This page is for reviews of existing Good articles. A Good article review is conducted when a current status article no longer meets one of the standards listed in the GAN rules or has significantly changed from the state it was in at the time of gaining status. On this page, users can nominate articles that they believe need updates or require their status removed.
How to nominate:
- Select a Good article that requires a review.
- Add {{GAreview}} at the top of the article you are creating a review for, and save the page. Please note that if the article you are nominating has been nominated for Good article review previously, the same page will be used.
- Members of Wookieepedia's Discord server can open a review with the following command, and JocastaBot will automatically add the review to this page: @JocastaBot create review for ArticleName
- Open the redlink in a new tab to create the nomination page, modifying the preloaded instructions as necessary. A reason for opening the review must be provided.
- Copy the code provided to the bottom of this page.
- Purge the article to update the template.
- Other users can add additional issues and suggested improvements (errors, style, organization, images, notability, sources, etc).
- On the review, all editors are able to add and address objections noted on the article's review. Afterward, one of several outcomes occurs:
- …all objections are satisfied.
- …all objections have remained unsatisfied for a period of thirty days, without a request for extension.
- …the article has exceeded or slipped under the Good article word count.
- …the article has changed significantly from its original state.
Closing stages:
- If all objections are addressed, AgriCorps review board members can start a vote to close the review after it has been open for a minimum of 48 hours. Three AgriCorps votes are required for an article to maintain its Good status.
- If objections have remained unsatisfied, the article has exceeded the word count, or the article has changed significantly from its original state, the AgriCorps review board can send the article to a probationary status. A consensus of at least three AgriCorps members is required for an article to retain its Good status or have it removed at the end of the probation.
- …articles that exceed or slip under the word count can have Good status removed.
- …articles marked for probation that have unsolved objections for over thirty days, with no request for extension or attempts made to fix, can have Good status removed.
- …articles that have changed significantly from their original state are reviewed by AgriCorps members. When determined that the article's current state is satisfactory, the review can be closed, and the article maintains its status.
Good article reviews
View recent changes for this page and its subpages
Bel/Legends
Object
- Death field needs to follow the precedent of including the date and location in a note if not directly citable to a source.
- Needs a pronouns update, and the body needs to directly state Bel was male (and remove the gender link on the he pronoun).
- Per the layout guide 'The "Affiliations" field of infoboxes shall list sub-bullets to a maximum depth of one.'
- Inconsitent referencing between the body and intro regarding homeworld to be fixed.
- Vassek and Jango Fett need context.
- Bestine's context of being an Inner Rim planet needs to be sourced as it's not mentioned in the episode.
- Anything that can be included in a skills/abilities section?
- Missing an equipment section.
- The insider 106 issue mentioned needs a release date. Lewisr (talk) 00:58, 20 July 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Two months unaddressed Lewisr (talk) 00:06, 20 September 2024 (UTC)- —spookywillowwtalk 00:09, 20 September 2024 (UTC)
Unidentified female Imperial Knight (Attack on Emperor Fel)
Object
- Is the double referencing for the death field necessary? If the comics date themselves to the year then only one issue needs to be cited.
- Need a pronouns/gender update.
- Eye color infobox exclusive.
- Double referencing at the end of the biography to be addressed, the info should be cited to the specific issue.
- Missing a personality/traits section (with the brown hair information from the biography), as well as an equipment one.
- BTS needs to include the publisher and provide full cited release dates for the mentioned comics. Lewisr (talk) 00:48, 21 July 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Unidentified female Imperial Knight (Agamar)
Object
- Needs a pronouns/gender update. If the character isn't actually female then the page needs moving.
- Skin color is infobox exclusive.
- Body could use a subject relevant image if no other images of the Knight are available.
- Not seeing a need for the double referencing used in a couple instances, should be cited to the specific issue in places.
- BTS needs to include the publisher for the comic. Lewisr (talk) 00:11, 24 July 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Unidentified clone trooper (Tranquility)/Legends
Object
- Gender and height are infobox exclusive.
- Needs a pronouns update.
- The clone is categorised as part of Green Company but this isn't reflected anywhere in the body. So needs to be mentioned if it's actually the case.
- Anything that can be included in a skills/abilities section?
- Missing an equipment section.
- BTS needs to include an airdate for the episode. Lewisr (talk) 21:51, 26 July 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Mazara
Object
- If Mazara was born on Falleen that should be in the born field too.
- Body could use a subject relevant image.
- The BBY date needs a source.
- Anything that can be included in a skills/abilities and/or equipment section? Lewisr (talk) 01:17, 28 July 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Unidentified male Imperial Knight (Agamar)
Object
- Needs a gender/pronouns update, and if the character isn't male then a move to a new title will be necessary.
- Can the eye color be determeined?
- Biography could use an image.
- Hair color should be moved to a personality and traits section, which should also include the character's skin color, and anything else of note. Lewisr (talk) 01:09, 29 July 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Toomer
Object
- Needs a pronouns update.
- Any reason the skin color wasn't added?
- I don't believe the year for the comic is citable to the issue itself (judging by the issue page) so that needs to be checked and sourced if necessary.
- Body should include that Toomer was a male.
- Anything that can be added to a skills/abilities section?
- Missing an equipment section.
- BTS should include a full release date. Lewisr (talk) 01:11, 1 August 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Tonzet
Object
- Needs a pronouns/gender update.
- Hair, eye, and skin color are all infobox exclusive.
- Context for Ukio in the intro needed, and I think the context in the biography should be moved to Ukio's first mention.
- I'd like to see a IU date added to the intro and body.
- Biography could use an image.
- Anything that can be added into a skills/abilities section?
- Missing an equipment section.
- Is there a release date for the specific installment that Tonzet was in? Lewisr (talk) 00:49, 2 August 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Dana Cadwell
- Requested By: Master Fredcerique(talk) (he/him)
- Date Requested: 16:03, 2 August 2024 (UTC)
Object
- Unsourced Bts. Master Fredcerique(talk) (he/him) 16:05, 2 August 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Unidentified male Imperial Knight II (Agamar)
Object
- Needs a gender/pronouns update, and if the character isn't male then a move to a new title will be necessary.
- Biography could use a subject relevant image.
- Hair and skin color should be noted in a personality and traits section, along with anything else of note.
- Publisher should be mentioned in the BTS. Lewisr (talk) 00:58, 3 August 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Unidentified male Imperial Knight III (Agamar)
Object
- Needs a gender/pronouns update, and if the character isn't male then a move to a new title will be necessary.
- Biography could use a subject relevant image.
- Hair color should be moved to a personality and traits section, which should also note the skin color along with anything else of note.
- Publisher should be mentioned in the BTS.
- Is Category:Bodyguards reasonable to add? Lewisr (talk) 00:41, 5 August 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Shadow Four/Legends
Object
- Needs a pronouns update.
- Gender and species need to be mentioned in the body.
- The biography might benefit from restructuring the paragraphs into 3, this might allow for another image also.
- The information about being born on Kamino should be mentioned first.
- Height should be mentioned in the personality/traits section.
- Missing an equipment section.
- Anything that can be included in a skills/abilities section?
- BTS needs to include an air date for the episode. Lewisr (talk) 03:58, 6 September 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Unidentified clone trooper pilot (Twilight)/Legends
Object
- Needs a pronouns update.
- Height is infobox exclusive.
- Some of the personality/traits section would be more suited to a skills/abilities section.
- Missing an equipment section.
- The appearance in the "Ambush" reel should be noted in the BTS. Lewisr (talk) 05:45, 7 September 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Bruu Jun-Fan
Object
- Death field needs to combine the date and location in one date note per precedent.
- Biography needs to be sectioned.
- Dup link to be removed.
- BTS needs to indicate what The Clone Wars: The Sith Hunters is, include the illustrator, and publisher. Also needs to cite the release date to a source that provides the date. Lewisr (talk) 00:37, 9 September 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Battle of Agomar
Object
- Per the layout guide, any events not mentioned in the body need to be removed from the infobox or find a way to include them.
- Curious if there's anything that can be included in an aftermath section?
- BTS needs to be cleaned up to remove months for release dates. Lewisr (talk) 00:07, 10 September 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Unidentified clone sergeant (Amidala's transmission)
Object
- Homeworld, species, gender, and being a clone of Jango are all infobox exclusive.
- Needs a pronouns update.
- Link to be removed from quote caption.
- I'd like to have it confirmed that Rodia being a planet, and Coruscant being the galactic capital is actually citable to the comic.
- Anything that can be added in a skills/abilities section?
- Missing an equipment section.
- BTS should note where the issue was published (on SW.com). Lewisr (talk) 00:15, 10 September 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Thar'quan
Object
- Infobox and body conflict on the birth year, should be investigated to check which one is accurate.
- Needs a pronouns/gender update.
- Contexts missing for various locations mentioned.
- Body could use a subject relevant image.
- It seems the personality and traits section has information that should be split into skills/abilities and equipment sections.
- BTS needs to be cleaned up to modern standards and sourced. Lewisr (talk) 02:28, 12 September 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Niner/Legends
Object
- Death field should include the date and location in a date note as per modern precedent.
- Needs a pronouns update.
- Species and gender are infobox exclusive.
- Per the layout guide 'The "Affiliations" field of infoboxes shall list sub-bullets to a maximum depth of one.'
- Vassek and Jango Fett need context.
- That Bestine is an Inner Rim planet isn't citable to the episode so needs another source cited to it.
- Anything that can be included in a skills/abilities section?
- Some of the personality/traits section should be moved to an equipment section. Lewisr (talk) 00:20, 14 September 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Knuckles (182nd Legion)
Object
- The death should include the location and date in a single date note as per modern precedent.
- Looking at the issue page, it says the story takes place in 22 BBY while this differs, would like to see the date investigated to be sure which is accurate.
- Needs a pronouns update.
- Per the layout guide 'The "Affiliations" field of infoboxes shall list sub-bullets to a maximum depth of one.'
- Don't see the need to mention about Jango's eye color, just mentioning Knuckles is fine.
- Anything that can be noted in a skills/abilities section?
- Needs an equipment section.
- BTS needs to include a full release date and publisher. Lewisr (talk) 00:22, 16 September 2024 (UTC)
Comments
Vote to retain Good status
Vote to strip Good status
Recon
Object
- The death should include the location and date in a single date note as per modern precedent.
- Looking at the issue page, it says the story takes place in 22 BBY while this differs, would like to see the date investigated to be sure which is accurate.
- Needs a pronouns update.
- Species and gender infobox exclusive.
- Per the layout guide 'The "Affiliations" field of infoboxes shall list sub-bullets to a maximum depth of one.'
- Skin color should be noted.
- Anything that can be noted in a skills/abilities section?
- Needs an equipment section.
- BTS needs to include a full release date and publisher. Lewisr (talk) 00:12, 19 September 2024 (UTC)