Forum:CT Archive/Imperial insignia page

Forums &gt; Consensus track &gt; 

I meant to do this before I left for the holidays and let everyone argue it out while I was away, but here goes anyway:

We have two versions of the Imperial insignia page: Rank insignia of the Galactic Empire and Rank Insignia of the Galactic Empire/temp. It's high time we picked one and stuck with it: it's been like this for months.

Both pages have problems: the first version is short, contains a good deal of conjecture, and is as far as I can tell incomplete.

The second version is impressively long and details, but some sections are still marked as "needing expansion", while others seem to be written in the style of a persuasive essay rather than a factual summary. There's also one fanonical assumption I don't like, namely the identification of the six films as a cache of video files R2-D2 gave the Whills, but that can be edited out fairly cleanly.

Which do you prefer?

Rank insignia of the Galactic Empire
This would mean that the current main article would be the focus of the edits, and the temp page would be moved out of the article space and/or deleted.

Rank Insignia of the Galactic Empire/temp
This would move the temp page over top of the current article, and focus our editing there.


 * 1) &mdash;Silly Dan (talk) 01:09, 11 January 2007 (UTC)