FANDOM


[18:58] Ataru: All right. I think we're ready.
[18:58] Ataru: The4dotelipsis; Are you master of ceremonies?
[18:59] The4dotelipsis: Bah!
[18:59] The4dotelipsis: Someone else can do it.
[18:59] Ataru: :-(
[18:59] Ataru: Fine.
[18:59] Xwing328: hehe
[18:59] The4dotelipsis: Yes, you do it.
[18:59] Ataru: I'll do it, since Cull's here.
[18:59] Ataru: Dim greetings everyone
[18:59] Ataru: Make sure the channel isn't invite only
[18:59] *** McEwok (n=McEwok@host81-154-89-136.range81-154.btcentralplus.com) has joined #wookieepedia-inquisitorius.
[18:59] Ataru: First up
[18:59] Ataru: Is the log on?
[18:59] Xwing328: yup
[18:59] Xwing328: always
[19:00] Ataru: Excellent
[19:00] The4dotelipsis: Crud.
[19:00] Ataru: Talon Karrde
[19:00] LordHydronium:  NR and Vong War sections seem really short for the importance the character has. TTT is one short paragraph per book.
[19:00] Ataru: Expansion of YVW needed. Sectioning.
[19:00] Ataru:  TTT?
[19:00] Ataru: nvm
[19:00] Ataru: I get it now
[19:00] Xwing328: I had no objections
[19:00] *** Breathes|shower (n=Susan@cpe-66-25-171-223.austin.res.rr.com) has joined #wookieepedia-inquisitorius.
[19:00] The4dotelipsis: Yeah, real YVW really needs more.
[19:00] LordHydronium: It could use an overall expansion
[19:01] Xwing328: lol - breathes has talent to use the computer while in the shower :P
[19:01] *** Mode change "+o Breathes|shower" for channel #wookieepedia-inquisitorius by Darth_Culator.
[19:01] *** Mode change "+o Breathes|shower" for channel #wookieepedia-inquisitorius by Ataru.
[19:01] The4dotelipsis: Does it cover the galaxies stuff?
[19:01] Ataru: Karrde?
[19:01] Ataru: I don't think so.
[19:01] Xwing328: I wouldn't know
[19:01] The4dotelipsis: Hmm.
[19:01] The4dotelipsis: Needs that too.
[19:01] Ataru: Okay, vote then
[19:01] The4dotelipsis: Remove
[19:01] Breathes|shower: errrrrr
[19:01] LordHydronium: Remove.
[19:01] Ataru: Remove
[19:02] The4dotelipsis: It was too short to begin with, methinks.
[19:02] Xwing328: Only based on you saying it needs more, remove
[19:02] Ataru: StarNeptune present?
[19:02] Ataru: Havac?
[19:02] Breathes|shower: can someone link me really quick?
[19:02] Ataru: Darth_Culator?
[19:02] Darth_Culator: Remove. Rule 9, 12, 14.
[19:02] Breathes|shower: to Karrde?
[19:02] LordHydronium: Neptune voted keep on the Meeting page, but since she's here I don't know if that holds
[19:02] Ataru: (Link: http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Talon_Karrde)http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Talon_Karrde
[19:03] LordHydronium: I mean, if she doesn't respond it stays
[19:03] Havac: I'm not really here.
[19:03] Ataru: Okay.
[19:03] Ataru: Hmm
[19:03] LordHydronium: But since she's here she might change
[19:03] LordHydronium: If she is here.
[19:03] Xwing328: If she doesn't comment in a few, obviously use her earlier vote
[19:03] LordHydronium: Right. So for now it's 5 remove, 1 keep.
[19:03] Ataru: Right
[19:04] LordHydronium: Anyone?
[19:04] Ataru: I need two more votes for removal, or we have no consensus
[19:04] Xwing328: Let's wait for breathes to read
[19:04] Ataru: How about Imp?
[19:04] Ataru: Imperialles?
[19:04] Breathes|shower: so we're saying it could be expanded in the YVW section?
[19:04] Ataru: yees
[19:04] LordHydronium: And the NR section
[19:04] Xwing328: o whoops...lol. I looked at Star's votes for mine. Here's my real ones: Remove (easy fixes). Short Personality, not even P&T (Rule 14). Unsourced quotes (Rule 12).
[19:05] Breathes|shower: I think Remove
[19:05] Ataru: Okay, I need Imp's vote or something
[19:05] LordHydronium: One more needed.
[19:05] LordHydronium: Havac? Imp?
[19:05] Ataru: Jeez, we're going slow today
[19:05] Ataru: Hmmm
[19:06] Havac: Is it sourced?
[19:06] Ataru: yes
[19:06] Breathes|shower: I wonder about Images also, perhaps better use of Images could be made
[19:06] Havac: Heh, remove.
[19:06] Breathes|shower: unsourced quotes though
[19:06] Ataru: Removed. Next.
[19:06] Ataru: Ebenn Q3 Baobab
[19:06] LordHydronium: Sourcing. Smattering of POV ("While admittedly a bit of a braggart, Ebenn Q3 Baobab truly had every right to be so. It was often difficult for New Republic citizens to comprehend the fact that this larger-than-life personality was, in fact, an actual person.") Personality and Traits.
[19:06] Xwing328: Sourcing (Rule 11). No quotes (Rule 13). 2 redlinks (OK by Rule 8). No P&T (Rule 14).
[19:06] Ataru: No P&T. No sourcing.
[19:06] Ataru: No quotes
[19:06] LordHydronium: Oh yeah, lead quote
[19:07] The4dotelipsis: Remove.
[19:07] Ataru: Surely we could get one.
[19:07] Ataru: Remove
[19:07] LordHydronium: Remove.
[19:07] The4dotelipsis: As much as I like this kind of info.
[19:07] *** Xwing328|Busy (n=Xwing328@unaffiliated/xwing328) has joined #wookieepedia-inquisitorius.
[19:07] *** Mode change "+o Xwing328|Busy" for channel #wookieepedia-inquisitorius by ChanServ.
[19:07] The4dotelipsis: I mean, article.
[19:07] LordHydronium: Neptune votes Weak Remove.
[19:08] Ataru: 3 more.
[19:08] *** Xwing328 (n=Xwing328@unaffiliated/xwing328) has signed off IRC (Nick collision from services.).
[19:08] *** Xwing328|Busy is now known as Xwing328.
[19:08] Darth_Culator: Remove. Rule 2, 11, 13, 14.
[19:08] Ataru: 2 more
[19:08] Xwing328: are we still on Ebenn?
[19:08] Ataru: Yes.
[19:08] LordHydronium: yeah
[19:08] Ataru: Do you have a vote?
[19:08] Xwing328: Remove
[19:08] Xwing328: Already listed it b4 I dropped out
[19:08] Breathes|shower: I actually say keep pending sourcing and adding of quotes
[19:08] Ataru: I see.
[19:09] Ataru: With no P&T?
[19:09] The4dotelipsis: Yuhp.
[19:09] Ataru: Interesting.
[19:09] Xwing328: so 3 rules broken...tssk tssk
[19:09] Breathes|shower: whatever. I vote how I want.
[19:09] Xwing328: :)
[19:09] Ataru: Well, I need one more vote for removal or one for keep.
[19:09] Breathes|shower: I mean probationary keep. if that makes sense.
[19:09] Ataru: Havac? Imperialles?
[19:10] Havac: Remove. And how are you typing this from the shower?
[19:10] Xwing328: Breathes|shower - it doesn't get removed for two weeks, following another vote to see if it improved, if that helps
[19:10] Ataru: Article is removed by consensus. Next.
[19:10] Ataru: Carnor Jax
[19:10] LordHydronium: Sourcing. Some images need sourcing. "Though it is suspected that he, along with Kir Kanos, may be a clone grown from the same prime clone, possibly Jax's "father"" is based on a cut idea; remove it. Personality and Traits.
[19:10] Xwing328: Carnor Jax - Remove. Sourcing (Rule 11). Unsourced pics, quotes could be more accurately sourced, from specific issues (Rule 12). No P&T (Rule 14).
[19:10] Ataru: No P&T. No sourcing. Remove merchandise section
[19:11] The4dotelipsis: Per everyone else.
[19:11] Xwing328: yes, remove merchandise to SWMW as well
[19:11] Breathes|shower: remove. per everyone else.
[19:11] LordHydronium: Neptune says: "Remove. Sourcing, several unsourced pics."
[19:11] LordHydronium: Remove
[19:11] Ataru: Vote!
[19:11] Ataru: Remove
[19:12] Xwing328: we already did :P
[19:12] Ataru: I have 5, I think
[19:12] Ataru: 6
[19:12] Darth_Culator: Remove. Rule 11, 12, 14.
[19:12] *** JainaSolo (n=4571a92f@host112.toad-host.com) has joined #wookieepedia-inquisitorius.
[19:12] Ataru: Article removed unless two people want to speak up
[19:12] *** Mode change "+o JainaSolo" for channel #wookieepedia-inquisitorius by Ataru.
[19:12] Ataru: Next
[19:12] Xwing328: Hi Jaina
[19:13] JainaSolo: Hi Xwing328
[19:13] Ataru: Ossus!
[19:13] LordHydronium: Perfect in every way. :P
[19:13] Xwing328: Ossus - Keep. Minor inconsistencies between "linkable" titles of Appearances/Sources and Notes and references.
[19:13] Ataru: Keep
[19:13] LordHydronium: Keep.
[19:13] JainaSolo: Keep
[19:13] The4dotelipsis: Keep
[19:13] Breathes|shower: Keep
[19:13] Ataru: Anyone else want to vote? :-P
[19:13] Darth_Culator: Doesn't seem necessary.
[19:13] Ataru: Not that it matters!
[19:14] Ataru: Article kept.
[19:14] Ataru: Next.
[19:14] Xwing328: Brenn Tantor - Keep. Fix Personality to fit P&T (Rule 14).
[19:14] LordHydronium: Keep.
[19:14] Ataru: Remove sourcing from intro. POV. Capitalization issues.
[19:14] Ataru: Remove
[19:14] Breathes|shower: do we allow sourcing in section titles?
[19:14] LordHydronium: Neptune voted Keep for Ossus and Brenn, BTW.
[19:14] Ataru: Yes
[19:14] Xwing328: Yes, we do allow
[19:15] Ataru: That's at least 3 keeps.
[19:15] Breathes|shower: keep
[19:15] Breathes|shower: yeah
[19:15] JainaSolo: Keep
[19:15] Ataru: Okay. Article kept
[19:15] Ataru: Next.
[19:15] Xwing328: Rune Haako - Keep. File:R Haako.JPG and File:Fake haako.jpg are not sourced (Rule 12).
[19:15] Ataru: Rune Haako
[19:15] LordHydronium: Keep. Some images need sourcing.
[19:16] Ataru: Remove sourcing from intro. Photo caption and P&T contradict each other. Keep
[19:16] The4dotelipsis: Ermm.
[19:16] LordHydronium: Neptune votes keep.
[19:16] The4dotelipsis: Keep.
[19:16] The4dotelipsis: :P
[19:16] The4dotelipsis: But I'll try to adress these problems.
[19:16] Breathes|shower: keep
[19:16] Xwing328: sounds good
[19:16] Ataru: Article kept by consensus.
[19:16] Ataru: Next up
[19:16] * The4dotelipsis whispers under breath "Stupid Chee"
[19:16] Ataru: Nagai-Tof War
[19:16] Xwing328: Nagai-Tof War - Remove. Formatting (Rule 4). Sourcing (Rule 11). Unsourced pics and quote (Rule 12).
[19:16] LordHydronium: Sourcing. I'd like to see some mention of the Hiromi, but that may be a personal bias. :P
[19:16] Ataru: Sourcing.
[19:17] The4dotelipsis: Keep.
[19:17] Ataru: Keep
[19:17] The4dotelipsis: Brainwave!
[19:17] Xwing328: grr...that's 3 rules broken
[19:17] LordHydronium: Remove, but it doesn't matter.
[19:17] Breathes|shower: keep, tag for sourcing
[19:17] The4dotelipsis: When we say Keep, and we've got minor issues with it, we should alert the major author.
[19:17] The4dotelipsis: Directly.
[19:17] Darth_Culator: I want more Hiromi info.
[19:17] LordHydronium: I don't think sourcing is a minor issue, though.
[19:17] Darth_Culator: Lots more.
[19:17] Darth_Culator: HOORAY!
[19:17] Ataru: We decided not to do that a couple meetings ago, IIRC
[19:17] LordHydronium: Let's hear it for the glorious destiny of Culator!
[19:18] LordHydronium: YAAAAAAYYY!
[19:18] Ataru: Darth_Culator: Can you help Hobbes15 get in here via ircatwork?
[19:18] Ataru: Next
[19:18] Ataru: That's 3 keeps, so we're moving on
[19:18] Ataru: Death Star
[19:18] Xwing328: Death Star - Remove. Sourcing (Rule 11). Unsourced pics (Rule 12).
[19:18] LordHydronium: Sourcing.
[19:18] Ataru: Needs pic with intro. Present tense. Sourcing.
[19:18] * Ataru hates present tense in IU articles
[19:19] LordHydronium: Neptune sez: "Sourcing, a couple of unsourced pics. The BTS picture comparing the Death Star to that moon of Saturn is not explained in the text."
[19:19] The4dotelipsis: :S
[19:19] The4dotelipsis: Keep.
[19:19] Ataru: Remove
[19:19] LordHydronium: Remove.
[19:19] Breathes|shower: remove
[19:19] LordHydronium: Neptune votes remove.
[19:19] Ataru: Jaina? Darth_Culator?
[19:19] JainaSolo: Remove
[19:20] LordHydronium: One more needed.
[19:20] Darth_Culator: Hate to say it, but remove. Rule 12, and whatever rule covers a slight excess of interpretation.
[19:20] Ataru: Hmm. I need one more.
[19:20] Xwing328: Remove if you didn't count mine
[19:20] Ataru: Someone speak up or it's removed.
[19:20] Ataru: Removed.
[19:20] Ataru: Next up
[19:20] Ataru: JAR JAR!
[19:20] Xwing328: Jar Jar Binks - Weak remove. Sourcing (Rule 11).
[19:20] LordHydronium: Sourcing. Some info in the top of BtS should go under "Criticism" and "Bullsh-" sorry, "Alleged racism".
[19:20] The4dotelipsis: Remove.
[19:20] Ataru: Sourcing. Speculation "Skywalker appreciated his help" "wife" part is speculation. Maybe a little POV
[19:20] The4dotelipsis: Basically, the BTS is in a shit-load of trouble.
[19:20] The4dotelipsis: And I'm going to have to ax a lot of it.
[19:21] Ataru: What does Star say?
[19:21] Ataru: Remve
[19:21] Ataru: *Remove
[19:21] Ataru: Star says Weak remove
[19:21] LordHydronium: SN: "Weak remove. The only issue is sourcing."
[19:21] The4dotelipsis: Hopefully I can get it up to scratch.
[19:21] LordHydronium: Remove
[19:21] Breathes|shower: weak remove-sourcing, BtS
[19:21] Ataru: 5
[19:22] JainaSolo: Remove
[19:22] *** Hobbes154 (n=hobbes15@c-24-131-128-231.hsd1.nh.comcast.net) has joined #wookieepedia-inquisitorius.
[19:22] Ataru: 6
[19:22] Ataru: hello
[19:22] Ataru: Anyone else?
[19:22] Ataru: Or am I counting wrong?
[19:22] Havac: Remove
[19:22] Ataru: We have 7
[19:22] Ataru: 8
[19:22] Darth_Culator: Yeah, what they said.
[19:22] Ataru: Article is removed
[19:22] Ataru: 9!
[19:22] Ataru: Hate on Jar Jar! :-P
[19:22] Ataru: Next!
[19:22] Ataru: Bria Tharen
[19:22] LordHydronium: Some POV in P/T ("It is, however, a testament to her inner strength").
[19:23] Ataru: Remove sourcing from intro
[19:23] The4dotelipsis: Keep
[19:23] Breathes|shower: better sectioning needed
[19:23] Ataru: Keep
[19:23] Darth_Culator: Bria has minor issues, but keepable.
[19:23] LordHydronium: Keep.
[19:23] The4dotelipsis: Damn these women and their inconsistent appearances!
[19:23] Xwing328: unless more complaints come, keep
[19:23] LordHydronium: SN says keep.
[19:23] Breathes|shower: but... I think.... keep
[19:23] JainaSolo: Keep
[19:23] Ataru: a whole bunch of keeps to 1 remove.
[19:23] Ataru: Article is kept.
[19:23] Ataru: Next
[19:23] Havac: REMOVE, because someone must be the voice of hatred!
[19:23] The4dotelipsis: Hmm.
[19:23] Ataru: Nute Gunray
[19:23] LordHydronium: Sourcing.
[19:23] Xwing328: Nute Gunray - Weak remove. Sourcing (Rule 11).
[19:24] Breathes|shower: remove.
[19:24] Ataru: Sourcing. Sectioning.
[19:24] LordHydronium: Neptune says...well, exactly the same thing as X.
[19:24] Ataru: Remove
[19:24] The4dotelipsis: Say Remove, because that gives me the incentive to fix him up.
[19:24] Breathes|shower: excessive quoting, sourcing
[19:24] Xwing328: lol - where do you think I got it?
[19:24] Ataru: 4 so far
[19:24] LordHydronium: Remove
[19:24] Ataru: 5
[19:24] Ataru: Jaina? Culator?
[19:24] Ataru: Imp? Havac?
[19:24] The4dotelipsis: Hmm.
[19:25] JainaSolo: Remove
[19:25] Ataru: 6!
[19:25] The4dotelipsis: Will I be breaking 3 RR if I restore the "This is Impossible!" quote?
[19:25] Havac: Remove
[19:25] Xwing328: You could bribe one of us to do it 4dot
[19:25] The4dotelipsis: Well, the other guy's already broken it.
[19:25] Ataru: Article is removed
[19:25] The4dotelipsis: Yeah, one of you guys do it.
[19:25] Xwing328: BAN HIM! :P
[19:25] The4dotelipsis: On grounds of, it's a better quote.
[19:25] Ataru: Meh
[19:26] Ataru: Article is removed.
[19:26] Ataru: Next
[19:26] Ataru: Drovian
[19:26] The4dotelipsis: Remove.
[19:26] The4dotelipsis: I want a government section, dammit!
[19:26] *** LucidFox (n=LucidFox@wikia/Sikon) has joined #wookieepedia-inquisitorius.
[19:26] LordHydronium: Neptune says keep.
[19:26] Breathes|shower: Keep
[19:26] Ataru: Keep
[19:26] LordHydronium: Keep
[19:26] The4dotelipsis: Bah!
[19:26] Xwing328: Keep unless other objections
[19:27] Ataru: That's 4 keeps to 1 remove.
[19:27] Ataru: make that 5 keeps
[19:27] Ataru: Article is kept!
[19:27] Xwing328: That was fast, considering the slow start
[19:27] Ataru: Next item on the agenda
[19:27] Ataru: Final votes on various articles
[19:27] Ataru: First up
[19:27] Ataru: Jacen Solo
[19:27] LordHydronium: (Link: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Jacen_Solo&diff=cur&oldid=1214424)http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Jacen_Solo&diff=cur&oldid=1214424
[19:27] Ataru: (Link: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Jacen_Solo&diff=cur&oldid=1214424)http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Jacen_Solo&diff=cur&oldid=1214424
[19:27] Ataru: durn
[19:28] LordHydronium: OK, I'll leave it to you. :P
[19:28] Ataru: lol
[19:28] The4dotelipsis: Remove.
[19:28] The4dotelipsis: Sectioning is still shit.
[19:28] Ataru: # ectioning
[19:28] Ataru: # Speculation in childhood section
[19:28] Ataru: # Condensing, too much play-by-play, particularly: Trivia in Reunion section, abductions, 1st Corellian Insurrection, Vergere
[19:28] Ataru: # More detail on Vong war
[19:28] Ataru: # Certain prose issues, particularly in "Vergere" section
[19:28] Ataru: # Personality and Traits section.
[19:28] Ataru: That's what we said was wrong with it
[19:28] The4dotelipsis: Well, the sectioning is not fixed.
[19:28] The4dotelipsis: So, Darth Who, see you later.
[19:29] Ataru: No, it's not.
[19:29] Breathes|shower: hey guys
[19:29] Ataru: yes?
[19:29] Breathes|shower: now that we've finished the mian voting, i really need to go
[19:29] LordHydronium: The Vergere section is still ick.
[19:29] Ataru: okay
[19:29] Ataru: Later Breathes!
[19:29] Breathes|shower: I'm screwed for class this week... like really really screwed
[19:29] Breathes|shower: later!
[19:29] *** Breathes|shower (n=Susan@cpe-66-25-171-223.austin.res.rr.com) has left #wookieepedia-inquisitorius.
[19:29] *** Xwing328|Busy (n=Xwing328@unaffiliated/xwing328) has joined #wookieepedia-inquisitorius.
[19:29] *** Mode change "+o Xwing328|Busy" for channel #wookieepedia-inquisitorius by ChanServ.
[19:29] Ataru: Interesting.
[19:29] Ataru: Ok, so vote on Jacen.
[19:29] The4dotelipsis: Remove
[19:29] Ataru: JainaSolo: No favoritism just because he's your bro! :-P
[19:29] *** Cull_Tremayne (n=howlrunn@dhcp80ffbc3f.residence-rooms.uiowa.edu) has joined #wookieepedia-inquisitorius.
[19:30] The4dotelipsis: Ben!
[19:30] *** Mode change "+o Cull_Tremayne" for channel #wookieepedia-inquisitorius by Ataru.
[19:30] The4dotelipsis: Dagobah System!
[19:30] Ataru: lol
[19:30] Ataru: Vote to remove Jacen now!
[19:30] Ataru: remove
[19:30] JainaSolo: Ataru: lol
[19:30] JainaSolo: Remove
[19:30] Ataru: 3 . . .
[19:30] Ataru: Xwing328, LordHydronium, Cull_Tremayne, Darth_Culator,
[19:30] Cull_Tremayne: Die another Day! With a Vengeance!
[19:30] Ataru: StarNeptune
[19:30] Cull_Tremayne: Err... Remove?
[19:30] Ataru: Imperialles
[19:30] LordHydronium: Yeah, I'll go with remove. Once it's cleaned up, it can be renommed.
[19:31] Ataru: (Link: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Jacen_Solo&diff=cur&oldid=1214424)http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Jacen_Solo&diff=cur&oldid=1214424
[19:31] Darth_Culator: Remove.
[19:31] LordHydronium: Neptune said keep.
[19:31] Ataru: 6
[19:31] Ataru: 6 to 1
[19:31] Ataru: Xwing328?
[19:31] Cull_Tremayne: Wow, we're already to reassessments?
[19:31] Ataru: yep
[19:31] Ataru: I'll post summary at the end. Everything will make sense
[19:31] Ataru: Havac?
[19:31] Ataru: We need one more vote either way
[19:32] Havac: About what?
[19:32] Ataru: Voting to remove Jacen Solo.
[19:32] LordHydronium: Whether Jacen stays
[19:32] * The4dotelipsis clobbers Ataru over the head with an Inflatable Forklift.
[19:32] Ataru: Forever
[19:32] Havac: I'm really paying no attention here.
[19:32] Ataru: Bah!
[19:32] Havac: Remove.
[19:32] Ataru: Removed.
[19:32] Ataru: Next.
[19:32] The4dotelipsis: Good.
[19:32] Ataru: Mara Jade
[19:32] Ataru: (Link: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Mara_Jade_Skywalker&diff=cur&oldid=1214427)http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Mara_Jade_Skywalker&diff=cur&oldid=1214427
[19:32] LordHydronium: No sourcing. Remove.
[19:33] LordHydronium: And a bunch of other stuff.
[19:33] The4dotelipsis: Sorry Shannon.
[19:33] Ataru: We said     * Sourcing. Quote and image sourcing.
[19:33] Ataru:     * Minor formatting (e.g. section capitalization)
[19:33] Ataru:     * More Allegiance detail. More detail on: 1st and 2nd Corellian Insurrections, Vong war, Hand of Thrawn.
[19:33] Ataru:     * Choice of images for Allegiance.
[19:33] The4dotelipsis: You're well equipped, but obviously not enough to source yourself.
[19:33] Ataru:     * Cleanup of Dark Nest.
[19:33] Ataru:     * Poor writing in personality and Traits section.
[19:33] Ataru:     * POV (e.g. "Mara was a witty character")
[19:33] Ataru:     * BTS largely speculation, remove products section, remove Mary Sue statements.
[19:33] Ataru:     * "Mara's ships" either goes entirely or gets expanded.
[19:33] Cull_Tremayne: Let's skip the next five. Since nothing was done.
[19:33] Ataru: Very little was done
[19:33] Ataru: Nothing was?
[19:33] Ataru: Vote on Mara.
[19:33] Ataru: Remove
[19:34] Darth_Culator: Remove.
[19:34] The4dotelipsis: Bahlete
[19:34] Cull_Tremayne: For the next five following Mara.
[19:34] Cull_Tremayne: Remove for Mara.
[19:34] LordHydronium: Remove on Mara, and everything up to Asajj. Haven't looked past that yet.
[19:34] JainaSolo: Remove
[19:34] Ataru: That's 5
[19:34] Ataru: *6
[19:35] Cull_Tremayne: Remove for Clone Wars as well, stuff was just moved around and the list removed. No sourcing done.
[19:35] Ataru: Havac?
[19:35] The4dotelipsis: Erm.
[19:35] The4dotelipsis: For the record, I say remove on every single one.
[19:35] The4dotelipsis: Just in case you miss me one one.
[19:35] Havac: I'm voting remove on everything.
[19:35] Ataru: Okay
[19:35] Ataru: It's removed
[19:35] *** Xwing328|FOOD (n=Xwing328@unaffiliated/xwing328) has joined #wookieepedia-inquisitorius.
[19:35] LordHydronium: Yeah, death to Clone Wars for the sourcing.
[19:35] *** Mode change "+o Xwing328|FOOD" for channel #wookieepedia-inquisitorius by ChanServ.
[19:35] Ataru: Nothing done on Freedon Nadd.
[19:35] Xwing328|FOOD: bloody hell again
[19:35] Cull_Tremayne: No sourcing for Ferus as well.
[19:35] Ataru: I'm assuming remove?
[19:36] *** Xwing328 (n=Xwing328@unaffiliated/xwing328) has signed off IRC (Nick collision from services.).
[19:36] *** Xwing328|Busy (n=Xwing328@unaffiliated/xwing328) has signed off IRC (Nick collision from services.).
[19:36] *** Xwing328|FOOD is now known as Xwing328.
[19:36] LordHydronium: No sourcing on Ferus, nothing done to Tahiri; klill both
[19:36] Cull_Tremayne: Same with Tahiri.
[19:36] Ataru: One at a time
[19:36] LordHydronium: Or kill them, even
[19:36] Ataru: ONE AT A TIME
[19:36] Cull_Tremayne: Why? Nothing was done on these.
[19:36] Ataru: Nadd removed
[19:36] Xwing328: link to one?
[19:36] Cull_Tremayne: Vote to remove all the rest?
[19:36] LordHydronium: Aye.
[19:36] Ataru: Ok
[19:36] Ataru: Maul removed
[19:37] Ataru: Plo Koon removed
[19:37] Xwing328: assuming nothing's been done
[19:37] Ataru: 2nd Imperium removed
[19:37] Ataru: If nothing's been done, it's removed
[19:37] Cull_Tremayne: No sourcing, and very little done, except for on Ferus, and that's a mess in itself.
[19:37] Ataru: How about Asajj?
[19:37] Cull_Tremayne: Nada.
[19:37] Ataru: Remove
[19:37] LordHydronium: Nothing substantial.
[19:37] LordHydronium: Remove.
[19:37] Ataru: Asajj removed, I think.
[19:38] Ataru: Clone Wars
[19:38] LordHydronium: remove
[19:38] Ataru: Remove
[19:38] Ataru: 4dot and Havac vote remove
[19:38] Darth_Culator: Kill.
[19:38] Ataru: that's 5
[19:38] Ataru: What does Star say?
[19:38] LordHydronium: remove
[19:38] Ataru: That's 6
[19:39] LordHydronium: Cull said above to remove all
[19:39] Ataru: oh
[19:39] Cull_Tremayne: Damn, never got around to sourcing Jax and N-T War bummer. :-{
[19:39] Ataru: 7 then
[19:39] LordHydronium: Cull: 2 weeks!
[19:39] Ataru: Removed
[19:39] Ataru: Next
[19:39] Ataru: Ferus
[19:39] LordHydronium: Remove.
[19:39] Ataru: If you notice, Hobbes154 is here.
[19:39] Ataru: He's been working on it.
[19:39] Ataru: I say give him another week
[19:39] Ataru: He started what, three days ago?
[19:40] The4dotelipsis: Too bad!
[19:40] Xwing328: Cruelty
[19:40] Ataru: hmm, okay
[19:40] Ataru: remove
[19:40] Cull_Tremayne: Sorry, no freebees.
[19:40] The4dotelipsis: Although kudos for the removal of that "crimson bladed lightsaber!"
[19:40] Darth_Culator: We don't have any provision for extending the probation period.
[19:40] Ataru: and especially "Jedi padawan vs. Sith wannabe"
[19:40] Ataru: True
[19:40] Xwing328: Hey, I'd give him a chance....but whatever
[19:40] The4dotelipsis: I was tempted to put the whole article up for VFD just for that.
[19:40] Darth_Culator: So, remove.
[19:40] LordHydronium: Once it's improved, it can be renommed.
[19:40] Cull_Tremayne: He can be the first one to bring back an FA.
[19:40] Ataru: Very true
[19:40] The4dotelipsis: Yes.
[19:40] Darth_Culator: That would be neat.
[19:40] The4dotelipsis: Jolly for him.
[19:40] Xwing328: yes
[19:40] LordHydronium: But it has no sourcing right now, for one thing
[19:40] Xwing328: get a cookiee for that maybe too :P
[19:41] Ataru: Article removed. Keep up the good work Hobbes154, and we'll see Ferus on the nom page in a tick.
[19:41] Ataru: Next
[19:41] The4dotelipsis: Yeah...
[19:41] Ataru: Tahiri
[19:41] LordHydronium: Nada to Tahiri, remove.
[19:41] Ataru: Remove
[19:41] The4dotelipsis: Ferus seems to be everywhere.
[19:41] Ataru: I have 5 removes on Tahiri
[19:41] Ataru: Jaina?
[19:41] Ataru: Culator?
[19:41] Ataru: Xwing?
[19:41] JainaSolo: Remove
[19:41] Xwing328: Remove...
[19:42] Darth_Culator: Minimal improvement. Remove.
[19:42] Ataru: Okay
[19:42] Ataru: Removed
[19:42] Ataru: Next item on the agenda.
[19:42] Ataru: How are we going to run subsequent meetings?
[19:42] Cull_Tremayne: Further meetings...
[19:42] Ataru: How often?
[19:42] Ataru: How many articles?
[19:42] *** Hobbes154 (n=hobbes15@c-24-131-128-231.hsd1.nh.comcast.net) has signed off IRC (Client Quit).
[19:42] LordHydronium: Well, we still need to vote on the previous two probation rounds in the upcoming weeks.
[19:42] The4dotelipsis: I refuse to Inq an article still on the queue.
[19:42] Xwing328: How many more articles do we have?
[19:42] Cull_Tremayne: We should probably run two more weekly meetings, just to make sure we go over the probationary FAs.
[19:43] Cull_Tremayne: Xwing: None.
[19:43] Xwing328: k
[19:43] Ataru: None not on the queue, IIRC
[19:43] Xwing328: than at least 2 more to finish off the probations, yes
[19:43] Ataru: Okay, so two more weekly meetings.
[19:43] LordHydronium: And we'll just be doing probations, then?
[19:43] Ataru: I think so
[19:43] Cull_Tremayne: Should go quick. :-P
[19:43] Ataru: We won't have any others to do.
[19:44] Ataru: After that, we may move to monthly meetings or whatever
[19:44] Cull_Tremayne: We can talk about further meetings in the next two meetings. :-P
[19:44] Ataru: Okay.
[19:44] Ataru: Next up
[19:44] Ataru: FA noms
[19:44] The4dotelipsis: Noms!
[19:44] Ataru: Vote to remove HK?
[19:44] Cull_Tremayne: "Rock us Dukakus!"
[19:44] LordHydronium: I've been lazy, but I'll read the new ones this weekend.
[19:44] The4dotelipsis: HK?
[19:44] The4dotelipsis: Yeah, it's been there for ages.
[19:44] The4dotelipsis: And no sign of progress.
[19:44] Ataru: HK-47 nom.
[19:44] Cull_Tremayne: Is anyone moving to source him? Then he should be gone.
[19:45] Ataru: Not much progress. Remove
[19:45] *** McEwok (n=McEwok@host81-154-89-136.range81-154.btcentralplus.com) has left #wookieepedia-inquisitorius.
[19:45] Ataru: I see 3 removes
[19:45] Ataru: Anyone else?
[19:45] LordHydronium: HK seems to have hit a standstill.
[19:45] Darth_Culator: +1
[19:45] LordHydronium: Sure, why not
[19:45] Ataru: 5
[19:45] Xwing328: sure
[19:45] Ataru: 6
[19:45] Ataru: Jaina?
[19:45] Cull_Tremayne: Have to say Remove. No one's bothering to source him, and he's the last article to "not fall under the new rules" Remove.
[19:45] JainaSolo: Remove
[19:46] Ataru: 7
[19:46] Ataru: Nom removed
[19:46] Ataru: Haunted Village. Hrm
[19:46] The4dotelipsis: Out.
[19:46] The4dotelipsis: No signs of improvement.
[19:46] The4dotelipsis: For ages.
[19:46] The4dotelipsis: The plot summary is a disgrace.
[19:46] Xwing328: bye bye to it
[19:46] Ataru: Eyrezer isn't here to defend it so . . .
[19:46] Ataru: remove
[19:46] Ataru: 3 . . .
[19:47] Ataru: Cull_Tremayne?
[19:47] Ataru: Darth_Culator?
[19:47] LordHydronium: At that rate of votes, it's probably not going anywhere
[19:47] Ataru: JainaSolo?
[19:47] LordHydronium: Sure
[19:47] Cull_Tremayne: Eh. It was brought up February 20th. Remove.
[19:47] Ataru: LordHydronium?
[19:47] Darth_Culator: Baleete.
[19:47] Ataru: 6
[19:47] Ataru: Havac?
[19:47] Ataru: Anyone else?
[19:47] JainaSolo: Remove
[19:47] Ataru: 7
[19:47] Ataru: nom removed
[19:48] Ataru: Next up: Carth
[19:48] The4dotelipsis: Keep.
[19:48] Ataru: Carth is pretty god
[19:48] The4dotelipsis: It's fairly recent.
[19:48] Ataru: *good
[19:48] Ataru: Remember, we can also vote to approve noms here.
[19:48] LordHydronium: Keep, but Imp needs to find the damn rule that lets him object on the grounds of specific references.
[19:48] Ataru: In this case, that may be in order
[19:48] Cull_Tremayne: I think people are misunderstanding what sourcing is. Sourcing everything from the NEC isn't sourcing.
[19:48] The4dotelipsis: Sure it is.
[19:48] The4dotelipsis: ;)
[19:48] Ataru: Carth is barely in NEC>
[19:48] The4dotelipsis: Oh, right.
[19:48] Xwing328: only if everything sourced really is in NEC
[19:49] Ataru: And NEC is pretty much awesome.
[19:49] The4dotelipsis: Why don't they just use KOTOR?
[19:49] Ataru: I dunno.
[19:49] The4dotelipsis: Easy.
[19:49] Cull_Tremayne: Well since Selkath was obviously just making up information...
[19:49] Ataru: Inq page needs some votes or someting
[19:49] Xwing328: then tell me what to vote on
[19:49] Ataru: (Link: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Inq:Carth_Onasi&t=20070331034506)http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Inq:Carth_Onasi&t=20070331034506
[19:49] Xwing328: :P
[19:50] Ataru: I guess this would be a vote for approval
[19:50] Ataru: I'm not going to put too many up for removal- they're all recent and in progress
[19:50] The4dotelipsis: No.
[19:50] The4dotelipsis: But do lets talk about them.
[19:50] Ataru: Basically, unless there's a nom someone wants to remove.
[19:50] Ataru: I'm fine with Carth
[19:50] Cull_Tremayne: Remove Human.
[19:50] The4dotelipsis: Oxygen and Human are tempting.
[19:50] Ataru: Yes, remove Human
[19:50] Xwing328: At a very quick glance, approve Carth
[19:51] The4dotelipsis: But effort is actually being made with Human.
[19:51] The4dotelipsis: Sourcing is in progesst.
[19:51] Ataru: Well fine.
[19:51] The4dotelipsis: *progess.
[19:51] Ataru: If Sourcing is in progress, then keep it
[19:51] Darth_Culator: We should probably kill oxygen.
[19:51] Ataru: And Sio Bibble
[19:51] Cull_Tremayne: Fine, remove Oxygen. :-P
[19:51] Darth_Culator: Unlike Jon, that was a WP:POINT violation.
[19:51] The4dotelipsis: Eh?
[19:51] Xwing328: kill oxygen, despite improvement
[19:51] Ataru: Remove Oxygen
[19:51] The4dotelipsis: Sio Bibble is totally within the rules at the moment.
[19:51] LordHydronium: Yeah, definitely remove oxygen
[19:51] Darth_Culator: Bibble can stay.
[19:51] Xwing328: Bibble seems fine, yeah
[19:51] Cull_Tremayne: It's not under 1000? Eh.
[19:51] Ataru: Bah!
[19:51] Darth_Culator: Mainly because I love his name so damn much.
[19:51] Ataru: 1000 word limit violated!
[19:52] LordHydronium: Bibble can stay, even if I don't vote for it. :P
[19:52] Ataru: I won't vote for it.
[19:52] The4dotelipsis: 1000 Word limit is not policy.
[19:52] The4dotelipsis: And I'll expand him.
[19:52] Darth_Culator: Yet.
[19:52] The4dotelipsis: Soon.
[19:52] Ataru: At least not until that new policy gets implemented
[19:52] The4dotelipsis: Plus.
[19:52] The4dotelipsis: He's Oliver Ford Davies.
[19:52] LordHydronium: Which is why nobody's officially objecting yet.
[19:52] Ataru: Okay, so vote to remove Oxygen is . . .
[19:52] The4dotelipsis: And he has a kick ass beard.
[19:52] Darth_Culator: Remove oxygen!
[19:52] Xwing328: Remove
[19:52] The4dotelipsis: Anyone wanna talk about Burl?
[19:52] LordHydronium: Oxygen should have been removed before it went up
[19:52] * Darth_Culator asphyxiates.
[19:52] The4dotelipsis: :P
[19:52] Darth_Culator: Maybe that was a bad idea.
[19:52] Ataru: I have 5 to remove oxygen
[19:52] Xwing328: I want more info on Burl's SW stuff!
[19:53] Ataru: 6
[19:53] Cull_Tremayne: I ended with "eh". That should be enough to say that it wasn't a formal objection. :-P
[19:53] Xwing328: Anyone with caravan do it now!
[19:53] Ataru: Per Xwing
[19:53] The4dotelipsis: I've added more information on Burl's stuff.
[19:53] Ataru: I still only  have 6 to remove Oxygen
[19:53] Xwing328: orly?
[19:53] The4dotelipsis: Sorry, Caravan of Courage info.
[19:53] * Xwing328 goes to look
[19:53] Ataru: JainaSolo? Imperialles?
[19:53] Darth_Culator: There's not much info to be had outside the realm of (dramatic sting) Original Research.
[19:53] The4dotelipsis: And I'm going to upload a .ogg file of his narration.
[19:53] Ataru: He did add some
[19:53] * Ataru is still waiting on the oxygen vote
[19:53] The4dotelipsis: That's all I can add.
[19:53] LordHydronium: Incidentally, people who make objections: Strike them out when they're filled!
[19:53] JainaSolo: Remove
[19:53] The4dotelipsis: Remove oxygen.
[19:53] The4dotelipsis: But if someone did it properly, I would support it.
[19:53] Ataru: I have 7 now :-)
[19:54] Ataru: Nom removed
[19:54] Xwing328: 4dot - is a quote possible from Burl's narration?
[19:54] The4dotelipsis: Jaymach and Evil Doll's objections for Burl Ives are not legit.
[19:54] The4dotelipsis: Xwing328: I'm going to do that as soon as this is all over.
[19:54] LordHydronium: Jaymach's is a legit objection, but it's factually incorrect
[19:54] Xwing328: ok
[19:54] Ataru: I'll strike Evir's in a minute, I think
[19:54] The4dotelipsis: Jaymach's does not apply to Burl.
[19:54] The4dotelipsis: He doesn't have "Official sources"
[19:55] LordHydronium: Sure he does. They're not LFL official, though. :P
[19:55] The4dotelipsis: So what?
[19:55] LordHydronium: I mean, you didn't get your info from speculation
[19:55] Xwing328: We should bug LFL to get some info about him :P
[19:55] LordHydronium: I'm saying that's fine, 4dot.
[19:55] The4dotelipsis: You can't apply the same blanket policies to a different type of article.
[19:55] The4dotelipsis: Oh, OK.
[19:55] Ataru: I can see Chee rolling his eyes now
[19:55] The4dotelipsis: Chee can roll his eyes all he wants.
[19:55] The4dotelipsis: He's a madman.
[19:55] LordHydronium: All that that item means is that the info must be officially verifiable.
[19:55] Cull_Tremayne: Chee has eyes?
[19:55] Ataru: Okay, so basically on Burl- there's two CTs relevant to us
[19:55] LordHydronium: And your info is, since you cite it
[19:56] Ataru: (Link: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Forum:Additional_FA_rule_suggestion&t=20070407221101)http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Forum:Additional_FA_rule_suggestion&t=20070407221101
[19:56] The4dotelipsis: So Jaymach can be struck.
[19:56] The4dotelipsis: Again.
[19:56] Ataru: (Link: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Forum:FA_reform_proposal&t=20070407220710)http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Forum:FA_reform_proposal&t=20070407220710
[19:56] Ataru: No, I don't think he can
[19:56] The4dotelipsis: Btw, KEJ's proposed policy would not affect Burl Ives in any way shape or form.
[19:56] Ataru: Our rules don't allow us to strike rules-based objections
[19:56] The4dotelipsis: It's the 3rd option that would damage Burl.
[19:56] Ataru: Even incorrect ones
[19:56] The4dotelipsis: It's not rules based.
[19:56] Ataru: (Link: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Forum:Real-world_biographies&t=20070407113729)http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Forum:Real-world_biographies&t=20070407113729
[19:56] Xwing328: GA prereq. is the only real close call right now
[19:56] Ataru: Yes, it is
[19:57] LordHydronium: Yes, it is, it's just factually incorrect.
[19:57] The4dotelipsis: Bah!
[19:57] LordHydronium: He's making an objection to something that's satisfied
[19:57] The4dotelipsis: We'll just ignore it then.
[19:57] Ataru: Official sources is a rule. It's just factually incorrect. No strike
[19:57] Ataru: Bah!
[19:57] LordHydronium: Do we have any rules on that?
[19:57] Ataru: Of course, if he's as stubborn as usual . .
[19:57] Ataru: LH: No.
[19:57] The4dotelipsis: (Link: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Forum:Real-world_biographies&t=20070407113729)http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Forum:Real-world_biographies&t=20070407113729 - We will soon.
[19:57] The4dotelipsis: Maybe.
[19:57] Ataru: Only if he's absent for awhile
[19:57] LordHydronium: So if I wanted to block a fully referenced article by saying "It's not referenced", nothing could stop me?
[19:57] Ataru: (Link: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Forum:Renomination_of_featured_articles_%28again%29&t=20070407221238)http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Forum:Renomination_of_featured_articles_%28again%29&t=20070407221238
[19:57] LordHydronium: That's retarded.
[19:58] Ataru: LH: Yes, it is, but no it isn't.
[19:58] Ataru: because "POV" is hard to define.
[19:58] Ataru: I could disagree with someone's definition of POV.
[19:58] LordHydronium: Sure it is. People shouldn't be able to object based on a lie.
[19:58] Cull_Tremayne: Hey, who was that Jedi priest in Union?
[19:58] Ataru: That way, we're prevented from striking objections.
[19:58] The4dotelipsis: He's just being obstructionist.
[19:58] Ataru: That he is
[19:58] The4dotelipsis: He doesn't want to see us broaden our scope.
[19:58] LordHydronium: POV is opinion, though. Verifiable info is objective.
[19:58] Xwing328: That one's good to close, the renomination one
[19:58] The4dotelipsis: LH is right.
[19:59] Ataru: Yeah, it's been two weeks.
[19:59] * Xwing328 is going to close it now. 2 weeks is up
[19:59] Cull_Tremayne: Anyway, I want a closer eye put on Shaelas or whatever his name is. That NEC thing kinda scares me. Where was it from? Oh just put NEC.
[19:59] Ataru: Let's close that thread.
[19:59] Ataru: Hmm. Okay.
[19:59] Ataru: Thanks for the heads-up.
[19:59] LordHydronium: If I wanted to and I were a dick, I could just make up any old crap and object to it if I didn't like an article.
[19:59] Ataru: Is there any other business before this body?
[19:59] LordHydronium: "Mount Sorrow? Sorry, it, er, doesn't have any images."
[20:00] Ataru: If not, I'll post the summary in a minute or two. Unless someone else wants to.
[20:00] Cull_Tremayne: We need to make sure that people don't put made up crap into the articles and then source them with a big book.
[20:00] Ataru: Nothing wrong with sourcing from a reference book.
[20:00] Ataru: Nothing against it
[20:00] The4dotelipsis: No official Inq business, I would just like some opinions of people here before you all leave.
[20:00] Ataru: As long as its in the big book
[20:00] The4dotelipsis: It's not.
[20:00] The4dotelipsis: That's the issue.
[20:00] Ataru: Right
[20:00] The4dotelipsis: Anyway...
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.

Fandom may earn an affiliate commission on sales made from links on this page.

Stream the best stories.

Fandom may earn an affiliate commission on sales made from links on this page.

Get Disney+