sholla Ord Klina PDC3141-02 Rafft Refgar Rrulinn Sappire Sev Tok Wilpiet Zuliria Iyred Mirshilan Murkhana Neary Nez Peron Ongella Ord Namurt Phoebus Saarn Sabrix Shiffrin Sufezz Talu Tebru Trassitan Vengler Vorusku Tholon Morcanth Osseriton Aesolian Alakatha, moon of K'vath 5 Algar Ank Ki'Shor Ansek Arden Arsteni Bantoo Asteroid Cluster Droxu Aviprine Axtria Bador Barcola Bellatrig Balanor Barenth Moons of Baroli Blathar Blathar III, moon of Blathar Callonia Calonica Carnth Carsanza Carz ice moon of Glakka Glakka Ceti 597 Chabosh Charenthoth Charis Choi Chromovon Chryya Chynoo Austan Asteroid Cluster Clar Clendora Cols Coomputu Corg Belt Corjain Coronar Corri Corva Yag Cotellier Cuirilla Cujicor Cuthbern Daemen Dahvil Daluba Dancreti Dargulli Darsie Daslkehnt Davirien Deathmoon DeGerrillion Doulos Demigue Deminol Demnadi Denbo De'nel Deneter Dennaskar Derf Derr Derricon Desargorr Dilbana Dithanune Dix'thaar Doaskin Dodz Donoa Dorajan Dorsis Draria Dravione Duhrib Asteroids Dreve Droecil Dronseen Dulathia Dulin Durgeon Duron Ealor Eskaron Eckless Eczar Ediorung Eedog Eislo Eliad Elokas Elsho Embaril Emmer Belt Enaleh Enarc Endoraan Endovan Enenpa Enet Entuur Ephemera Erai Eredin Erinar Ertegas Fadden Fangol Maltorian Mining Belt Farboon Farsellah Farstey Fendry Fenn Fenves Ferrhast Ferxani Fether Fluwhaka Fodro Fodurant Fokask Foless Fondurant Fornow Freliq Frewwil Friijillis Frisal Fwatna Gaios Gandolo Gandolo IV, moon of Gandolo Galltine Galtea Gandalla Ganlihk Ganthel Garia Garn Garrthinius Garsala Gartana Gascon Gathus Gauther D8-Red Base Gendoraan Genon Fortay Gestron Gettiarn Gibbela Glade Glom Tho Golh Gondagali Gorbah Gorlan Gorm Gorta Gortamni Gorth Graal'diin Grakouine Grall Grandeel Grathus Greater Galam Greater Marianas Tertiary Kesmere Had Abbadon Hadlress Hali Hanchin Breshkall Hapuntep Harbin-re Harazod Hast Hazzard Helisk Hethar Hettsk Hewl Hiffis Hilo Hino-111 Hirin Hovan Hovan 99, moon of Hovan H'ken Hologram Fun World Homon Hoylin Houll Hultomo Hyder Hypotria Ibanjii Ifron Ihopek Iktotchon Imoco Indellian Intran Ios Iqobal Irith Isde Naha Issarga Ivatch Jalarren Jangelle Janodral Mizar Jaresh Jaroona Jarsatt Javis-12 Jinathik Jestan Jhensrus Jinet Jodaka Jofoger Joodrudda Jomon Jurzan Justa Kaa Kalab Jiroch-Kalok Klaymore 4-2 Kammia Kamur Karatha Karavis Karoliston Kashir Kas Kassido Kastin K'ath Kay-Gee Kelliadu Kendamar Kevron Keryt Keskin Ketal k'Farri Kholes Kich Kins Kiilimaar Killaniri King's Galquek Kintoni Kalki Kalki's Braid Kanawyn Belt Kissarm Kiskin Kismaano Klatoon Kluistar Knores Koaan Kobal's World Kobbahn Kolos Moon Koratas Korad Kordu Korfin Kormoran Korriz Kostra Kraten Kreeling Krenhner Krnay Kronas Kuantar Versieds Vessar asteroids Kuminphal Kur Kumru Kvabja Kwannot KyLessia Kyryll's World Ladro Laertos Laim Laut Lifemoon Langoona Lankashiir Lanthrym Latharra Latoma Laud Lesser Galam Lessuris Lesu Lexrol Liintaar Liok Little Capella Lish XI, moon of Lish Magresh Mayvitch 7 Midakinos Midakos Mim Lonatro Londori Longwind Lorardian Loretto Lorrad Lota Loth Lo'Uran Loxizhra Lucrenn Lununmo M4-78 Maccent Mairne Majilop Makksre Makthierse Malanose Malkii Manalin Carto Asteroid Belt Manforgon Mangez Mantarran Mapuzo Skynara Marmoth Maro Della Marotan Masalou Mastala Metacom Mattri asteroids Mattri (Matarri) Maxca Medepiest Medth Menkooro Merikon Mexeluine Mila Millinar Milyvane Mindemir Minntaa Mira Mirshaf Miyuu Moer Moll Moraices Movris Myomar Najarka Namore Nanth'ri Nar Narth Natinati NCW-781 Nelfrus Nellac Kram Neocomora Nepoy Neree New Cylimba Nichen Niian N'ildwab Ninn Niran Noonar Nopsin Norclune Notak Nur Nurstin Off-Canau Ogoth Tiir OM813A Omakaton Ohratuu Olabria Oligatz Omar Ondus Onuf Ookbat Ooo-sek Or Tuma Ord Bueri Ord Dorlass Ord Mynock Ord Segra Ord Simres Ord Tasson Ord Torrenze Ord Traga Ord Wylan Ord Zat Ordnandell OrulShai III, moon of Gyosha Pharnas Orma Orn Kios Orroman Orryxia Osirrag Otranto Outpost Ozu Pako Ramoon Parada Paramatan Parein II 4 Partold Parthis Pasmin Pavilion Pedducis Chorios Peirs Pellastrallas Pelutt Plah Primor Relephon Moons Qetix Qetix IV, moon of Qetix Radeon Redilos Phosphura Belt Pendari Peridon's Folly Perilious Petrakis Phateem Phemis Serianan asteroids Fyrth Asteroid Field Graewyn Pinoora Pirik Pkihantri Plesstil Plexis Faa Coins of Gauha Velsor's Ring Polixi Porchello Polos Port Evokk Port Haven Port Jerrell Poytta Praidaw Presteen Puloorn Pyjridi Pyros Sagresh Seldibia Sequal Misnor Moon Lady Moratrig Mortav Mrykos Mutar-Horan Nekotrig Nerit Qlothos Q'Maere Q'mara Qualtrough Quanton Quian Quyste Raamen Rachuk Radix Randon Rangorah Rannon Rantorin Rasterous Ravaath Reef Refnar Reginard Rellnas Relkass Rehn Relus Remitik Rena Renas Renegg Renforia Renforra Rentalles Resti Kel Reyna Reynon Rhilithan Rigoran Rivvidu Sarnikken Belt Ronyards Rorgam Rove R'terleD'er Rue Ruisto Rya Ryl Ryloon Rymm Ryvellia Safe Home Salltine Saloth Salteract Samarine Province Santarine Arah Belt Sardoran Sarranket Sartoy Seline Sellasas Senna Serenity Asdroni, moon of Rhigar Rhigar Rhigar 3, moon of Rhugar Ronay Serpine Shalam Shallow March Shallow Reach Shatuun Shesharile Shesharile 5, moon of Shesharile Shesharile 6, moon of Shesharile Shimmer Shintel Shuldene Shumavar Shumogi Sinded Sirdar Skann Skartis Skone Smarck Socco Sochi Solacton Solanus Somawa Sondarr Syngia Moon Tallakron Tanatrig Syvris Nightsinger's Orb Sorfina Sorimow Speco Spirador Spoi Spunchina Stassia Steelious Stovax Sumarin Swarquen Syned Talesia Talita Tallaso Tallek Tamboon Tanalou Tanthior Tar Morden Tarastra Taraloon Tashtor Seneca Tasrin Tauber Taul Tavitz Te Hasa Tedel Tekurr'k Telkadis Telil Menin Terana asteroids Tempay Tenek Tentrix Praxlis Thalemute Theal Thermon Thomquizarr Thomork Thoran Thorsgild Thosa Thrantin Threfal Thrugii Tibro Tierell Tifnyl Timbra Ott Tinallis Tintel Tiragga Tirsa Togominda Tol Ado To-phalion Torize Torpris Torve Tothis Tragrud Trallan Trammen Tran Mariel Tranthellix Udine asteroids Trebela Tresidiss Tridius Trif Tuvvet Trosh Truuzdaan Tue Tujiamoor Tun Tuulab Ulbasca Unillian Uridia Velga Prime, moon of Velga Velga Tyshapahl Tytun Tzarib U'Dray Uhltenden Ulda Fray Uriek Corus Vaenrood Valera Vandron Varhus Varlinaar Vasch Vaykaaris Vatleria Venaari Vendred Vex-Shel Venzeiia 2 Prime Verdanth Vessitoar Vizcarra Vlemoth Port Vob Vobos Woern's Asteroid Voniss Voorlach Voorsbain Vornax Voss Vosteltig Vryssa Warmoon Vulcar Vunak Vundaria Vuzsa Vykos Wann Tsir Weerden Wei Wodenstam Worru'du Wranag Wrea Wyveral Xend Xerxes Xiunsrus Yabol Opa Yalln Yaronn Yeshocq Yetnis Yhifar Yhuli Yityl Yntrann Yoggoy Yuka Yorn Skot Yurb Yutusk Zarsteck Zelakesh Harrod's Planet Yuvern

Lists
Since lists like this one and the List of Jedi get huge, especially in their current format, wouldn't it be a good idea to have a disambig page for the list, with links to, say, List of Planets (A-M) and List of Planets (N-Z)? --Fade 16:33, 26 Nov 2005 (UTC)
 * Or, they should be grouped by location (ex. Deep Core, Core Worlds, etc.). Admiral J. Nebulax 17:21, 26 Nov 2005 (UTC)
 * I don't think that's as handy for referential purposes, though. It's more likely you know the name of the planet than its location in the Galaxy, especially considering that many people looking for the planet in the first place would only have minimal knowledge of it. --Fade 12:03, 27 Nov 2005 (UTC)
 * Or, they could be arranged in both ways. Admiral J. Nebulax 12:22, 27 Nov 2005 (UTC)
 * Yea why be forced to go with one format when we have all the room in the internet? (I still think we should have stuck to my old format instead of listing them all vertically.) -- Riffsyphon1024 23:27, 27 Nov 2005 (UTC)
 * What was your format? Admiral J. Nebulax 23:29, 27 Nov 2005 (UTC)
 * If you look right above this section, it looked like that, with each planet under its letter. One page could hold all the planets of a letter within a giant block, and maybe two or more depending on the size of the letter blocks. -- Riffsyphon1024 23:38, 27 Nov 2005 (UTC)
 * Then it should be like that, in my opinion. Admiral J. Nebulax 23:46, 27 Nov 2005 (UTC)
 * Care to ask JustinGann why he decided to lay it out as this current format? -- Riffsyphon1024 23:48, 27 Nov 2005 (UTC)
 * I think you should ask him that. After all, that was your format, not mine. Admiral J. Nebulax 23:50, 27 Nov 2005 (UTC)