Warning: This Essay contains spoilers from Star Wars: Jedi: Survivor.
[Essay of the Week Contest] Submission: Week 76
Word Count: 2788
Reminder, don’t just drop a like on this post, be sure to add one to the actual submission post on the contest!
Introduction
We recently had the identity of Baylan Skoll confirmed to us in a news article, as a survivor of Order 66 who became a mercenary after the fall of the Jedi Order. I have no problems with this core fact, nor any reveal of new survivors who escaped the Order’s initial execution. 1% of 10,000 still leaves you with 100, etcetera, etcetera. However, there is a broader concern with Baylan and other recent additions to the Star Wars canon regarding the ratio of Order 66 (shortened to O66 from here on) survivors due to the narrative their inclusion solidifies. This narrative is not positive, and casts people of diversity and disadvantage as a hostile force looking to hunt and kill or hurt the often Caucasian, if not male, protagonists of various stories. I feel it is essential to keep this narrative in mind going forward as the Star Wars canon nears and clears a decade of new storytelling, as something that fans should be aware needs to change.
The Ratio
There are a number of survivors of O66 in canon, but many are just a name, and we lack any further context or knowledge of who they are. A handful joined or were converted into Inquisitors, and those I will not count due to the reversal of their role, and other elements to be explained later on. Of those left who we have seen, I fully acknowledge I do not know them all. However, with that said, the problem arises when one considers the prominent survivors who have appeared in popular comics, were the subject of/played a major role in books, or who have appeared in major video games, streaming/TV shows, or films. This list excludes prominent male alien survivors in order to demonstrate the problem at the heart of this analysis as even with their inclusion, the narrative remains the same.
White Human Male Survivors: Kanan Jarrus, Obi-Wan Kenobi, Cal Kestis, Baylan Skoll, Eno Cordova, Taron Malicos, and Naq Med (a key character to the novel Force Collector, and an interesting instance of a Jedi Order dropout being hunted by the Inquisitors)
Human Male Survivors: All of the above, Nari (from Obi-Wan Kenobi and while a near-human, there is no visual difference to indicate that), Quinlan Vos (again like Nari, so extremely similar to a baseline human it doesn't impact his visuals), Bode Akuna, and Kelleran Beq
Female Survivors: Ashoka, Cere Junda, and Jocasta Nu
The ratio is depressingly skewed, and as suggested earlier, recently grew with the addition of three new male survivors in prominent positions for the canon. This expansion has not been met with the growth of notable female characters, and when coupled with the narrative found in the Inquisitors, begins to paint a highly concerning picture.
The Other
We have continued to see the number of Inquisitors expand, with recent years being particularly kind in filling out the roster to the point it might be too full, and questions have been raised regarding the numbers in the Inquisitorius, and how their naming system functions. Ignoring those questions or possible issues, many of the Inquisitors present us with narratives of the Other, and how the suffering generated from that now drives them through their adoption of the Dark Side. For those unfamiliar with the concept, the Other is a term used to define an array of entities, characters, and more from literature and other material which are characterized as different, and often hostile, when compared with the surrounding world they are found in. Alien invasion narratives are the most easily understood example of the world versus an Other, and here, the Inquisitors drip with Otherness for multiple reasons. Below is a rundown of relevant information for each Inquisitor, even those we know little about.
Grand Inquisitor: His narrative is not part of this argument specifically, as pride and selfish desire led to his fall. However, we can note his physically imposing features, with sharpened teeth and altered eyes.
Second Sister: Trilla, who first appeared in Jedi: Fallen Order, is a woman who suffered greatly at the hands of the Inquisitorius. Betrayed by her master, her close friend and mentor, in a moment of weakness after her capture, Trilla and the younglings they were trying to keep safe were captured by the sinister organization. One can only imagine the fate of these young Jedi, and Trilla herself fell into hatred for her former master. While she later forgave Cere Junda, she survived this redemption mere seconds, and Darth Vader then cut her down.
Third Sister: Reva Sevander, who first appeared in Obi-Wan Kenobi, was among the survivors who directly fled from the Jedi temple itself. After being struck down, but not killed, by Anakin Skywalker, she lay within the bodies of her fellow Jedi until she was able to escape. Her grief, pain, and ultimately rage at knowing who Darth Vader truly was, as well as who had helped train him, and partner with him in the Order, led her to burn with hatred for Vader and Obi-Wan Kenobi, ultimately making moves to eliminate them both but failing, instead being put on a path toward redemption. Her fate after this point is a mystery.
Fourth Sister: An entirely new character, we know little about her at this time.
Fifth Brother: A native to Artemesium, the Fifth Brother was taken into the Jedi Order, and watched as the Republic chose to decimate his homeworld for mineral extraction. The Jedi did nothing to stop these events, and disgusted by what had happened, the Brother ultimately turned to the Dark Side, believing the Jedi to be corrupt, weak, and deserving of death for having lost their way. He had many missions, and survived many of his fellows, before dying on Malachor.
Sixth Brother: While an older character, he is still a relative unknown, beyond that he was once a Jedi known as Bil Valen.
Seventh Sister: Another older character in SW canon, she remains an enigma as well. However, she has a significant aesthetic, as one of the first Inquisitors seen, with altered eyes and warped voice, as well as a malevolently playful personality.
Eighth Brother: We’ve not seen much of the 8th, and there is little to comment on, though depending on your theories or suspicions, we may see more of them in Ashoka.
Ninth Sister: Masana Tide is one of the most notable Inquisitors so far. Making a very successful transfer between comics and video games, she was an imposing Dowutin who suffered greatly at the hands of the Inquisitors, Vader, and then Cal Kestis. She lost limbs, her face was damaged, and due to her strong abilities around emotions, was prone to powerful rages. She was ultimately killed by Cal Kestis on Coruscant.
Tenth Brother: The last of our numbered Inquisitors, Prosset Dibs was a member of the Jedi Order to fall fairly early into the Clone Wars. Filled with doubts about the methods of the Order and its new role as generals in the conflict, he ultimately turned against Mace Windu during a mission, though he was defeated and arrested. Allowed to live, he ultimately fell into the ranks of the Inquisitorius after O66, only to be one of its first members to die, being shot by his own Purge Troopers on Mon Cala.
Iskat Akaris: Certainly not a new Inquisitor, though only recently named, we roughly know the path of Iskat’s story due to the summary released for Inquisitor: Rise of the Red Blade. Brought into the Jedi Order, she was part of the Jedi team sent to Geonosis as a Padawan, going on to serve in the Clone Wars where she began to question her origins and other elements of her role as a Jedi. When the Order fell, she eventually became an Inquisitor, only to die when Vader attacked her and her fellow yet unnumbered Inquisitor, Tualon, killing both due to their affection for each other.
Tualon: We know little about Tualon, but he has black skin, a seeming rarity for a Twi’lek, as well as sharpened teeth and thus a severely menacing appearance.
Aside from these characters, there are several others who lack names, numbers, or solid identification in the canon. But, with all of their stories laid out, we should consider the parallels one can draw between many of these characters, real-world elements, and the nature of Otherness. Reva’s story has similarities to those of school shooting victims, especially with the detail of how she lay among the dead, her fellow students and teachers, only to escape later on after the massacre. Her Otherness comes from surviving such a horrific event, being in the direct line of fire and taking a wound, but living to deal with that pain the rest of her life. The Fifth Brother can be read as a migrant who leaves his home for a wealthier country, only to see their place of origin destroyed by war, corporate greed, or disaster. The outside parties who are in a position to help it recover or rebuild then simply don’t do anything to help, rendering him feeling angry and betrayed, perhaps even a lone survivor to a great disaster. The Ninth Sister is a heavy-framed female character with a great deal of emotion to her who undergoes terrible suffering through the loss of body parts, ending up broken and raging at the forces who have done this to her, wanting to extend that pain to others. The Tenth Brother, a theoretical blind man (though as a Miraluka, still able to see), has enough insight to understand the fall of his group from their standards and ideals, but ends up censured and confined for those beliefs. Iskat, a theoretically adopted character, tries to question her true origins and is shut down from pursuing her past, leading her to make a deal with the devil to try and learn the truths that were kept from her. She even goes on to make an “adopted” child of her own out of Eeth Koth’s offspring, stealing the newborn from their mother’s arms, and allowing strange caretakers to rear them upon the mission’s return to Coruscant.
All of these characters represent people who are detached from the wider world, rendered separate from it by trauma, loss, or circumstances outside of their control. These divisions grow, and create emotions they cannot turn away from, and in the realm of Star Wars, create forces which they embrace as doers of evil. They represent the Other for this reason. However, they represent the Other in more obvious ways. Almost all of the Inquisitors are alien species, and often fearsome members of those species. Be it sharp teeth, altered/gleaming eyes of unnatural hues (in the case of the Tenth Brother, a complete lack of eyes), or other traits, in addition to their suits of sleek black armor, they often serve to intimidate and are meant to stand out from other beings, especially in a state as conform-heavy as the Empire. The Otherness is unfortunately added to even further by the two human Inquisitors we know of so far, as both Reva and Trilla are female people of color, and for much of world history, such people have been treated as exotic, different, and separate from the rest of the world. Their inclusion here, in the rank of an organization like the Inquisitorius, only reinforces this element. Thankfully, we understand their stories with great clarity, and we can sympathize with them as a result, but few others are so lucky. In the end, the Inquisitorius and its members ultimately embody the Other on a deep level, through characters who hold close parallels to many real-world groups who have suffered, and continue to suffer.
The Narrative
As discussed above, the Inquisitors represent the Other, but it is an Other which has a worrying contrast against the characters who they stand in opposition to. These figures are often men, often Caucasian men as well, and are the vast majority of the well-known Jedi survivors we have currently identified. Before looking at the reasons from outside of the Star Wars universe for this dominance, we should also consider some elements of the Star Wars universe which can be used to explain the survival of these characters.
First, we should consider the nature of humans in Star Wars. They are a nearly ubiquitous species, found on virtually every planet in the galaxy, and have diversified to the point of producing various near-human species with minor physical traits differentiating themselves from Star Wars baseline humans. Due to this ubiquity, human Jedi undoubtedly had an advantage in hiding and moving throughout the galaxy after O66 because of this, and it would make sense that they and near-humans make up a large portion of the survivors. The ratio further skewing toward men points to the Star Wars galaxy generally featuring elements from our real world regarding gender relations, and it is likely those male characters had an easier time finding transit, accommodations, or traveling alone, than female counterparts.
Now, we should consider the out of universe reasons why there are so many human, male, often Caucasian, survivors of O66: connection, marketing, and merchandising. All three are wrapped up with one another, feeding each other for multiple reasons. For a character like Cal Kestis, as a human he is more immediately relatable to a general audience, they can understand what he looks like, and they know he lives, thinks, and acts how we might on an everyday basis. He is relatable, and thus marketable, able to sell hundreds of thousands of copies of his game on top of action figures, artwork, and more because we form a connection with him. But he is also familiar. The audience of Star Wars has often skewed male and for a lot of its history, so has the media produced to satisfy that audience. However, over the years, that dominance has shifted, and other groups are making themselves more recognized as being part of the fandom. They existed before, but time, and social media, has helped to broaden their reach and visibility. They want to see themselves represented, and companies are shifting to accommodate these groups, and acknowledge them more through characters and narratives which connect them better to the content of Star Wars.
But, this ultimately makes the optics of the growing narrative so disconcerting. The Inquisitorius, as an organization of Otherness, of alien species and women of color, hunt down Jedi survivors whose most notable members, and most prized targets, are often Caucasian and male. In the case of Cal Kestis, the Ninth Sister screams about wanting to break him, and cause him pain, while the Third Sister hunts a fan-favorite character (Obi-Wan), and then resorts to almost killing another (Luke Skywalker), all in the pursuit of her goals. I have nothing against Eno Cordova, Bode Akuna, or Baylan Skoll, each of them have (and will likely) add to Star Wars lore in exciting or unique ways. But, I still fear the growing subtext that we as fans are being subjected to, especially as it coincides with a particularly rough time in the real world for people who are often framed as the Other.
We as fans should hope for there to be more female Jedi survivors of note in the future, in addition to hoping to learn the backstories of the Inquisitors so we can understand them better. Characters like Reva and Trilla have so much added to them because we know the origin of their pain, and can empathize with them. We need that for all of these fallen Jedi, so they can become more relatable, and not exist so firmly in the sphere of the Other. All of this is possible as Star Wars continues to fill in knowledge gaps or threads left hanging in more recent years, and I sincerely hope that strides are taken to dismantle the underlying narrative I have outlined.
Conclusion
Even as I write this, we may be about to see things turning around. Maybe, when we get Rise of the Red Blade this July, we will both explore the backstories of multiple Inquisitors and gain information on a new and notable female Jedi survivor. Maybe as the months or future years wear on, the faceless names of survivors will be filled in, and we can see or experience the adventures of diverse characters during the perilous rise and expansion of the Empire. All I can say is that I hope that change or new information comes, and quicker than another decade, to give us more unique characters to root for, and to offer us as an audience greater understanding of what exists already.