Forum:CT Archive/Featured article ground rules

Seeing some examples of fanboyism voting/nominations on the Featured Article page, I propose some ground rules set regarding nominations and voting.


 * DO
 * Nominate an article that is well-rounded and complete.
 * Take all nominated articles into consideration when voting, regardless of your like/dislike of the subject matter.
 * Sign your name under any article you want to vote for, and make comments if necessary.
 * Add the tag to the top of an article you nominated.
 * Keep the nominated article list in alphabetical order.
 * Add Object in the Comments section if you disagree with a nomination, and list your reasons.


 * DON'T
 * Nominate or vote for an article because you think the subject is cool.
 * Nominate or vote for an article that is obviously in need of more work.

I propose that anyone that anyone who gets caught voting fanboyishly has their vote removed. The Featured Article page is not a popularity contest.