Talk: Thracia Cho Leem

Member of the Lost Twenty?

Is Thracia a member of the Lost Twenty? -- SFH 00:08, 3 Oct 2005 (UTC)

• No. Dooku is no 20 and he left in 32 BBY. QuentinGeorge 00:24, 3 Oct 2005 (UTC)
• She is not because she did not fall the the dark side, she just left. I will add that to the Behind the Scenes, if no one objects.Nick sponge 21:45, 16 May 2006 (UTC)
  • Falling to the darkside isn't what makes someone part of the Lost 20. Dooku was added well before the Jedi realized he'd gone dark. —Unsigned comment by 68.37.170.34 (talk • contribs).
    • exactly, she was not a member because she wasn't lost, she still went to the temple even after she lefT Jedi Dude 14:19, 11 August 2006 (UTC)
      • Maybe in her case it's the Jedi equivalent of retirement? DAWUSS 00:28, 5 September 2007 (UTC)

About her resignation

Issue 1: I don't think Thracia left the Order to "become a wife and mother" (I removed that bit when I edited the article, and I think she was too old to have children at that point, anyway). If my memory serves me correctly, in the epilogue of Rogue Planet it is stated that she didn't explain the reasons for her resignation. I always thought her leaving had something to do with something she saw in Anakin's future while she was giving him therapy after the events on Zonama Sekot. It's not said in so many words of course, but IMO the book heavily suggests this. Maybe something along these lines should be added to the article? I'd do it myself if only I had the book, but I don't, and I don't trust my memory enough to do it without the reference. Anyone else?

Issue 2: Where is it said that she visited the Jedi Temple after she resigned the Order? Is it from the Power of the Jedi Sourcebook (which I haven't read), since it clearly isn't from either Rogue Planet or Cloack of Deception? --Tinwe 13:11, 13 October 2006 (UTC)

Off?

I dunno something seems off about her. Her methods and teachings. Her advice to Anakin in Rogue Planet. I dunno, something seems odd about her. —Unsigned comment by 71.12.210.124 (talk • contribs).

Death

How did she die? —Unsigned comment by 84.187.213.83 (talk • contribs).

Her Fate?

If she managed to live during the Clone Wars what is her fate during the rise of the Empire? When Order 66 was issued would she have been overlooked due to her resignation? According to the Great Jedi Purge article on here she lived is there any source to back up this claim?

In my opinion she was probably killed in Imperial mop-up operations. Since being a former Jedi Master that would have made her a threat to the Empire. She more than likely was killed. —Unsigned comment by Rac Ward (talk • contribs).

• She probably was overlooked because she left the order before Order 66. She likely survived the Jedi Purge and lived at least into the Imperial era. The Empire probably did not find her because they most likely did not know anything about her due to her leaving the order before the Jedi Purge. 173.51.126.86 07:50, April 22, 2011 (UTC)

Conflicting Statements, Bring the editors!

This article is ambiguous concerning if Thracia Cho Leem maintained contact with the Jedi Temple, and if revealed her reasons for leaving to the Jedi Order. The article is self-contradicting. Cho Leem, as is according to the Codex in Rogue Planet, left the Jedi Order without saying why. This is mentioned in the content. But it is followed up with the statement that she maintained contact with the Jedi Order. Also, the statement is followed closely by the assertion she no longer served the Republic, but the Force. These are inconsistent facts that need to be properly sourced and straightened out. Until then, the article itself is unreliable. Someone has told me that Jedi vs. Sith: the Essential Guide to the Force has made it clear she was not a member of the Lost Twenty. This article still needs help though in regards to how much the Jedi knew about her exit. Did she not tell them until later? If so we need to make that clear. Did she not actually reestablish contact? Are we looking at an editor's incorrect extrapolation? Someone, or some group, needs to work on editing this material for the good understanding of the rest of the fans. At present, I lack the information. It is recommended that, though I have told you things from Rogue Planet and the Jedi vs. Sith guide, a team with the materials look at them fresh together, cooperating to check each other's perspective and interpretation. That is all. Thank you for those who will tackle this page. 99.188.36.80 18:17, July 24, 2013 (UTC)

Image?

Is the image from a canon source?99.188.36.80 02:28, February 5, 2014 (UTC)