All posts by LordOfShatteredFields

Good choice

I've watched it three times, and I only caught the books on the third.

When was Cassian Fulcrum?

Here's a related question: what's the most populated planet?

Ahsoka (but I've already voted in the other thread)

Ok, I have a thing. It's a little weird.

I think the Jedi should not use lightsabers.

I know that they are for defending themselves, the Order, and civilians, but that's not what they became. The Jedi went in to Geonisis with the equivalent of their guns blazing (along with a secret mass-produced army of gun-blazers) and set about starting a war.

Their original task was, as mentioned above, to protect the innocent via non-violent means. Lightsabers make this impossible.

As a side note, this is why Luke's final decisions in TLJ are so meaningful. However, to avoid this becoming another argument, ignore this paragraph if you feel you need to.

It looks like he's in the process of quite litterally "turning" to the Dark Side!

8 or 9

But look at it from a slightly out-of-universe perspective. When the prequels were written, Ahsoka didn't exist and Anakin did fall. While I think she was a great addition, there were enough other factors.

I think he would have. The PT is full of other reasons he fell to the Dark Side.

Out of curiosity, what was Jar Jar's fifth line?

Twilight no question.

But here's a thought: did people prefer part 1 or 2?

@Brendol. This was a clever retcon to a little issue Lucas and the team didn't spot straight away.

Hard to answer, since we don't really know what/when/where force ghost exist. Nice food for thought though. I like to think they talked it all out at the end there.

I think another interesting title trend is the combination of words (?). Hear me out...

starwars.wikia.com/wiki/The_Phantom_Menace

starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Attack_of_the_Clones

starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Revenge_of_the_Sith

starwars.wikia.com/wiki/A_New_Hope

starwars.wikia.com/wiki/The_Empire_Strikes_Back

starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Return_of_the_Jedi

starwars.wikia.com/wiki/The_Force_Awakens

starwars.wikia.com/wiki/The_Last_Jedi

Presented alternatively:

1. (The) Word Word

2. Word of the Word

3. Word of the Word

4. (A) Word Word

6. Word of the Word

7. The Word Word

8. (The) Word Word

What I'm looking at here is the occurrence of the capitalised nouns in the titles. Looking at the roster like this, it seems high time that we had another large title with "Word of the Word".

However, it's pretty thin evidence and I think that Episode IX will be called a fitting and accurate title, rather than anything that fits a pattern.

The only other clue we have for IX is the working title: "trIXie"

****

As a side note, the interesting standout, and the movie I've omitted above, is The Empire Strikes Back. This title is different to anything before or after. I think it's a cool name, and it doesn't bother me too much that it stands out from my pretty pattern.

Additionally, when looked at with the beauty of hindsight, it seems fitting that the movie in the centre of the centre trilogy holds up like that (unless IX decides to stomp on my aforesaid pretty pattern).

@Riverdale Chauffer.

Very clever. Joseph Jett Sally = Sephjet Josall

I'd like to. She's a skilled actress and is intrinsically connected to my favourite franchise!

Ahsoka's because of how they visually represent her story and beliefs.

I love it. Regardless of whether it's true or not, these thoughts are why Star Wars thrives.

Where's the source for Phasma's return? Where's the source for new appearance?

Harrumph.