Wookieepedia:EduCorps/Meeting 19/Log

[00:00:31] All right is anyone on here and ready to work on the EC meeting? [00:01:05]  No one is here? [00:01:07]  Seriously? [00:01:38] Well dogma, SE, and Ayrehead all left notes. [00:02:10] The problem is that I have issues with some articles that people voted to spare in their notes. [00:03:11] All right, starting up with the old articles. [00:03:37]  Go ahead. [00:04:17] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Blasted_Asteroid [00:04:25] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Blasted_Asteroid [00:04:33] Ayrehead said he fixed it. [00:04:54] On the meeting page [00:05:15]  Is it? [00:05:38]  Keep, I guess. [00:05:39] I just need to tweak one more thing. [00:05:45]  Okay. [00:06:25]  The BTS could also use an update [00:07:06] That was my tweak. [00:07:08]  I made it [00:07:23]  Alright, keep. [00:07:44] We are currently voting on Blasted Asteroid [00:07:49] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Blasted_Asteroid [00:07:54] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Blasted_Asteroid [00:08:04] Keep, I think everything is fixed now. [00:08:04]  Keeo [00:08:34]  Keep [00:08:40] dogma and Ayrehead vote keep. [00:08:53]  keep\ [00:09:15] Blasted Asteroid kept. [00:16:48] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Incident_Commander [00:16:56] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Incident_Commander [00:17:07] From what I can tell, no one checked this. [00:17:23]  Kill. [00:17:26] Kill [00:17:27]  Kill Bill [00:17:33]  Yep, kill [00:17:37]  And kill [00:17:45] IC killed. [00:17:56] <Cade> Also, that quote makes the capitalization suspect. [00:18:14] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/PTB-625_planetary_bomber [00:18:20] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/PTB-625_planetary_bomber [00:18:25] No change [00:18:26] Kill [00:18:30] <SimToprawa> Kill Bill, Vol. 2 [00:18:32] <Cade> Kill. [00:19:04] <CorellianPremier> Yep, kill [00:19:04] dogma votes kill [00:19:08] <SimToprawa> The Peanut Butter-625 planetary bomber [00:19:15] PTB bomber killed. [00:19:22] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Systems_analyst [00:19:27] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Systems_analyst [00:19:28] No change [00:19:30] Kill [00:19:32] <Cade> Kill. [00:19:37] <SimToprawa> Kill Bill, Vol. 3 [00:19:44] <CorellianPremier> Ex-ter-me-nate [00:20:05] Systems analyst killed. [00:20:07] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Testosterone [00:20:11] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Testosterone [00:20:13] No change [00:20:17] Kill [00:20:17] <SimToprawa> To Kill a Mockingbird [00:20:31] <Cade> Kill. [00:20:59] dogma and SE vote kill [00:21:13] Testosterone killed. [00:21:15] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Z [00:21:24] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:EC/Z [00:21:32] No change [00:21:36] <Cade> Kill. [00:21:38] <SimToprawa> Killed By Science [00:21:41] Kill [00:21:49] <CorellianPremier> Let's kill it [00:21:58] Z Killed. [00:22:03] Now for new articles. [00:22:14] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/221st_Mechanized_Assault_Group [00:22:18] <SimToprawa> aww [00:22:23] <SimToprawa> I didn't get to use Killington, VT [00:22:30] There is nothing on the piece that says it was part of the Remnant. The Remnant wasn't even around in the Rebellion era. All that can be gained about the piece's affiliation is that it has an Imperial symbol on its base. The full release date also cannot be sourced to the game. [00:22:45] This one is bad. [00:22:46] <Cade> Probe. [00:22:50] <SimToprawa> Bob Probert [00:22:53] <Cade> Prrrooobbbbee. [00:22:54] Probe [00:22:57] <Cade> Gethralkin, [00:23:21] <Cade> Or Naru. [00:23:27] Notes say probe [00:23:40] 221st probed. [00:23:54] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/88th_Mechanized_Assault_Group [00:24:01] Same as the previous one. [00:24:06] <SimToprawa> Probe [00:24:14] <Cade> Probe. [00:24:15] Probe The other two are different. [00:24:38] Notes say probe. [00:24:56] <CorellianPremier> Probe it as well [00:24:59] 88th probed. [00:25:12] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/98th_Elite_Mechanized_Assault_Group [00:25:33] There is nothing on the piece that says it was part of the Remnant or was used by warlords. I have no clue what is being used in the link in reference two for sourcing purposes. The release date will need a source. [00:25:37] <Cade> Probe. [00:25:39] Probe [00:25:40] <SimToprawa> Probe [00:25:51] <CorellianPremier> Prope [00:26:08] 98th probed. [00:26:20] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/71st_Elite_Mechanized_Assault_Group [00:26:32] There is nothing on the piece that says it was part of the Remnant. The Remnant wasn't even around in the Rebellion era. All that can be gained about the piece's affiliation is that it has an Imperial symbol on its base. Someone should check to see what the Imperial Handbook: A Commander's Guide says about the group. Also, the BTS cannot all be sourced to that news article. [00:26:40] <Cade> Probe. [00:26:40] Probe. [00:26:45] <SimToprawa> Probe [00:26:52] <CorellianPremier> Yep, probe [00:26:57] 71st probed. [00:27:08] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/88-R_Nightscreamer [00:27:20]    This article has two redlinks. [00:27:20]    The release date needs its own source. [00:27:20]    From a note on page 82, it can be determined that Chentu Chek lived at the same time as Dengar. I believe that from this information and other information in the book, an range of eras can be determined, which should be mentioned in the BTS. [00:27:20]    There are a couple more things that can be added about Chek's opinions/recommendations for the vehicle. [00:27:28] <SimToprawa> Probe [00:27:28] Probe [00:27:29] <Cade> Probe. [00:27:50] Notes say probe. [00:27:55] <CorellianPremier> Probe it [00:28:05] 88-R probed. [00:28:06] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/BAX-7_landspeeder [00:28:20]    The release date needs its own source. [00:28:20]    It should be mentioned that this vehicle was included in Chentu Chek's section of the guide. [00:28:20]    From a note on page 82, it can be determined that Chentu Chek lived at the same time as Dengar. I believe that from this information and other information in the book, an range of eras can be determined, which should be mentioned in the BTS. [00:28:22] Probe [00:28:25] <SimToprawa> Probe [00:28:30] <CorellianPremier> Probe [00:28:44] <Cade> Probe. [00:28:49] BAX-7 probed. [00:28:50] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/ABP-980_bio-light_panel [00:29:05] Ayrehead said he fixed this. [00:29:11] <SimToprawa> Ad-Blocker Plus [00:29:46] <Cade> The question is did he/ [00:29:56] <Cade> That looks rather large for a CA. [00:29:58] Reference three looks kind of suspect. [00:30:13] <CorellianPremier> He said on the meeting page it went over 250 [00:31:04] <Cade> Kill it, unless he's nominating it. [00:31:07] He doesn't use the thing's name in the body. [00:31:37] We can't kill it outright. [00:31:43] That's been discussed before. [00:31:48] <Cade> True. [00:32:13] <Cade> Probe it at the next meeting if he hasn't nominated it, then. [00:32:26] I'm going to vote to probe it now. [00:32:35] <Cade> I'm good with that. [00:32:36] There's intro-exclusive information. [00:32:57] At the very least reference three needs a cite web template. [00:32:59] <Cade> Also, Tope gave me his vote since h's AFK for a bit, so probe for Tope too. [00:33:30] CP? [00:33:45] <CorellianPremier> Probing is fine [00:34:07] ABP-980 probed. [00:34:17] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/BTL-S3B_Y-wing_starfighter [00:34:31] It could be a mistake, but WhatLinksHere shows that Star Wars: Age of Rebellion Core Rulebook mentions the ship. [00:34:36] Someone should check. [00:34:41] <Cade> Probe, then. [00:34:42] Probe. [00:35:00] <CorellianPremier> I don't think it's in there [00:35:00] <Cade> Probe from Tope. [00:35:20] <Cade> Well, it's worth probing anyway. [00:35:56] If you give a good check before next meeting, we can keep it then. [00:36:07] <CorellianPremier> Okay, probe [00:36:17] BTL-S3B probed. [00:36:27] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/GRGC-800_grav_mill [00:36:34] Another one Ayrehead said he fixed. [00:37:36] <Cade> No mention of the time in the intro? [00:37:46] Reference three is a problem again. [00:37:58] Needs a cite web at the very least. [00:38:09] The intro is way too short. [00:38:17] <Cade> Yeah, probe. [00:38:26] Probe [00:38:34] <SimToprawa> Probe [00:38:36] <CorellianPremier> Probe [00:38:46] Probe grav mill [00:38:53] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Hiding_Cube_SCT-1000 [00:39:01] Another one Ayrehead said he fixed. [00:39:32] Bith hiding cube is only in the intro. [00:39:39] Reference 3 is a problem again. [00:39:54] Probe [00:39:57] <Cade> Bith was mentioned in the History *shrug* [00:40:40] <CorellianPremier> Gotta say probe [00:40:43] <Cade> Probe. [00:40:57] Well, reference three still needs work. [00:41:31] Tope? [00:41:45] <SimToprawa> Probe [00:42:00] SCT-100 probed. [00:42:14] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Ilosian [00:42:19] Atlas extrapolation. [00:42:28] Probe, I'm sick of fixing this stuff. [00:42:35] <Cade> Probe. [00:42:53] <SimToprawa> Probe [00:43:12] Notes say probe. [00:43:15] Ilosian probed. [00:43:26] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/InstaMist_generator [00:43:30] Another Ayrehead fix. [00:43:46] Reference three is a problem again. [00:43:51] <Cade> Probe. [00:44:16] <CorellianPremier> Yep, probe [00:44:17] Probe [00:44:27] <SimToprawa> Probe [00:44:31] InstaMist probed. [00:44:40] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Kashyyykian_giant_weaver [00:44:49] Upon examination, the description for this creature is the same as that of the Wyyyschokk, so I believe that this article needs to be merged. [00:45:11] <Cade> Probe. [00:45:12] Probe [00:45:19] <SimToprawa> Lest we make the fatal mistake of giving any sort of credence to the abominations that were the TFU novels [00:45:23] <SimToprawa> Probe [00:45:39] Notes say probe. [00:45:42] KGW probed. [00:45:50] <SimToprawa> KGB [00:45:55] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Meiloorun [00:46:11]    I'm not sure why the given source is considered to be part of the Rebellion era in this article. [00:46:11]    All it says is this: "He hit hard, with his helmet splitting like the rind of an overripe meiloorun." I'm not sure if this is enough to call it a fruit, but the part about the rind splitting when overripe should definitely be included in the article. [00:46:12] <Cade> Probe. [00:46:15] Probe [00:46:30] <SimToprawa> Probe [00:46:32] <CorellianPremier> Probe [00:46:32] <SimToprawa> Too fruity [00:46:50] Meiloorun probed. [00:46:55] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Riileb_precursor_species [00:47:00] Another one Ayrehead fixed. [00:47:53] I think this one might be okay. [00:48:11] <Cade> Keep, then. [00:48:17] <CorellianPremier> Keep [00:48:20] Spare [00:48:28] <SimToprawa> Feet [00:48:37] Feet? [00:48:52] <SimToprawa> As in...Spare [00:49:10] Riileb spared. [00:49:19] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Scintil_vine [00:49:22] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Tass_root [00:49:41] These two lack references, and should check to see if the date can be sourced to the book. [00:49:56] The release date needs another source as well. [00:49:59] <Cade> Probe. [00:50:01] Probe both. [00:50:02] <SimToprawa> Hobo [00:50:07] <CorellianPremier> For sure [00:50:15] Vine and Root probed. [00:50:23] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Tellanadan_moonflower [00:50:29] <SimToprawa> Ann Arbor is a whore [00:51:02] <CorellianPremier> Yes. [00:51:06] Huh? [00:51:14] <CorellianPremier> U of M [00:51:42] I didn't see this before, but reference 4 doesn't make any sense. [00:52:05] That source has nothing to do with anything that I can see. [00:52:11] It needs some kind of explanation. [00:52:28] <SimToprawa> Yah [00:52:30] <SimToprawa> Proob [00:52:31] Probe. [00:52:35] <CorellianPremier> Probe. [00:52:44] Cade? [00:52:49] <Cade> Probe. [00:53:07] Telanadan moonflower probed. [00:53:12] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Tuskbeast_pike [00:53:19] Needs an update. Is over one month old. [00:53:20] Probe [00:53:28] <CorellianPremier> Probe, THIS time [00:53:58] <Cade> Probe. [00:54:04] Notes say probe. [00:54:14] <SimToprawa> Proob [00:54:15] <Cade> Okay, I have to go. EJ has my vote. [00:54:17] Tuskbeast pike probed. [00:54:19] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Vendaran [00:54:26] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Vendaran [00:54:30] Oops. [00:54:40] Reference three sources a lot of information to the Atlas Companion, which cannot support most of this information. [00:54:54] Probe [00:55:18] <SimToprawa> Proob [00:55:40] Notes say probe. [00:55:43] <CorellianPremier> Probe [00:55:46] Vendaran probed. [00:55:49] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Fame_Drimal [00:55:55] The question has been brought up whether any of the post-4/25 SW.com posts should be added to Legends articles, and if any apparent new info should really be taken as official as opposed to just fan speculation. Currently I sourced his Neimoidian Gunnery Battalion affiliation to the SW.com Neimoidians article, but wonder, besides the whole questionable nature of those Blogs on Legends articles at all, is this ju [00:55:55] st a duck test scenario, based on him and Gap Nox both wearing the typical outfits of the Gunnery Battalion? We consider this guy ISB based on his outfit, without anything AFAIK explicitly saying so. And if we were to see a stormtrooper, Bespin Wing Guard, Rebel pilot, etc. we would know what they are from their outfits. I admit I am not that familiar with the Neimoidian Gunnery Battalion, but it seems to me thi [00:55:55] s is another apparent duck test case. Hanzo Hasashi (talk) 16:17, February 13, 2015 (UTC) [00:56:15] I have no clue what is going on here. [00:56:29] <SimToprawa> tl;dr [00:57:24] What do you want to do here? [00:57:41] <SimToprawa> Not read it and move on :P [00:57:44] Okay. [00:58:02] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/K26_explosive_antivehicle_rocket?t=20150307234255 [00:58:06] <CorellianPremier> Well first, he was named in a post 4/14 Blog post, so canon or not? [00:58:11] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/%22Dumb%22_Energy_Quarrel?t=20150226183456 [00:58:16] http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Lumablast_rocket?t=20150226180645 [00:58:29] These all need updates for old stuff. [00:58:31] Probe [00:58:58] <SimToprawa> Probe [00:59:00] <CorellianPremier> Probe all. [00:59:08] Stuff probed. [00:59:16] All right that's all the articles for this time. [00:59:35] As a note, we really need to have meeting more frequently. [00:59:45] I have a list of over 400 articles with issues. [00:59:56] This is just a taste. [01:00:49] Doing a meeting every two weeks would help us get through everything before an eternity passes. [01:01:07] <SimToprawa> I agree, and I like oatmeal on some days. [01:01:07] I've got to go now so I will present the meeting duties. [01:01:28] I am on scheduling. [01:01:38] SE is on paperwork. [01:01:44] Thanks for coming.