Wookieepedia:AC/Log/2016 October 22

[20:15:21] <exiledjedi> Welcome to AC Meeting 90.
[20:15:36] <exiledjedi> We will start off with the articles left over from last meeting:
[20:15:55] <exiledjedi> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Xexto
[20:16:04] <exiledjedi> http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?diff=cur&oldid=6515014
[20:16:12] <exiledjedi> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:AC/Xexto
[20:16:47] <exiledjedi> Tope: Said that something needed to be added to the BTS when he added the update tag.
[20:17:19] <exiledjedi> But AV did not think that anything needed to be added.
[20:17:53] <exiledjedi> I must confess to knowing nothing about the source in question.
[20:18:00] <CavalierOne> Me either.
[20:18:11] <CavalierOne> We can extend if Tope wants to press the issue.
[20:18:31] <Imperators> what I understood from Tope's comment was that he wanted merely the mention of the non-canonical appearance in BTS
[20:18:48] <Imperators> while AV commented about there being no new content in said appearance
[20:19:01] <exiledjedi> Yeah, that's what I thought as well. Which seems reasonable to me.
[20:19:18] <Imperators> heh
[20:19:19] <exiledjedi> Hey Tope.
[20:19:26] <Toprawa> hey EJ, everyone
[20:19:45] <exiledjedi> We are currently discussing http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Xexto
[20:19:52] <exiledjedi> http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?diff=cur&oldid=6515014
[20:19:57] <Toprawa> Can someone link me to the meeting?
[20:19:58] <exiledjedi> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:AC/Xexto
[20:20:06] <exiledjedi> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:AC/Meeting_90#New_business
[20:20:07] <Toprawa> I was only given a redlink in the talk page message
[20:20:09] <Toprawa> Thank you
[20:21:35] <Toprawa> Are you waiting on my input?
[20:22:11] <exiledjedi> I was leaning towards extending and telling him to add something to the BTS.
[20:23:01] <CavalierOne> Based on your comment in the update tag: http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Xexto?diff=6461955&oldid=6461954
[20:23:14] <CavalierOne> But AV didn't add anything to the BTS
[20:23:31] <CavalierOne> So we were considering extension 
[20:24:39] <Toprawa> I only intended to convey to the original author that any info that might be added belongs in the BTS. I noticed on my watchlist that someone added this Freemakers thing to the Appearances list and that the author made no apparent move to update the article, so I added the update tag.
[20:25:01] <Toprawa> Judging from the author's comments, it's clear that he didn't have access to the source and simply chose to do nothing
[20:25:20] <Toprawa> So if there's nothing to add, fine, but I feel satisfied that our probe at least made him check the source to verify that nothing needed to be added
[20:25:28] <exiledjedi> Ah, okay. I was wondering if that was the case.
[20:25:57] <exiledjedi> Keep then.
[20:26:01] <CavalierOne> Fair enough. Keep.
[20:26:03] <Toprawa> Keep
[20:26:04] <Imperators> keep
[20:26:14] <exiledjedi> Xexto kept.
[20:26:25] <exiledjedi> Moving on to new articles:
[20:26:37] <exiledjedi> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Adria_Reyn
[20:26:47] <exiledjedi>     The quality of the main image really needs to be improved.
[20:26:47] <exiledjedi>     Her entry in the article has a fair amount of information related to her skill and abilities that can be pulled from the RPG statistics.
[20:26:47] <exiledjedi>     From the image it looks like she observed some dealings between Sasallo, Han Solo, and Lando Calrissian while onboard what appears to be some kind of Star Destroyer. This should be mentioned and integrated with the article.--Exiled Jedi (talk) 19:31, October 22, 2016 (UTC) 
[20:27:11] <exiledjedi> Probe
[20:27:12] <Imperators> probe
[20:27:15] <Toprawa> Probe
[20:27:16] <CavalierOne> Probe
[20:27:30] <exiledjedi> Adria Reyn probed.
[20:27:34] <Toprawa> Probably wouldn't be a bad idea to add a non-cropped version of that image to the body too if there's more of that picture to show
[20:27:45] <exiledjedi> Yeah.
[20:28:00] <Toprawa> You could crop out the hologram portion for the infobox
[20:28:22] <exiledjedi> Does anyone else have any new articles?
[20:28:27] <Toprawa> I have at least one.
[20:28:31] <Toprawa> Probably two
[20:28:53] <Toprawa> Let me pull it up...
[20:29:06] <Toprawa> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Faa/Legends
[20:29:34] <Toprawa> I noticed recently that this article is missing either a needed {{1stm}} or {{1stID}} in the Sources list
[20:29:45] <Toprawa> And an accompanying BTS explanation noting where the subject's name came from
[20:29:57] <Toprawa> Probably the Visual Dictionary, I'd guess
[20:30:32] <Toprawa> So, I vote probe
[20:30:33] <CavalierOne> I would expect so.
[20:30:36] <CavalierOne> Probe
[20:30:38] <exiledjedi> Probe
[20:30:50] <Imperators> probe, it's in the Visual Dictionary
[20:31:25] <exiledjedi> Faa/Legends probed.
[20:31:31] <Toprawa> I do have one more.
[20:31:56] <Toprawa> Last comment on the page, since it's not sectioned: http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Talk:R5-J2
[20:32:43] <Toprawa> Given that we treat action figures as canon, which includes any artwork and text on their packaging, this is fairly notable BTS information not included in the article http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/R5-J2
[20:33:00] <Toprawa> It's basically an inconsistency 
[20:33:25] <exiledjedi> I agree, probe.
[20:33:30] <Toprawa> Probe
[20:33:31] <Imperators> probe
[20:33:56] <CavalierOne> Probe
[20:34:05] <exiledjedi> R5-J2 probed.
[20:34:11] <exiledjedi> Anything else?
[20:34:14] <Imperators> can we vote to remove idle noms here, or should it wait for after the meeting?
[20:34:14] <Toprawa> Not from me
[20:34:35] <Toprawa> Come again?
[20:35:15] <Imperators> I was told ACs can vote to remove idle nominations on the IRC, as well. Should it be done at this point during the meeting, or after the meeting?
[20:35:26] <Toprawa> Doesn't really matter
[20:35:29] <Toprawa> We can do it while we're here
[20:35:35] <Imperators> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:Good_article_nominations/Sakas#Toprawa
[20:35:42] <Imperators> and http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:Good_article_nominations/Mul_Sanaka#Floyd
[20:36:15] <Toprawa> I'm ok with giving Brandon at least until the end of the month, since it took me two months to respond
[20:36:24] <Toprawa> Someone could perhaps remind him to look at it
[20:36:44] <Toprawa> I vote to remove Mul Sanaka, however
[20:36:56] <exiledjedi> I also vote to remove Mul Sanaka.
[20:37:12] <Imperators> I also vote to remove Mul Sanaka.
[20:37:26] <CavalierOne> Ditto.
[20:38:29] <exiledjedi> All right, if there is not any other business, I will move on to meeting responsibilities.
[20:39:14] <exiledjedi> Exiledjedi is responsible for scheduling Meeting 91, Imperators II is responsible for Meeting 90's paperwork.
[20:39:40] <exiledjedi> The meeting is concluded.