Wookieepedia:Comprehensive article review

 From time to time, a comprehensive article may need to be reviewed and possibly stripped of its status.

Comprehensive article review rules
 * 1) Any user may nominate an article for removal. In order to do so, the user must place the Cacleanup template on the article in question and list grievances against the article on the review page. If no grievances are provided with the nomination, the nominating user should be contacted to ask for objections; the nomination may be deemed frivolous if no objections are provided within 48 hours. Frivolous removal nominations, defined as nominations without objections 48 hours after contacting the user or any nomination clearly made in bad faith without any remotely valid objections (e.g. "this guy doesn't deserve status because he's a jerk"), may be unilaterally removed by any EduCorps member or admin and should not be archived (this is to prevent users from repeatedly nominating the same article and clogging the milestones template on that article's talk page, as well as to deny recognition).''
 * 2) One week is allowed for objections to be addressed, after which EduCorps members will have five days to vote to keep or remove the article.
 * 3) The support of at least two EC members with less than two opposed is required to strip a CA of its status. Otherwise, the CA will be kept after the allotted time period.
 * 4) Refer to the CA instructions page on how to properly archive a CA review.

All Stars Burn as One

 * Review comments: It looks like the official anthem of the Republic appears in either The Old Republic, Knights of the Old Republic, or both. Youtube links here and here. I'm going to seek confirmation from Cade on the former and Naru on the latter. Menkooroo (talk) 16:29, January 5, 2013 (UTC)

(+0)
Keep

Vote to remove (votes in this section are only allowed after one week on the review page)

Objections/grievances

Comments
 * Yes, it definitely does appear in both KotOR and TOR. --Saboteur100 (talk) 16:41, January 5, 2013 (UTC)
 * Just saw your comment on the article's talk page. Thanks for the clarification on KOTOR --- the opening and the ending theme, eh? Cool. Do you know which TOR quest uses it? Menkooroo (talk) 16:56, January 5, 2013 (UTC)
 * Not sure of the quest's name. I do remember that it's on Balmorra. --Saboteur100 (talk) 17:00, January 5, 2013 (UTC)
 * Also, in KotoR, to be more specific, it is heard in the very opening sequence when the player is trying to escape the Endar Spire and in the ending Light-side cinematic ending when the player and his crew are honored by Admiral Dodonna and Jedi Master Vandar.--Saboteur100 (talk) 17:27, January 5, 2013 (UTC)
 * Cool, thanks. Is it actually identified as the Republic anthem in KOTOR, or did that identification come later? Menkooroo (talk) 06:58, January 6, 2013 (UTC)


 * Besides the Youtube videos, what source do we have that this music is the same as the one from KotOR and TOR? (P.S. Are those even official videos?)-- Exiled Jedi  Oldrepublic crest.svg (Greetings)  23:08, January 5, 2013 (UTC)
 * I'm hoping we can get confirmation that it's actually identified as the Republic anthem in either game. You're a TOR player, EJ --- do you know anything about the Balmorra one? Menkooroo (talk) 03:16, January 6, 2013 (UTC)
 * Not offhand, but it has been awhile since I did any of the Republic Balmorra missions, and I can't check until my main computer is fixed in a couple of weeks. I can't remember it being identified in KotOR either.-- Exiled Jedi  Oldrepublic crest.svg (Greetings)  03:28, January 6, 2013 (UTC)
 * I can check it out tomorrow night after work or maybe Monday morning if I get off early enough to see the Hobbit again. Basically, I should have the info by Monday. *goes back to sleep* Cade   Calrayn  StupidRepublicEmblem-Traced-TORkit.svg 06:45, January 6, 2013 (UTC)
 * Awesome, thanks. Can you let us know if the game actually identifies it as the Republic anthem? Menkooroo (talk) 06:58, January 6, 2013 (UTC)
 * Okay, so I just played this song as a Republic Trooper in SW:TOR on a cantina jukebox. It is titled "For the Republic" in the Jukebox menu. The tune is the same as the YouTube videos, but obviously the title is different, so maybe I'm wrong about it being the same song. The tune in those YouTube videos is obviously an in-universe tune and if it's not 'All Stars Burn as One' then it was possibly an anthem for the Old Republic in 3642 BBY. The tune from the YouTube videos is also apparently known as "Revan's Theme" and simply "The Old Republic". It was composed by Jeremy Soule for the KotOR soundtrack originally, but as I said, it appears I am probably wrong about it being 'All Stars Burn as One'. --Saboteur100 (talk) 11:53, January 6, 2013 (UTC)
 * I've removed the update tag, since it doesn't seem like the song in KOTOR and TOR is the same one. However, judging from here, it looks like a small update is needed from the TFU II Databank. Menkooroo (talk) 15:10, January 28, 2013 (UTC)
 * Quick comment: the article should add information on Imperial Edict 2.33b.  Stake black   msg 17:07, January 28, 2013 (UTC)

BT7 Thunderstrike

 * Review comments: According to an email from Paul Kemp, the BT7 Thunderstrike was an earlier name used for the BT-7 Thunderclap.

(-2)
Keep

Vote to remove (votes in this section are only allowed after one week on the review page)
 * 1) The article's over 350 words now, so we can't vote to keep. Let's get this puppy offa here and onto the GAN page. Menkooroo (talk) 15:12, January 28, 2013 (UTC)
 * 2) I don't know, it might be a FAN after I'm through with the updating.-- Exiled Jedi  Oldrepublic crest.svg  (Greetings)  04:10, January 31, 2013 (UTC)

Objections/grievances
 * This article is not longer comprehensive, and requires a lot of information from The Old Republic and other sources.-- Exiled Jedi  Oldrepublic crest.svg (Greetings)  04:24, January 9, 2013 (UTC)

Comments
 * For the record, I cannot update this since I do not have access to all of the sources. As much as I'd like to save one of my own articles, I can't personally.&mdash; Cal Jedi Infinite Empire.svg (Personal Comm Channel) 14:19, January 9, 2013 (UTC)
 * I can start expanding the information from The Old Republic as soon as my main computer is returned from being repaired. However, I do not have the other sources, so other people will have to help with the update as well.-- Exiled Jedi  Oldrepublic crest.svg (Greetings)  14:28, January 9, 2013 (UTC)
 * I really appreciate that, EJ. TOR was the main source that was holding me back. I own Revan, so I should be able to take care of that aspect shortly. As for Annihilation, Art and Making, and TORE, I might be able to borrow those and check them. I'll see what I can do.&mdash; Cal Jedi Infinite Empire.svg (Personal Comm Channel) 14:33, January 9, 2013 (UTC)
 * BTW, thanks for getting all this lined up, EJ. Saved me a lot of work on my own article. :P &mdash; Cal Jedi Infinite Empire.svg (Personal Comm Channel) 14:41, January 9, 2013 (UTC)

Smapp

 * Review comments:

(+0)
Keep

Vote to remove (votes in this section are only allowed after one week on the review page)

Objections/grievances
 * 1) Exiled Jedi
 * 2) *Kind of funny since this is my article, but I want some opinions on what I should do with it.
 * 3) *All right, Stake black recently found that the Smapp had a large entry and image in Monsters and Aliens from George Lucas, which is a non-canon book.
 * Here is the information that he gave me from the book
 * Here is the image. (it could probably use a higher-quality upload)
 * 1) *Right now there are a lot of redlinks in the article, and I would like to have peoples opinions on which things deserve articles.
 * 2) *I would also like any opinions on how to integrate the new information in the rest of the article. I'm pretty sure it should all go in the BTS, but should the article still just treat it as a food?
 * 3) *How detailed should the information from the book be? The information in the article now contains my condensed version of the information in the entry. However, I am not sure if this is the appropriate level of detail.
 * 4) Whew...-- Exiled Jedi  Oldrepublic crest.svg (Greetings)  04:20, January 31, 2013 (UTC)

Comments